Hiring takes a U-turn: Job recruitment script flips in an unexpected way
One of the great ironies of the AI revolution is that the more sophisticated technology becomes, the more valuable direct human assessment may become. The future of hiring may not be less digital. It may simply demand more proof that the person be...

There have been widespread reports of unfair practices used by candidates at campus hirings. This has made recruiters more cautious about trusting online test scores.
After a period of embracing online assessments, automated screening, virtual interviews and AI-powered hiring tools, companies are again turning to physical tests and face-to-face interviews to find out whether candidates actually possess the skills they claim.
Also read | Contract staffing in Indian IT grows 10.1% in FY26, outpaces permanent hiring
For employers, the challenge is no longer simply finding talent with AI skills; it is establishing that the person being hired can actually think and perform.
As AI makes it increasingly difficult to distinguish genuine ability from machine-generated performance, employers are rediscovering the value of human interaction.
So, in essence, a technology that promised to make hiring faster, smarter and more convenient is now causing the job interview to be back to where it began: across a table, with a recruiter looking a candidate in the eye.
The same trust deficit has hit the education sector too. According to reports, South Korea has introduced a number of extraordinary checks to prevent AI-assisted exam fraud.
A reversal at campuses
The change is particularly visible in India's premier engineering institutes, the Mint newspaper reported.Placement teams at IIT Jodhpur, IIT Patna, IIT Ropar, IIT Mandi and IIT Indore have reported that more companies want to conduct recruitment physically for the 2027 graduating batch.
At some newer IITs, the proportion of companies opting for offline recruitment has climbed to 60-70%, compared with 40-50% a year earlier, Mint's report says.
This reversal is striking because recruitment had been moving in the opposite direction for quite some time.
Also read | AI, data, cybersecurity lead tech hiring with 30.3% share in September quarter
During and after the pandemic, companies increasingly shifted preliminary tests, technical assessments and even final interviews online, because automated screening and AI-based evaluation promised lower costs, quicker shortlisting and access to a wider talent pool.
Last year's recruiters even sought to test how candidates used AI prompts to solve problems. But the same technology has now become a potential means of bypassing tough interview questions.
The difference is between using AI as a workplace tool and using it to mis-sell one's abilities.
Companies recruiting advanced AI engineers and prompt engineers may actively encourage candidates to use these tools. However, employers hiring software developers, data analysts and graduate engineer trainees are concerned about candidates relying on AI when independent problem-solving is what they are trying to measure.
There have been widespread reports of unfair practices used by candidates at campus hirings. This has made recruiters more cautious about trusting online test scores.
Cheating during interviews has moved beyond using stand-in applicants or outside help; candidates are now using hidden browser tabs, secondary screens running ChatGPT, and voice-cloning tools to beat the assessment process, Anil Agarwal, cofounder, InCruiter, told ET.
An extraordinary exam crackdown
The problem is not limited to job recruitment. Schools and colleges everywhere have been at their wit's end as more and more students cheat their way to excellent marks at exams.South Korea is confronting a similar challenge. AI-enabled devices are threatening the credibility of high-stakes examinations in that country.
It has ordered stringent security measures for its College Scholastic Ability Test, or Suneung, to be held tomorrow (November 19). The new measures had to be ordered after a candidate who topped a national tax-accountant examination admitted using a concealed camera, a smartphone and generative AI to obtain answers.
Authorities will now inspect candidates' glasses, examine their collars and cover shirt buttons with stickers to prevent hidden cameras from being used. Metal detectors will also be deployed when necessary, Reuters reported.
More than 550,000 candidates are expected to take the examination across approximately 1,300 centres. Nearly 8,400 additional supervisors will be deployed. Candidates must surrender electronic devices, including smartphones, smartwatches and smart glasses. Even failing to hand over a prohibited device will be treated as cheating, whether or not it was actually used.
The scale of the crackdown reflects the seriousness of the challenge.
The government also plans to increase the disqualification period for offenders from one year to 10 years. AI chatbot companies have agreed to assist investigations into suspected cases, Reuters report said.
What this means for employers
For companies, the return to physical recruitment will mean higher hiring costs, longer recruitment cycles and greater logistical demands.Travelling to campuses, arranging supervised tests and deploying interview panels can be expensive, particularly when companies recruit across several institutions or locations.
Smaller employers may find this more difficult.
Yet the alternative carries its own risks. Hiring someone whose test performance is no marker of their ability can lead to big problems -- poor productivity, costly mistakes, additional training expenses.
Large multinational companies are also examining the legal, ethical and bias-related implications of using AI in recruitment itself.
A completely offline approach, however, is unlikely to become the norm. Companies recruiting for AI-intensive roles will continue to assess candidates on their ability to use these tools.
Companies will now combine physical invigilation with digital monitoring during interviews/assessments.
Ecomm company Meesho is updating its hiring process by pairing AI tools with human evaluation. The company improves interview quality and integrity using AI-supported frameworks, secure browser settings, and advanced video analysis, says Ashish Kumar Singh, the company's chief human resources officer.
Striking a new balance
The likely outcome is a hybrid recruitment model -- in which AI handles the necessary part of the hiring processe, and humans supervise.Going forward, more and more recruiters may combine online screening with supervised practical assignments, live problem-solving exercises, in-person technical interviews and verification of candidates' actual capabilities.
For example, Deutsche Bank Group India is using assessment platforms with advanced monitoring tools to automatically spot and flag irregularities -- such as unauthorised browser extensions or suspicious activity -- as they happen, says Madhavi Lall, head of human resources.
While AI will certainly remain a critical part of the hiring process, companies will have to distinguish between candidates who use it intelligently and those who depend on it to conceal their shortcomings, analysts say.
Multi-stage evaluations with cross-functional interviewers will help corroborate recruiter's observations, Deloitte India's Deepti Sagar had told ET a little while ago.
The same principle will apply to examinations and professional certifications.
Many of the recruiters don't see AI-assisted cheating as a huge setback. It is not something that can reverse the shift toward flexible and digital hiring; remote hiring is set to remain essential for accessing diverse talent from diverse places, Sagar added.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.