Arizona customer paid for only $60 of her $85 lottery order; the ticket she left behind won $12.8 million, and now three people want it

An Arizona woman ordered $85 worth of lottery tickets but only paid for $60 before leaving. A ticket she left behind ultimately won a $12.8 million jackpot, complicating ownership claims. The store manager bought the leftover tickets, not disclosi...

TIMESOFINDIA.COM

Arizona customer paid for only $60 of her $85 lottery order; the ticket she left behind won $12.8 million, and now three people want it

An Arizona woman ordered $85 worth of lottery tickets but walked away after paying for only $60. One of the 25 tickets she left behind went on to win a $12.8 million jackpot. The customer, a former Circle K manager and the convenience store chain are caught up in a legal battle over who should receive the money. The winning ticket remains on hold while a judge considers the competing claims.


How did the winning ticket get left behind?

The incident began on November 24, 2025, at a Circle K store in Scottsdale. According to court documents cited by AZ Family, Soonchun Kim asked an employee to print $85 worth of $1 tickets for The Pick, an Arizona Lottery game.


However, Kim discovered she had only $60 and paid for that amount. The remaining 25 tickets were left at the store.

The winning numbers drawn that evening were 3, 13, 14, 15, 19 and 26. One of the unpaid tickets matched all six numbers, making it worth $12.8 million.

The following morning, store manager Robert Gawlitza discovered that one of the leftover tickets had won the jackpot.

ADVERTISEMENT

Why did the former manager buy the tickets?

According to court filings, Gawlitza clocked out, changed out of his uniform and asked cashier Marline Ybarra to sell him the remaining tickets. He paid $10 and received a receipt.

Court exhibits also show that he sought approval from his supervisor through a text message before making the purchase. However, he did not reveal that he had already found the winning ticket.

Gawlitza and Ybarra reportedly agreed to split any winnings equally. Circle K later took possession of the ticket, fired Gawlitza and filed a lawsuit in February to establish who was entitled to the jackpot.

His attorney, Josh Kolsrud, argues that Gawlitza followed a longstanding, unwritten company practice requiring employees to pay for tickets that were printed by mistake but left unsold. Six current and former employees have submitted statements supporting that account.
ADVERTISEMENT


Three competing claims over the jackpot

Circle K argues that Arizona Lottery rules give retailers ownership of unsold tickets. The company also maintains that Gawlitza could not legally purchase a winning ticket after the drawing had taken place.

ADVERTISEMENT
State Rep. Jeff Weninger told AZ Family, “It is in the administrative rules that basically says if they overprint that the retailer owns the tickets.”

The dispute became more complicated when Kim joined the case in September, claiming an interest in the ticket she originally ordered but did not fully pay for. The legal basis of her claim remains unclear.

The Arizona Lottery is also named in the lawsuit. A spokesperson told AZ Family, “This is a unique situation, and we are not aware of any prior litigation of this sort involving the Arizona Lottery.”

According to NBC Palm Springs, Maricopa County Superior Court Judge Joseph Kreamer allowed the case to continue at a November 6 hearing but paused most of the employees' other claims until ownership is decided.

The judge had previously extended the claim deadline to prevent the ticket from expiring during the legal fight. The winning ticket must be claimed by May 23. Arizona 12 News reported that the $12.8 million prize is the fourth-largest jackpot in The Pick's history and the biggest won in Arizona since 2019. The information is taken from Casino.org and Local12.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › World › US › Arizona customer paid for only $60 of her $85 lottery order; the ticket she left behind won $12.8 million, and now three people want it
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+