Investing for daughter: Should you opt for Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana or PPF?
The interest rate offered is usually higher in case of SSY. On the other hand, PPF allows one to earn tax-free interest without any constraints in terms of investments, has a shorter lock-in and allows a longer investment horizon.
By ET CONTRIBUTORS | Updated:
Getty Images
The SSY can give the benefit of compounding if the horizon is long term.
Kavita believes that investment decisions should be made after proper analysis of available options and their specifications. So, before she starts investing for her 8-year old-daughter, she wants to consider factors such as returns, interest rates, risks involved, time horizon, etc. of investments. Since Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) and Public Provident Fund (PPF) are considered the safest investment options for investors seeking financial growth, Kavita wants to evaluate and compare these two. She is aware that both these investments are eligible for tax benefits under Section 80C for up to Rs 1.5 lakh annually. However, the interest rate on SSY is usually at least 0.5% higher than that of PPF. She wonders if SSY is a better option.
Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana is a government-sponsored investment initiative for the girl child up to the age of 10. This scheme comes with a tenure of 21 years. Kavita will need to invest the minimum amount every year for up to 15 years from the date of account opening to earn interest until maturity. But, in the case of SSY, her entire corpus will be locked in till her daughter attains 18 years of age. In fact, even after 18 years, Kavita will be able to take out only 50% of the investment and the rest of the amount can be withdrawn only when her daughter turns 21.
All you need to know about Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana
1/11
The Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) is a government-backed small deposit scheme for a girl child and her financial needs. It was launched as part of the 'Beti Bachao Beti Padhao' campaign. The scheme comes with income-tax benefit under section 80C. The returns are tax-free as well.
The Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) is a government-backed small deposit scheme for a girl child and her financial needs. It was launched as part of the 'Beti Bachao Beti Padhao' campaign. The scheme ..
Read More
A Sukanya Samriddhi Account can be opened any time after the birth of a girl child till she turns 10, where you will have to deposit a minimum of Rs 250. In subsequent years, a minimum of Rs 250 and a maximum of Rs 1.5 lakh can be deposited during the ongoing financial year.
The account will remain operative for 21 years from the date of its opening or till the marriage of the girl after she turns 18. To meet the requirement of the child's higher education expenses, partial withdrawal of 50 per cent of the balance is allowed after she turns 18.
A Sukanya Samriddhi Account can be opened any time after the birth of a girl child till she turns 10, where you will have to deposit a minimum of Rs 250. In subsequent years, a minimum of Rs 250 and ..
Read More
You can only open and operate one account in the name of the girl child. You can't open two accounts for one girl. The parents or legal guardians of a girl child (up to 10 years old) can open this account with a notified bank or post office in the name of the girl.
The birth certificate of the girl in whose name the account is opened should be submitted by the guardian at the time of the opening of the account in the post office or bank, along with other documents relating to identity and residence proof of the depositor.
You can only open and operate one account in the name of the girl child. You can't open two accounts for one girl. The parents or legal guardians of a girl child (up to 10 years old) can open this ac..
Read More
To keep the account active, a minimum contribution of Rs 250 is mandatory in each financial year (and in multiples of Rs 100 thereafter). Maximum investment allowed per annum under the Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana is Rs 1.5 lakh up to the end of 15th year from the opening of the account.
To keep the account active, a minimum contribution of Rs 250 is mandatory in each financial year (and in multiples of Rs 100 thereafter). Maximum investment allowed per annum under the Sukanya Samrid..
Read More
A Sukanya Samriddhi account can become a default account if the minimum deposit is not made in a financial year. The account in default can be revived before the completion of 15 years from the date of opening of the account by paying the minimum deposit amount, i.e., Rs 250 plus penalty amount of Rs 50 for each year of default.
If the penalty is not paid, the entire deposit, including those made before the date of default, will receive interest at post office savings bank account rate.
A Sukanya Samriddhi account can become a default account if the minimum deposit is not made in a financial year. The account in default can be revived before the completion of 15 years from the date ..
Read More
The government fixes interest rates on small savings and post office schemes a quarterly basis, SSY falls under this category and thus, interest rates are announced quarterly, based on government securities (G-sec) yields.
The government fixes interest rates on small savings and post office schemes a quarterly basis, SSY falls under this category and thus, interest rates are announced quarterly, based on government sec..
Read More
The SSY enjoys a exempt-exempt-exempt (EEE) status. The annual deposit (contributions) qualifies for Section 80C benefit and the maturity benefits are non-taxable.
The SSY enjoys a exempt-exempt-exempt (EEE) status. The annual deposit (contributions) qualifies for Section 80C benefit and the maturity benefits are non-taxable.
When she turns 10, the girl child whose name the account has been opened in can operate the account herself, however, deposit in the account has to be made by the guardian or any other person or authority.
The Sukanya Samriddhi account will mature after 21 years from the date of opening of the account or at the time of marriage of the girl child after attaining age of 18 years (1 month before or 3 months after date of marriage).
When she turns 10, the girl child whose name the account has been opened in can operate the account herself, however, deposit in the account has to be made by the guardian or any other person or auth..
Read More
In the event of death of the account holder, the account will be closed immediately on the production of a death certificate. The balance in the account will be paid, along with the interest till the month preceding the month of the premature closure of the account, to the guardian of the account holder.
In any other case, a request for the premature closure of an SSY account can be put forward after the completion of five years of the account opening. This too will be allowed, as per the rules, on extreme compassionate grounds such as medical support in life-threatening diseases. Still, if the account has to be closed for another reason, it will be allowed, but the entire deposit will only get interest of a Post Office Savings Bank account.
In the event of death of the account holder, the account will be closed immediately on the production of a death certificate. The balance in the account will be paid, along with the interest till the..
Read More
The account can be transferred anywhere in India if the girl child in whose name the account has been opened shifts to a place other than the city. A transfer request must be filled and one needs to visit their bank/post office branch with the passbook.
The transfer is free of cost up on furnishing proof of shifting of residence of either the parent/guardian or account holder. If no such proof is submitted, then the applicant will have to pay Rs 100 to the post office or the bank to which the transfer is made.
The account can be transferred anywhere in India if the girl child in whose name the account has been opened shifts to a place other than the city. A transfer request must be filled and one needs to ..
The interest offered is usually higher in case of SSY, as it encourages parents like Kavita to build funds for their daughter’s future. However, deposits can be made only till the 15th year. No deposits are allowed between the 16th and 21st years, though the account continues to earn interest for all 21 years. Hence, even while the funds are locked-in, investments beyond year 15 are restricted which places serious constraints on the accumulation potential of the corpus. On the other hand, PPF would allow her to earn tax-free interest without any constraints in terms of investments, has a shorter lock-in and allows a longer investment horizon. These PPF features neutralise any benefit in terms of the compounding period of a higher interest rate product like SSY, unless the time horizon is fairly long.
Hence, the promise of higher rate of interest alone shouldn’t sway Kavita’s investment decisions. Her relatively shorter investment period (7 years) may not allow the power of compounding to benefit her, adversely impacting her corpus size. SSY would have been an ideal option had Kavita’s daughter been younger. This would have given her the benefit of a longer investment horizon and greater wealth accumulation opportunity as compared to PPF.
(Content on this page is courtesy Centre for Investment Education and Learning (CIEL). Contributions by Girija Gadre, Arti Bhargava and Labdhi Mehta.)
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)