Street artist Banksy loses legal battle over 'Flower Thrower' grafitti work due to his anonymity
The EU panel ruled the trademark to be invalid and ordered Banksy to pay the costs.
By AFP |
AP
The mysterious artist, whose iconic graffiti paintings have appeared overnight on buildings around the world, successfully obtained a European Union trademark for the image in 2014.
MADRID: British street artist Banksy has lost a two-year trademark battle with a greetings card company over his 'Flower Thrower' graffiti work after EU officials said his anonymity meant he couldn't be identified as the owner.
The ruling by the EU's intellectual property office (EUIPO), which is based in Spain, concerns one of Banksy's most famous efforts showing a masked protester hurling a bunch of flowers, which first appeared on a wall in Jerusalem in 2005.
The mysterious artist, whose iconic graffiti paintings have appeared overnight on buildings around the world, successfully obtained a European Union trademark for the image in 2014.
But two years ago, Full Colour Black, which makes greetings cards and wanted to use the image, issued a legal challenge, claiming the trademark was taken out in bad faith as he never intended to use it for goods or services -- in a challenge accepted by the EU's intellectual property czars.
"It is clear that when [Banksy] filed the EUTM, he did not have any intention of using the sign to commercialise goods or provide services," the panel found, saying the artist's anonymity had worked against him.
"The predicament of Banksy's right to the work 'Flower Thrower' is clear. To protect the right under copyright law would require him to lose his anonymity, which would undermine his persona," it found.
ADVERTISEMENT
"He cannot be identified as the unquestionable owner of such works as his identity is hidden."
It said he had filed the trademark in order to secure "legal rights over the [artwork] as he could not rely on copyright rights, but that is not a function of a trade mark."
Last year, Banksy opened a pop-up shop in south London, named "Gross Domestic Product", saying its purpose was to address issues raised in the dispute -- largely to show he was using the trademark, which the panel also found went against his case.
The EU panel ruled the trademark to be invalid and ordered Banksy and his legal representative to pay the costs and fees incurred by Full Colour Black. Any appeal must be filed within two months.
ADVERTISEMENT
Picasso Isn't The Only One: Artists Who Shared A Troubled Bond With Their Muse
1/6
Pablo Picasso immortalised French artist and lover Dora Maar through his paintings. Now, she is stepping out of his shadow, with a retrospective of her works at the Pompidou Centre. A look at other artists and their troubled bond with their inspirations.
Pablo Picasso immortalised French artist and lover Dora Maar through his paintings. Now, she is stepping out of his shadow, with a retrospective of her works at the Pompidou Centre. A look at other a..
Read More
Picasso was almost 30 years older than Walter when he met her in 1927. The painter and his muse had a secret affair for over eight years before Walter got pregnant and the affair was discovered by Picasso’s wife, Olga. At the time, Picasso was also having an affair with Dora Maar. The artist suggested that both his muses fight it out for his affections. Walter continued to be involved with Picasso till the early 1940s.
Picasso was almost 30 years older than Walter when he met her in 1927. The painter and his muse had a secret affair for over eight years before Walter got pregnant and the affair was discovered by Pi..
Read More
Gala, born in Russia, was first married to poet Paul Éluard. The two had an open marriage and Éluard would introduce Gala to new artists, including Max Ernst, who became one of her lovers. Gala met Salvador Dali in 1929 and soon after, they began to live together. Almost immediately after they met, Dali began featuring Gala in his paintings. She became his muse, portrait model and business manager. He even signed his paintings with both of their names. The two tied the knot in 1934, but Gala continued to have affairs. Her death in 1982 reportedly took a terrible toll on the artist.
Gala, born in Russia, was first married to poet Paul Éluard. The two had an open marriage and Éluard would introduce Gala to new artists, including Max Ernst, who became one of her lovers. Gala met S..
Read More
Bacon’s relationship with Dyer was fraught with conf lict and had a tragic end. Their relationship began in late 1963 in a pub in Soho and was infused with passion, alcohol and drugs. From then, Dyer became Bacon’s muse. However, their relationship started to go downhill, and Dyer’s addiction worsened with time. Two days before the opening of the Francis Bacon Retrospective at the Grand Palais in Paris in 1971, Dyer committed suicide. Bacon painted the renowned three ‘Black Triptychs’, which portrayed a few moments before and after Dyer’s suicide.
Bacon’s relationship with Dyer was fraught with conf lict and had a tragic end. Their relationship began in late 1963 in a pub in Soho and was infused with passion, alcohol and drugs. From then, Dyer..
Read More
Siddal was the muse and model for many pre-Raphaelites before sitting for Rossetti in 1851. Within two years, Siddal and Rossetti began to work with each other exclusively. By 1853, the couple lived together and reportedly became absorbed in each other to the point of becoming anti-social. Some reports suggest that Siddal was plagued by insecurities that she would be replaced by a younger muse and Rossetti worried about his family’s approval. The two married in 1860. Siddal died of an overdose of laudanum two years later.
Siddal was the muse and model for many pre-Raphaelites before sitting for Rossetti in 1851. Within two years, Siddal and Rossetti began to work with each other exclusively. By 1853, the couple lived ..
Read More
Claudel was a French sculptor who started to work as the assistant of renowned sculptor Auguste Rodin. Rodin was drawn to her and soon, she was his lover and muse. What followed was a tumultuous 10-year relationship. Rodin, already in a committed relationship, was not prepared to leave his long-term partner. The destructive aftermath of the affair turned Claudel into a paranoid recluse. She threw away most her of work and spent the last 30 years of her life confined to a mental institution.
Claudel was a French sculptor who started to work as the assistant of renowned sculptor Auguste Rodin. Rodin was drawn to her and soon, she was his lover and muse. What followed was a tumultuous 10-y..