San Antonio landlord wins $33,243 from HOA after parking lot confrontation with tenant's assistant: What led to the three-year legal battle?
A San Antonio landlord has won a $33,243 judgment against her HOA after a dispute over rental restrictions escalated into a nearly three-year legal battle. The case involved a proposed short-term rental ban, a parking lot confrontation with her te...

San Antonio landlord wins $33,243 from HOA after parking lot confrontation with tenant's assistant: What led to the three-year legal battle? (Photo: iStock)
Luna owned a rental townhome at Oaks Northwest, a community of just 11 homes near the San Antonio Medical Center. She bought the property when there were no rental restrictions and provided housing to long term residents and traveling professionals.
The dispute began when HOA president Terri Thomure pushed to prohibit short-term rentals. What followed affected Luna's efforts to find a long-term tenant and eventually sell the property.
San Antonio HOA's Proposed Rental Ban Was Declared Void
According to Luna's lawsuit, filed in Bexar County's 438th District Court, Thomure called a special meeting in March 2023 to approve a ban on short-term rentals, as per a Ksat report.But the meeting did not meet Texas law's notice requirements. Court records showed that the proposed amendment was void.
Luna said she tried to comply with the proposed restriction anyway, arranging a 12-month lease with a long-term tenant. The agreement, however, fell apart after an encounter involving the tenant's assistant.
Parking Lot Confrontation Led Tenant to Cancel Lease
Court documents state that Thomure approached the tenant's assistant in the community parking lot without identifying herself. She demanded the assistant's personal identification information and asked about the reason for the visit.The tenant canceled the lease days after the encounter.
The disagreement continued when Luna tried to sell the townhome. The HOA filed a legal claim against the property in an effort to block the sale, but a judge later dismissed it.
Luna eventually sold the unit in May 2024 and continued her legal case against the association and its president.
She highlighted that the experience made her question how much power the HOA was exercising over homeowners.
Luna said, “What was going through my head when all of this was happening is the abuse of power of the homeowners association,” adding, “I’ve seen online and on the broadcast multiple stories about homeowners associations running amok — boards not following rules and harassing and making homeowners’ lives difficult,” as quoted by Ksat.
Judge Orders HOA and Its President to Pay More Than $33,000
The case reached a conclusion in May 2026, when Bexar County District Judge Monique Diaz ruled in Luna's favor.The HOA was ordered to pay $10,743.39 in damages and $10,000 in attorney's fees. Thomure was personally ordered to pay another $12,500 for tortious interference with Luna's rental contract.
Together, the awards amounted to $33,243.39. Luna confirmed that both the association and Thomure had paid.
Looking back on the lengthy dispute, Luna pointed out that going to court was her only option.
She said, “My only recourse after that was to take them to court. And so that’s what I did. And it was a three-year battle,” adding, “But overall, the judge saw the truth, and we prevailed,” as quoted by Ksat.
Luna Wants Homeowners to Challenge HOA Decisions
Luna hopes that the outcome sends a message to both homeowners and HOA board members as she wants residents who feel their associations are not following the rules to hold them accountable.She emphasised that, “If you find that your board members are not following the rules, hold them accountable. Hold them to a higher standard. Because often they abuse that power,” as quoted in the report.
Bexar County residents who want to file a civil lawsuit against their HOA can use different courts depending on the amount of the claim. Cases involving less than $10,000 can be filed through a local justice of the peace court.
Larger claims can be filed through the Bexar County district clerk's office at 100 Dolorosa, Suite 104, San Antonio, Texas, 78205, or through the Texas e-filing website.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.