India's economic model needs a demand-side pivot, not another round of supply-side reforms
Narendra Modi criticized Indian corporations for not creating jobs after substantial corporate tax reductions. The focus on supply-side reforms since 1991 has led to disappointing outcomes in economic growth. While financial markets have performed...

Over the years, there has been much over-promise and under-delivery around storied supply-side 'reform' interventions. Pundits said GST would add 1-2% to GDP growth. After a decade of GST, there's no break from pre-GST trend. Openness to foreign capital was supposed to create technology-access. India's one of the most open Asian economies in terms of foreign ownership across sectors. Yet, critical technology access remains a moving mirage.
Free trade was meant to create market access. Three decades of WTO membership and numerous FTAs later, India's market share in global trade remains painfully low. Corporate tax cuts were supposed to spur private investment. Not only has that remained static, but India's private corporate sector invested shockingly pitiful amounts in R&D just when a wave of technology-gating is sweeping the world.
It's good to compare Indian outcomes against the rest of Asia to get a sense of relative utility of the current supply-side approach. There is much self-congratulation of post-liberalisation India outcomes. But a closer scrutiny of numbers would make the assessment more sobering. India's per-capita GDP growth, in constant (2015) dollar terms, in the last 10 years has been 4.8%, growing from $1,500 to $2,500.
Using the same take-off point ($1,500), India is only at the median range of the Asian pack. South Korea grew at over 9% for a decade after crossing $1,500, China over 8%, Thailand nearly 6%. From the time credible data has been available, Japan ($6,400) and Singapore ($3,600) had already crossed that mark. Yet, both grew faster from the higher take-off point, at 8% and 7%, respectively.
To be sure, one place where current strategy has paid off handsomely is in financial markets. Financialisation has rapidly increased; markets infrastructure and regulations are world-class; and Indian corporate sector has demonstrated a level of capital efficiency rarely seen in Asia. Across a 33-year window, from 1993 to 2025, MSCI India generated 10.5% CAGR in dollar terms, outperforming most major EM peers and beating the broader MSCI EM index by over 300 basis points.
A large part of this alpha was generated post-2013 (12.3% vs 5.1% for the index), underpinned by margin expansion and steady domestic flows into capital markets that allowed Indian markets to decouple substantially from foreign investor sentiment. While some of the outsized relative gains were pared a bit in the early half of 2026, things seem to be reverting to normal business lately as global AI trade stutters.
What explains the massive macro-markets performance dichotomy? The Asian playbook is intuitively explanatory:
Financial repression Banks funded targeted sectors, from household deposits at administered rates, which transferred income from savers to industrial borrowers.
Wage repression Labour organisation was kept weak with little political influence, allowing productivity gains to accrue as profit & reinvested.
Competitive exchange rate An undervalued currency protected exporters and discouraged consumption of imports
Industrial policy Foreign investment was tightly controlled and linked to market and technology access. While support to domestic industry was conditional on export performance, which forced firms to reach world-class cost and scale rather than serve a protected home market.
Suppressed consumption Combination of industrial policy and financial repression produced very investment rates, even as it (relatively) suppressed mass consumption.
Each of the above has deleterious impact on equity market performance. If firms have access to cheap debt capital, they are likely to be blase about efficiency of equity capital, leading to invariably inefficient allocation decisions and, thereby, poor equity price performance.
Wage repression leads to depressed consumption and constrains growth of some of the most capital-efficient businesses in consumption and services - precisely the sectors that have driven both growth and stock market performance in India.
While a sweeping explanation is 'democracy,' Japan's experience with similar playbook and outcomes show it may be deeper than that. Perhaps, it's societal. Maybe, it's a wiring impact of India's traditional elite being heavily 'western' in its influences.
If it walks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it is most likely a duck. Clearly, the current supply-side focussed approach isn't optimal. As data changes, there is a need to change views. Policy must pivot towards demand-side and industrial policy:
Personal income-tax cuts, instead of corporate tax cuts
Strategies to fund higher incremental public debt rather than hard caps on fisc.
Industrial incentives and tariff protections linked firmly to export performance and technology-localisation milestones.
Make capital easier to get for firms, but outcomes attuned to macro-objectives rather than market performance.
The objective of Viksit Bharat by 2047 is on per-capita income, not equity market performance. It's time policy started reflecting a little bit of that.
The writer is chief investment officer, ASK Private Wealth
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.