RBI flags suspicious off-market deals in state bonds
The Reserve Bank of India is investigating suspicious trading activities involving illiquid state development loans in September. Some traders allegedly tried to manipulate prices to mitigate quarter-end mark-to-market losses for their banks. Tran...

The regulator has asked a few banks to explain the prices at which the deals were cut, two senior bankers told ET.
The regulator has asked a few banks to explain the prices at which the deals were cut, two senior bankers told ET.
The transactions took place in September when some traders were believed to have attempted to prop up prices of state securities to reduce quarter-end mark-to-market (MTM) losses.
MTM losses show up in trading books of banks and bond houses when current market price of securities drop below original purchase prices. Saddled with MTM losses amid a surge in bond yields, a group of dealers are understood have indulged in circular trading to push up prices of these state papers to cover MTM losses as on September 30. As inflation and interest rate harden, bond yields rise while prices fall.
State securities, better known as state development loans (SDLs) are debt securities issued by state governments to fund deficits, infrastructure, and other projects. Managed and auctioned by RBI, SDLs typically offer higher yields than central government securities with similar maturities.
Read more: Trifecta effect! How RIL, HDFC Bank and ICICI Bank are powering Nifty rebound after 2 years
"So far, RBI has flagged off the trades last month to at least three banks. We are trying to find out more to caution our traders. With bond yields rising, some could be tempted," said a treasurer of a large bank.
It's learnt that at least one bank questioned by RBI has asked a dealer to go on leave.
ET's email and text message to the RBI spokesman went unanswered time of going to press.
Over the years such circular trading to window-dress books has come down significantly with RBI having a full visibility of transaction trail and more robust surveillance mechanism.
Read more: Reliance Industries share rebound is not over yet, says JPMorgan. Target price set at Rs 1,675
A bank sitting on a bag of thinly traded security whose price has fallen would sell a small part of its holding to another bank at a price higher than what it would fetch. Simultaneously, a similar transaction happens when the second bank sells a slice of its illiquid portfolio to the first bank. With this, the papers are valued at higher dealt prices, thereby cutting MTM losses. Sometimes deals may happen to book profits.
However, one or two isolated deals do not set the valuation price. In such cases bonds would be valued at historical prices derived from a standard model. "Understandably, this does not serve the purpose. So, to escape regulator's attention, two to four banks would carry out multiple trades spread over few weeks with the transactions exceeding Rs 25-30 crore," said another banker.
State and central government bonds are primarily traded on RBI's negotiated Dealing System-Order Matching (NDS-OM) platform. Also, there are over-the-counter (OTC) trades, where deals are confirmed over phone and later reported and settled on NDS-OM.
Before the introduction of anonymous order-matching screen-based trading, manipulation often happened with help of select bond brokers. However, broker driven volumes have significantly shrunk since a decade.
Bankers said the market's attention was also drawn to a few off-market deals in a central government security carrying a coupon rate of 6.68% and maturing in 2040. "This month there large trades which happened towards closing hours but reversed next day by respective counter-parties. This could be due to fat finger error. Usually, such unwinding is done through a dispute resolution mechanism of the industry body FIMMDA. But since it could not be resolved, the trades were reversed at different prices in odd-lot segment. We are trying to find out whether this was a genuine error," said a senior banker.
Download ET Markets APP