Tata Trusts Chair Noel Tata fires stronger salvo at Tata Sons board in new letter
Noel Tata has raised significant concerns regarding decisions made by Tata Sons, aiming for greater transparency. He specifically questions the reappointment of executive chairman N Chandrasekaran as valid or not. In a letter, Tata demands recordi...

In a seven-page letter dated November 20 to Tata Sons company secretary Suprakash Mukhopadhyay, and copied to all directors, Noel Tata raised questions over the board meeting that took place on September 17 and sought detailed written responses by November 25, a day before the company’s next board meeting is scheduled. ET has seen a copy of the letter.
On Wednesday, ET reported that the November 26 Tata Sons board meeting was likely to be contentious owing to the differences between the company and its principal shareholder, Tata Trusts, over whether the holdco should remain privately held or comply with the RBI’s listing requirement.
Noel Tata, a director of Tata Sons, argued that Chandrasekaran’s reappointment for five years was moved without prior notice and on the basis of a recommendation that had not been made by the company’s Nomination and Remuneration Committee (NRC).

The committee, which met on September 3, had only asked Chandrasekaran to reconsider his decision to step down and not formally recommended his reappointment, Noel Tata said. The NRC’s minutes did not record a subsequent meeting or a recommendation to the board, he added
He also questioned the validity of the voting process, citing Article 121 of Tata Sons’ Articles of Association (AoA), which he said required the affirmative vote of a majority of directors appointed under Article 104B who were present at the meeting.
Only two such directors attended, with one voting against the resolution, Noel Tata said. He disputed the use of the chairman’s casting vote to break what the draft minutes described as an equality between nominee directors of the Trusts, arguing that the provision did not authorise such an intervention. Noel Tata pointed out that an identical proposal tabled in February had been treated as not carried because one director did not support it. He also questioned why Tata Sons had not constituted a selection committee under Article 118 of its AoA for the appointment process.
The dispute over the voting process carries legal uncertainty, said Harshal Anjaria, founder of Shreeyam Advisors. “The core question is whether a chairman’s casting vote can substitute for an affirmative vote the articles specifically reserve for the Trusts’ nominees,” he said, adding that legal counsel on both sides had taken opposing positions. Ultimately, only a court or tribunal would settle the issue, and until then the reappointment carried legal uncertainty.
The letter also intensifies a separate dispute over access to the audio and video recording of the September 17 meeting.
Noel Tata said the company’s November 9 response had confirmed that the meeting was recorded. But it had refused to share the recording, arguing that it was intended only to assist in preparing the minutes and not required to be retained or disclosed to directors.
This, Noel Tata said, was unacceptable and that directors were entitled to inspect company records in electronic form. Article 129 of the AoA did not exclude such access, he said.He sought written confirmation that the complete, unedited recording still existed, details of its custody and access, and an assurance that it would be preserved until the issues over the meeting were resolved.
Warning that any deletion or alteration after September 18, when he first sought preservation of the recording, would amount to the “deliberate destruction of evidence,” Noel Tata offered to inspect it at Bombay House, Tata headquarters, in the presence of an adviser.
Once a company records a board meeting and uses it to prepare minutes, it becomes difficult to argue that’s not a company record, Anjaria said. “Where the minutes are disputed, preserving that recording is basic good governance and, ideally, in the company’s own interest.” The Companies Act and Secretarial Standards expect minutes to be finalised within 30 days and to record dissent. Delays in a disputed matter only invite scrutiny, he added.
Noel Tata also asked that the minutes of the September 17 meeting be finalised only after the board had considered his objections, with Chandrasekaran taking no part in the discussion on his reappointment.
The letter separately raised questions about potential conflicts of interest involving Chandrasekaran and director Venu Srinivasan: it said Chandrasekaran’s April 2025 disclosure listed his wife and son as partners and directors in Hanno entities but did not disclose any dealings with TVS Motor Co.
This assumes significance, Noel Tata said, in light of reports that TVS Motor had leased land to Hanno One in June 2025. He questioned whether Srinivasan, who was part of the committee that assessed Chandrasekaran’s performance and recommended his remuneration and reappointment, had disclosed any potential conflict arising from the relationship.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.