In 1952, a 19-year-old bought one of his father’s 5 dairy stores in Pennsylvania. His brother joined him. That store became Sheetz, with more than 800 locations
Bob Sheetz made a daring decision in 1952, purchasing a dairy store, and subsequently reinvented it into a successful convenience store chain. Though the early days were fraught with difficulties, introducing made-to-order food services changed th...

In 1952, a 19-year-old bought one of his father’s 5 dairy stores in Pennsylvania. His brother joined him. That store became Sheetz, with more than 800 locations [Image: Wikipedia]
Sheetz is still very much a privately held company and is still very much in the family. Growth has been achieved through a combination of fuel sales, convenience shopping and the made-to-order food, which has become such a key part of the business. The information is taken from Chowhound, Mental Floss and CSP.
How did Sheetz go from one dairy?
The company's origins actually go back even further than 1952. J.E. Harshbarger was supplying milk to Altoona in 1907 after he observed that the local dairy farmers were just throwing their surplus milk away. The business then passed to his son-in-law, Jerry Sheetz, who opened up five Sheetz Dairy Stores in 1941.Bob Sheetz bought one of those stores in 1952 and started building the business from there. His brother Steve joined him on a part-time basis in 1961. They opened their second store in 1963 and then progressively expanded into the grocery, deli and fuel areas.
The first gas pumps came in 1973. By 1983, they were at 100 stores, many of them running 24 hours a day.
The business was under financial pressure in the 1980s as it found it very difficult to compete with supermarket prices. The move into made-to-order food was the thing that changed the business.
A store manager called Earl Springer came up with the idea of putting in stations where the customer could actually select what they wanted in their sandwich. The first one cost $1,100 and it worked a treat. Sheetz went on to roll it out across the network under the well-known "I want my M.T.O." banner.
What made Sheetz different from the other convenience stores?
Made-to-order food became one of the chain's biggest draws. The menu subsequently expanded to include burgers, hot dogs, tacos, wraps and all sorts of other items, as well as some rather odd fried items such as Oreos and mac and cheese balls.Sheetz were also early adopters of the touchscreen ordering system. The first Sheetz store to have a touchscreen was in Altoona in 1994, and it quickly became standard across the chain.
Who owns Sheetz today?
Sheetz is still a privately held family business. As per the figures provided by Chowhound, the Sheetz family own approximately 90% of the company, with the employees holding the balance.Leadership has gone through a number of generations. Steve Sheetz became President and CEO following Bob's retirement in 1984. Subsequently, a number of other family members took on senior leadership roles (Stan and Joe Sheetz, to name but two). Travis Sheetz has been CEO since 2022.
The company continued to expand in 2024 with the addition of a Michigan location. At the start of 2025, it had 770 stores in PA, MI, NC, VA, WV, OH and MD. Later figures from Chowhound describe the network as being well over 800 stores. Its expansion plans have included new stores in Ohio and western PA as well as a distribution centre in Findlay, Ohio, due to be completed in 2026. From a single dairy store in Altoona to a chain with operations in seven states, the Sheetz story is still very much a family story.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.