Democrats want Donald Trump’s paper trail. Can the White House keep it out of reach?

Democrats plan to seek records from private companies and advisers when they take control of Congress in January.The Trump administration argues that executive privilege can protect some confidential conversations with people outside government.

Democrats want Donald Trump’s paper trail. Can the White House keep it out of reach?

When Democrats take control of Congress in January, some of the records they want won’t be at the White House. They’ll be with private companies and advisers who dealt with President Donald Trump or his administration. Lawmakers have already asked for documents about the Trump family’s cryptocurrency ventures and the administration’s pressure on law firms.

Some requests are already getting results. One organization targeted by a Trump executive order turned over records within 48 hours of Election Day after withholding them for months, according to a report by CNN, citing a person familiar with the matter. The report did not identify the organization.

The harder fight may come when lawmakers seek confidential communications with outside advisers. Trump’s Justice Department says executive privilege can protect some of those exchanges. If a dispute goes to court, lawmakers could spend months waiting for records. Even if they eventually get the documents, the 2028 presidential campaign may already be underway.



Why are Democrats asking private companies for records?

Companies may have their own records of dealings with the administration. Connecticut Sen. Richard Blumenthal has told companies involved in Senate inquiries to preserve documents. A company can hand over records voluntarily. If it declines, lawmakers may seek a subpoena, which is a formal demand.

The White House has already warned Democrats about how they use that power. In a Nov. 10 letter to California Rep. Robert Garcia, the Democrat in line to chair the House Oversight Committee, White House counsel Will Scharf argued that using investigative powers to intimidate officials could cross into criminal conduct.

ADVERTISEMENT

How could Donald Trump use executive privilege?

Executive privilege can protect certain confidential presidential communications. In an August opinion, the Justice Department’s Office of Legal Counsel said the protection can extend to outside advisers. In its view, the exchanges must be confidential and concern official presidential decisions. They must also involve or reflect communications with the president or his direct advisers. The department argues that outsiders may be less willing to speak frankly if their advice could become public.

The administration has already made that argument in a civil case brought by the American Bar Association over executive orders targeting law firms. It is seeking to block subpoenas to Boris Epshteyn, a private Trump adviser. Those subpoenas came from a lawsuit, but the dispute raises a question Congress could soon face: Can the White House keep a conversation confidential when the records are held outside government?

What did the Supreme Court say about Trump’s financial records?

In 2019, the House subpoenaed Trump’s accounting firm, Mazars USA, for financial records. Trump challenged the demand. The Supreme Court sent the dispute back to the lower courts in 2020. It told judges to weigh the balance of power between Congress and the presidency and examine how closely the records were tied to a valid legislative purpose. Trump didn’t claim executive privilege over those records.

By then, more than a year had passed since the House issued the subpoena. Blumenthal told CNN that he is looking for ways to speed up Senate subpoena enforcement. Congressional investigators also told CNN that they hope public pressure will persuade companies and individuals to cooperate without a court fight.

ADVERTISEMENT
FAQs

Can Congress subpoena a private company?

ADVERTISEMENT
Yes. The demand must serve a valid legislative purpose.

Does executive privilege cover everything an outside adviser tells the president?

No. The Justice Department’s opinion addresses certain confidential exchanges about official decisions. It isn’t a court ruling.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › World › US › Democrats want Donald Trump’s paper trail. Can the White House keep it out of reach?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+