Slavery reparations: The case for historical acknowledgement, not compensation
At the Commonwealth Heads of Government Summit, Caribbean and African nations reiterated their calls for reparations regarding slavery. While Britain expresses sorrow over past injustices, it firmly rejects financial compensation for these claims....

The issue of reparations raises uncomfortable moral and economic questions. Why should prosperous Caribbean countries receive compensation, when they are vastly richer than the African countries from which their enslaved ancestors came? And why should African countries receive compensation when African rulers and merchants themselves captured and sold the slaves?

Why should Europeans who never owned slaves compensate Caribbeans who have never been enslaved? Because, say the Caribbeans, they have been economically scarred by slavery, which has held up their development, and so they merit reparations. There is no evidence that scarring held them back compared to their original African regions. Let nobody claim slavery gave the Caribbeans an advantage. Neither should we go to the other extreme and justify reparations.
Some Caribbean countries have not opted for complete independence and remain British Overseas Territories with the British king as their sovereign. They have fared fantastically well. Their per capita incomes are inflated by banking profits. But their continuing institutional association with Britain helped greatly.
Europeans did not invent slavery. It existed for millennia in Africa, Asia, Europe and in West Asia. African kingdoms enslaved fellow Africans long before Europeans entered the Atlantic trade. Indeed, North Africans enslaved more than a million Europeans.
During the transatlantic trade, African gangs captured slaves and transported them to coastal markets. Europeans purchased them, shipped them across the Atlantic and exploited them on plantations. European demand encouraged further enslavement at unprecedented rates. Both sides bear historical responsibility. Why, then, demand compensation only from European purchasers and not the African suppliers?
Although Christianity had tolerated slavery for centuries, British clergymen like William Wilberforce persuaded their government to abolish slavery. Britain subsequently used gunboats to squash the slave trade of others, capturing over 1,600 slave ships and liberating 150,000 Africans.
Today's universal rejection of slavery is a historical achievement, reversing an earlier global consensus. Britain's role in this transformation must be acknowledged alongside the horrors of slavery.

Why this spectacular divergence? The biggest reason was creation of strong institutions in most colonies, but their collapse in Haiti. Its revolution destroyed the plantation regime but also disrupted production and administration. Subsequent history featured political instability, dictatorship, weak public institutions and recurrent violence. Today, criminal gangs dominate the country, and the state seems helpless to combat them.
The task of Haiti's revolutionaries was made difficult by European countries refusing to buy its sugar until it compensated white plantation owners. France imposed an enormous indemnity in 1825 to compensate former slaveowners. Debt servicing, international isolation, foreign intervention and natural disasters compounded Haiti's difficulties. This spurred the deterioration of institutions. Haiti never recovered.
Other Caribbean countries inherited good administrative and legal institutions. They have parliamentary democracy, independent courts, decent education and health, and good commercial institutions.
Slavery was a colonial institution. But after its abolition, the same colonialists brought in new institutions based on liberty, equality and fraternity. Indeed, institutional development was far better in the Caribbean than in the African colonies from which Black Caribbeans came. That fueled prosperity.
Africa's post-colonial performance has been poor. Many countries have suffered coups, authoritarian rule, corruption and weak institutions. As in Haiti, mere independence from colonial rule has not ensured prosperity. The uncomfortable lesson is that slave trade alone cannot explain contemporary income differences. Institutions, governance and economic policies have profoundly influenced whether former slave societies became prosperous or remained poor.
There is a strong moral case for acknowledging historical atrocities, both by African slave catchers and European buyers. But there's none for reparations.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.