A Tennessee retiree divorced with a $2.3 million 401(k); the state Supreme Court ruled his wedding-day balance stayed his; only marital gains were shared
Robert H. Snodgrass was married to Iris Kay Snodgrass. They got married in July 1982. Both had worked as salaried employees for Alcoa. They were married for about 23 years, and both reportedly participated in employer-provided 401(k) plans. Before...

What had exactly happened?
Robert H. Snodgrass was married to Iris Kay Snodgrass. They got married in July 1982. Both had worked as salaried employees for Alcoa. They were married for about 23 years, and both reportedly participated in employer-provided 401(k) plans. Before their wedding day, his 401(k) account was valued at $54,000, meanwhile, hers was valued at $17,000 in her retirement account.They had both continued contributing to their accounts throughout their marriage. Alcoa had also continued to make employer contributions.
ALSO READ: A UPS worker who never earned more than $14,000 a year kept buying company stock; here's what happened to his $70 million retirement fortune
However, they later filed for divorce. Notably, Iris filed for divorce in February 2005. By the time this was all done, Robert's 401(k) grew approximately $2.301 million. Meanwhile, Iris's account reportedly reached $691,000.
What happened in the court?
The trial court awarded each spouse the premarital balance of his and her 401(k) as separate property. The court classified all gains during the marriage as marital property. It divided this as marital deferred compensation. However, Robert challenged the decision.ALSO READ: A 77-year-old billionaire took over bankrupt Japan Airlines for no salary; within 2 years it was among the world's most profitable airlines, and the state doubled its money
Later, the Tennessee Court of Appeals took his side. It allowed the possibility that gains that were attributable to premarital balances could be separated as individual property.
Notably, the Tennessee Supreme Court upheld the trial court's decision. It reversed the appeals court ruling on the treatment of retirement account gains. The court ruled against Robert, and sided with the trial judge, saying that the money Robert and Iris had saved before marriage belonged to them individually. However, the gains earned during the marriage had to be shared.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.