Explained: Why PB Fintech, Turtlemint, SBI Life, HDFC Life and other insurance stocks tanked up to 26% on Thursday
IRDAI has proposed insurance distribution reforms, including a ban on dark patterns, lower Expense of Management limits and greater commission transparency. The changes could affect customer acquisition costs and distribution economics for insurer...
By Veer Sharma, ETMarkets.com | Updated:
ETMarkets.com
Insurance stocks in focus as IRDAI proposes tighter distribution rules.
Shares of PB Fintech, Turtlemint, SBI Life Insurance, HDFC Life Insurance and ICICI Lombard General Insurance, among others, tumbled up to 26% on Thursday after the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (Irdai) proposed prohibiting ‘dark patterns’ on insurance websites. This prohibition includes practices that require customers to provide personal details before accessing product features and pricing information.
In today's session, PB Fintech hit a 26% lower circuit of Rs 1,399, while newly-listed Turtlemint hit a 20% lower circuit of Rs 109 per share on the BSE. SBI Life Insurance declined over 3% to Rs 1,700. Private player HDFC Life Insurance crashed as much as 7% to Rs 523 per share.
The proposed IRDAI reforms could weigh on insurance stocks by pressuring distribution economics. Lower Expense of Management (EoM) limits would restrict how much insurers can spend on commissions, distribution and other operating expenses. This could make customer acquisition more expensive.
Read More: Irdai proposes product-wise commission caps, lower expense limits for insurers
It proposed a set of structural reforms aimed at lowering insurance costs, expanding coverage among underserved sections and putting the sector on a sustainable growth path. The draft paper focuses on several key areas, including rationalising Expenses of Management (EoM), reintroducing segmental commission limits and prohibiting "dark patterns".
Under the proposed framework, insurers would have to disclose product and pricing information without requiring customers to share personal details. The paper also proposes disclosing commission rates on policy documents and streamlining motor insurance.
Other distribution-related proposals cover the types of policies banks can sell, a ban on incentives to agents, enabling insurers to use Market Infrastructure Institutions (MIIs) for insurance sales and prohibiting compulsory bundling of insurance products, such as credit life insurance.
For general insurers, the calculation would move from gross written premium (GWP) to domestic GDPI. The EoM limit would be reduced from 30% of GWP to 20% of GDPI over five years, through progressive annual reductions.
The regulator said the proposed reduction in EoM is aimed at lowering the overall cost of insurance, expanding the risk pool available in general insurance and improving returns for policyholders in life savings products.
The proposed framework also seeks to strengthen market discipline by tracking dark patterns and making relevant performance information available. IRDAI said insurers should disclose product features, pricing and quality information in a standard, easy-to-understand format without requiring customers to share personal details.
The regulator defines dark patterns as practices or deceptive design patterns using user interface or user experience interactions on any platform that are designed to mislead or trick users into doing something they did not originally intend or want to do.
IRDAI has proposed recalibrating the commission framework alongside these changes. Rather than applying a uniform approach, commission limits would factor in the segment, line of business, distribution channel, product complexity and the effort involved in selling and servicing the product.
Insurers and large distribution entities would also have to disclose commission policies and structures in a simple and accessible manner. In contrast, specified commercial policies would carry commission disclosures, according to the paper.
The regulator has further proposed stronger safeguards against mis-selling. These include making suitability an enforceable obligation, documenting customer needs and suitability for specified life insurance sales, and maintaining an audit trail.
Disclaimer: The views/recommendations mentioned in this article, wherever applicable, are those of the respective SEBI-registered Research Analyst/brokerage and have been reproduced/reported with due attribution. They should not be construed as the views or recommendations of The Economic Times Digital or the journalist. Readers are advised to consider the original research report and make their investment decisions based on their own assessment. Brokerage disclaimers here
In today's session, PB Fintech hit a 26% lower circuit of Rs 1,399, while newly-listed Turtlemint hit a 20% lower circuit of Rs 109 per share on the BSE. SBI Life Insurance declined over 3% to Rs 1,700. Private player HDFC Life Insurance crashed as much as 7% to Rs 523 per share.
The proposed IRDAI reforms could weigh on insurance stocks by pressuring distribution economics. Lower Expense of Management (EoM) limits would restrict how much insurers can spend on commissions, distribution and other operating expenses. This could make customer acquisition more expensive.
Read More: Irdai proposes product-wise commission caps, lower expense limits for insurers
What did IRDAI say in its consultation paper?
The regulator proposed replacing the existing complex and fragmented distribution structure with three broad categories of entities: Insurance Distribution Entities (IDEs), Insurance Distribution Persons (IDPs) and Market Infrastructure Institutions (MIIs).It proposed a set of structural reforms aimed at lowering insurance costs, expanding coverage among underserved sections and putting the sector on a sustainable growth path. The draft paper focuses on several key areas, including rationalising Expenses of Management (EoM), reintroducing segmental commission limits and prohibiting "dark patterns".
ADVERTISEMENT
Under the proposed framework, insurers would have to disclose product and pricing information without requiring customers to share personal details. The paper also proposes disclosing commission rates on policy documents and streamlining motor insurance.
Other distribution-related proposals cover the types of policies banks can sell, a ban on incentives to agents, enabling insurers to use Market Infrastructure Institutions (MIIs) for insurance sales and prohibiting compulsory bundling of insurance products, such as credit life insurance.
For general insurers, the calculation would move from gross written premium (GWP) to domestic GDPI. The EoM limit would be reduced from 30% of GWP to 20% of GDPI over five years, through progressive annual reductions.
The regulator said the proposed reduction in EoM is aimed at lowering the overall cost of insurance, expanding the risk pool available in general insurance and improving returns for policyholders in life savings products.
ADVERTISEMENT
The proposed framework also seeks to strengthen market discipline by tracking dark patterns and making relevant performance information available. IRDAI said insurers should disclose product features, pricing and quality information in a standard, easy-to-understand format without requiring customers to share personal details.
What happens now?
At present, the public can access product features and pricing information only after providing personal details. IRDAI said this is one of the ‘dark patterns’ frequently seen on insurer and distributor websites and is also against guidelines issued by the Central Consumer Protection Authority under the Consumer Protection Act, 2019.ADVERTISEMENT
The regulator defines dark patterns as practices or deceptive design patterns using user interface or user experience interactions on any platform that are designed to mislead or trick users into doing something they did not originally intend or want to do.
IRDAI has proposed recalibrating the commission framework alongside these changes. Rather than applying a uniform approach, commission limits would factor in the segment, line of business, distribution channel, product complexity and the effort involved in selling and servicing the product.
Insurers and large distribution entities would also have to disclose commission policies and structures in a simple and accessible manner. In contrast, specified commercial policies would carry commission disclosures, according to the paper.
The regulator has further proposed stronger safeguards against mis-selling. These include making suitability an enforceable obligation, documenting customer needs and suitability for specified life insurance sales, and maintaining an audit trail.
Disclaimer: The views/recommendations mentioned in this article, wherever applicable, are those of the respective SEBI-registered Research Analyst/brokerage and have been reproduced/reported with due attribution. They should not be construed as the views or recommendations of The Economic Times Digital or the journalist. Readers are advised to consider the original research report and make their investment decisions based on their own assessment. Brokerage disclaimers here
Too busy to trade in stocks? Invest in Mutual Funds with ET Money!
Bookmark or read stories offline -
Download ET Markets APP
Download ET Markets APP
Related Articles
Two Trades for Today: A leading pharma firm for a 5.75% rise, a mid-cap online insurance stock for a gain of almost 6%ADVERTISEMENT
