‘Water is also a drink’: Waitress mocked customer asking for water at NYC diner, vanished during service, then pushed for preset tip; customer’s final comment left her speechless

Dining out is supposed to be relaxing, especially after a long day of travel. But for one customer visiting New York City, a late-night restaurant stop reportedly turned into a frustrating experience that later sparked debate online about service, tipping culture, and customer expectations.

The story was shared on Reddit’s r/tipping forum by a user who described a tense interaction with a waitress at a famous NYC restaurant chain.

According to the post, the situation began shortly after the group was seated. When the waitress asked what they wanted to drink, the customer reportedly replied, “umm... nothing,” before asking for water instead.


The user claimed the waitress responded, “Water is also a drink, FYI.” “Honestly, I should have walked out right there,” the Reddit user wrote.

Also Read: Coffee shop worker in Michigan says boss keeps credit card tips while staff go home with just $2

Customer says service has become uncomfortable

Despite the awkward start, the group decided to stay because it was late and they were hungry after returning to their hotel. The customer explained that they asked the waitress for menu recommendations because they do not eat pork, beef, or bacon. However, they alleged that the server appeared irritated while answering follow-up questions.

After the food arrived, the experience reportedly became even more frustrating. The Reddit user claimed the table waited at least 15 minutes for the check while the waitress was nowhere to be found. According to the post, another server allegedly refused to bring the bill and told them they needed to speak directly with their assigned waitress.

Eventually, the waitress returned with the payment machine for the roughly $90 meal.

Tipping prompt reportedly became final straw

The customer said they originally intended to leave around a $10 tip, describing it as “generous for the experience.” However, the situation escalated during the payment process.

According to the post, the diner was searching for a custom tip option when the waitress allegedly interrupted and said, “You have to choose one of these options,” while pointing toward preset percentages.

The Reddit user claimed the default options ranged around 15% to 25%. “That was the last straw,” the customer angrily wrote.

Instead of selecting one of the preset amounts, the diner reportedly pressed “No Tip” and responded, “Then how come I can click this and still proceed?” “I’ve never felt so satisfied closing out a check,” the post added.

Reddit users split over tipping and attitude debate

The post quickly drew attention online, with many users debating whether the customer’s reaction was justified or overly harsh. Some commenters supported the diner, arguing that rude service should affect gratuity decisions, especially in restaurants where tipping is culturally expected.

Others focused on the opening interaction itself, pointing out that the waitress was technically correct when she said water counted as a drink order.

The original poster later acknowledged that criticism in an edit, writing: “Yeah, fair, I know water is a drink.” However, the user argued the real issue was not the statement itself but “the tone, plus everything that followed.”

Debate around tipping culture

The viral discussion also reopened arguments surrounding the infamous tipping culture in the United States, particularly around digital payment systems that push preset gratuity percentages.

Many diners have complained online about feeling pressured by tip screens, while service workers often argue that tips remain essential because of low base wages in the restaurant industry.

In this case, opinions remained divided. Some readers saw the customer’s decision as a reasonable response to poor service, while others felt withholding the tip entirely may have escalated an already tense interaction.

The unresolved question left many Reddit users debating the same issue: when service feels rude or dismissive, where should customers draw the line between frustration and fairness?