Heisman winner Desmond Howard casts a serious doubt over Jeremiah Smith’s credentials to join the elite list, points out lack of season-defining games but gets countered by Robert Griffin III
As a prominent frontrunner for the Heisman Trophy, Jeremiah Smith has stirred debate about his performance in critical games. Analyst Desmond Howard raised concerns about Smith's effectiveness in tough matchups, while Robert Griffin III countered ...

FILE - Ohio State head coach Ryan Day and Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith (4) celebrate after defeating Notre Dame during the College Football Playoff national championship game, on Jan. 20, 2025, in Atlanta. (AP Photo/Jacob Kupferman, File)
According to former Heisman winner and Michigan Alum, Desmond Howard, the answer is no. While Howard acknowledged that Smith had impressive numbers and unreal athleticism, he argued that the Ohio State star has failed to deliver in season-defining games. In his eyes, Smith hasn’t been enough of a difference-maker when the stakes are at their highest.
“In the last two years, give me one game where Jeremiah Smith, the wide receiver of Ohio State, was a difference maker in big games in the last two years. As much as puts up magnificent numbers and these one-handed catches, I need moments against the top competition that makes me say- he was the guy”
However, another former Heisman winner and ex- NFL QB, Robert Griffin III, has come to Smith’s defense. RG3 accused Howard of making dubious attempts to malign the Buckeyes wide receiver.
ALSO READ: Tiger Woods to make a return to competitive gold after two years: Here’s a look into his career earnings, a huge part of the golfer’s $1.5 billion net worth
According to Griffin, Smith deserves the Heisman Trophy if Ohio State wins its remaining games. His numbers and resume, RG3 believes, already makes a strong case for the prestigious award.
Smith was also instrumental in Ohio State’s run to the National Championship as a freshman, producing big performances against ranked opponents such as Tennessee, Oregon, and Notre Dame. He has also set multiple FBS and Big Ten records during his career.
For Griffin, there is little doubt that Smith is the best player in the country and deserves the Heisman Trophy. While acknowledging Howard’s status as a college football legend, RG3 believes he needs to stop “hating” and recognize Smith’s greatness.
Griffin believes that Ohio State Star should win the Heisman, the odds too favor him.
Is Jeremiah Smith still the favorite to win the Heisman Trophy? What are his odds?
In each of his three seasons with the Buckeyes, Smith has crossed the 1,000-yard mark. His college tally of 232 receptions, 3,758 yards, and 41 touchdowns is an all-time college football record. Besides that, he is also a national champion, has earned All-American honors twice, and was twice voted Big Ten Receiver of the Year.While the Buckeyes have struggled with consistency this season, Smith has continued to produce at an elite level. Before Week 11, he had already recorded 69 receptions for 1,200 yards and 14 receiving touchdowns. Even if he doesn’t take the field again before entering the NFL Draft, Smith appears to be the favorite to be selected No. 1 overall, with many considering him the best prospect in college football.
Given his production, it was hardly surprising that Smith entered the season as Heisman Award favorite. He remained atop the odds for much of the campaign, but Ohio State’s losses hurt his chances and eventually pushed him down to third behind C.J. Carr and Darian Mensah.
However, the Heisman race has shifted again following week 11. Smith delivered another impressive performance against Northwestern, hauling in 11 passes for 117 yards and one TD. His latest outing has propelled him back to the top of the Heisman race, with odds ranging from -144 to -160, implying roughly a 60% chance of winning the award.
Smith has now surged ahead of Mensah, who was the favorite last week but has slipped to +350 odds, giving him an implied 18 percent chance of winning the Heisman. Devon Dampier has moved into third at +550, while Carr has fallen to fourth at +1100.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.