Amtrak train started moving while a woman helped her parents with their bags: What happened next led to a federal lawsuit
Amtrak lawsuit: A woman helping her parents board an Amtrak train in 2013 was still aboard when the train started moving. She was later found injured beside the tracks, sparking a negligence lawsuit over whether she jumped or fell from the train ...

Amtrak train started moving while a woman helped her parents with their bags: What happened next led to a federal lawsuit (Photo: iStock)
Butler-Tessier was later found injured beside the railway tracks and the incident led to a negligence lawsuit against Amtrak. The railroad said she had jumped from the moving train. She disputed that account, and the circumstances of her exit became a central issue in the court case.
The incident happened on November 6, 2013, at the Route 128 station in Westwood, Massachusetts. According to the US District Court for the District of New Hampshire, Butler-Tessier had driven her parents to the station and helped them board with their luggage.
Amtrak Train Pulled Away While Woman Was Still Helping Her Parents
Butler-Tessier placed her parents' bags near the door and helped them find their seats. She did not have a ticket and was not travelling with them.Before she could leave, the train began moving. She walked through the connecting doors from her parents' passenger car into the café car. An exterior door of the café car, known as a vestibule door, was ajar.
She exited the moving train and was later found injured beside the tracks west of the station. She was airlifted to Boston Medical Center for treatment.
Amtrak Said She Jumped From the Train, But She Could Not Recall Her Exit
Amtrak maintained that Butler-Tessier had jumped from the moving train. She disputed the railroad's account but could not remember exactly how she had left the train.There appeared to be no eyewitness to the incident. Medical records also offered different descriptions. One referred to a jump, while another described a fall from a train.
Her mother, Eleanor Butler, reportedly told Amtrak employees that her daughter had jumped. Butler-Tessier challenged the use of those statements as hearsay.
Court also considered questions about whether her mother could have seen what had happened. The evidence included references to possible dementia and also concerns about her ability to observe her daughter's exit. Her mother's statements did not settle the question of how Butler-Tessier left the train.
Open Door on Moving Train Became Key Issue in Amtrak Lawsuit
The café car's exterior door became an important part of Butler-Tessier's negligence claim.She argued that the door was open while the train was moving. She presented evidence that allowing a train to leave a station with an open door would violate Amtrak's passenger safety policies and potentially other applicable standards.
Amtrak disputed that the door had caused her injuries. The railroad argued that her alleged decision to jump was responsible.
The judge found that a jury could conclude that the open door had contributed to the incident. Even if Butler-Tessier had jumped, a jury could find that the door's condition was a substantial factor in her injuries.
The train's departure announcement was another point of disagreement. The parties disputed whether an announcement was required and whether one had been made.
Federal Judge Allows Negligence Case Against Amtrak to Continue
Butler-Tessier sued the National Railroad Passenger Corporation, commonly known as Amtrak, over the incident. Her husband, Christopher Tessier, also brought a loss-of-consortium claim.Amtrak asked the court to grant summary judgment, arguing that Butler-Tessier could not prove that the railroad's actions had caused her injuries. It also argued that her own conduct should prevent her from recovering damages.
On March 11, 2016, US District Judge Joseph N. Laplante denied Amtrak's request.
The judge found that the conflicting accounts and evidence raised questions that could not be resolved in the railroad's favour at that stage. These included whether Butler-Tessier jumped or fell, whether the café car door was open and whether the train had left without a required announcement.
The decision did not find Amtrak responsible for her injuries. It allowed the lawsuit to continue rather than dismissing it before the disputed facts could be considered further.
https://economictimes.indiatimes.com/world/money/medicare-2027-premium-hike-why-your-income-from-2-years-ago-could-push-your-monthly-bill-above-209-and-how-to-appeal/articleshow/135970264.cms
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.