A Colorado man reopened his divorce to cut his ex-wife’s pension share from $2,798 to $401 a month. An appeals court reversed it

A Colorado man sought to reopen a property settlement regarding his pension payment after his divorce. He argued the amount awarded to his ex-wife was based on a calculation error. The court found that the attorney's statement during the hearing d...

TIL Creatives
A Colorado man reopened his divorce to cut his ex-wife’s pension share from $2,798 to $401 a month. An appeals court reversed it
A Colorado divorce case took a bizarre turn when a man attempted to reopen his property settlement some years after the marriage had ended. He was arguing that his ex-wife had been awarded an excessive amount of his pension as a result of a simple calculation error. The difference was huge. He was asking for his monthly share to be reduced from $2,798 to $401. The Colorado Court of Appeals didn't buy it. They ruled that the divorce rules didn't allow him to go back and correct a mistake he could have challenged earlier. The inputs are taken from Graham Law.


Why did the husband want to change the pension payment?

The couple married in 2003 and divorced in 2016 (they had separated in 2010). Most of the issues were resolved, but there was a continuing dispute over the division of the husband's pension.


During the divorce, the wife was asking for half the marital portion of his pension. Her solicitor suggested a calculation based on about 6 years of the marriage divided by 17.5 years of pension service.

The husband didn't dispute the formula. The wife was awarded $2,798 per month on the formula which had been put forward at the hearing.

Neither side had a representative from the pension system to come in and explain the formula or confirm that the calculation was right.

ADVERTISEMENT
Several years later, the husband did in fact return to court. He was relying on Colorado Rule of Civil Procedure 16.2(e)(10), which permits a court to reevaluate the division of assets where there has been a material mistake or omission in the financial disclosure. That motion must be filed within five years of the final divorce decree.


What was the cause of the dispute over the pension calculation?

At the evidentiary hearing, the pension system rep explained that the wife's solicitor had omitted a crucial element of the calculation, namely the husband's age.

Once that factor was included, the wife's share of the marital portion was $401 a month rather than $2,798. The original award was therefore more than seven times the corrected figure.

The trial court accepted the husband's argument. It found that the attorney's explanation of the pension formula amounted to a disclosure misstatement and ordered a new Qualified Domestic Relations Order, or QDRO, reflecting the lower payment. The wife appealed the decision.
ADVERTISEMENT


Why did the Court of Appeal quash the decision?

The Colorado Court of Appeals took a different view and disagreed with the trial court. In its unpublished opinion, it held that an attorney's statement made at a hearing was not the equivalent of a financial disclosure under Rule 16.2. The ruling stated, "Although the parties to a dissolution of marriage case must provide each other with broad disclosures, under C.R.C.P. 16.2 and Form 35.1, an attorney’s statement during a hearing or other court proceeding does not substitute for, and is not the equivalent of, a ‘disclosure.'"

ADVERTISEMENT
The court also made it very clear that the rule wasn't intended to give either spouse a further opportunity to argue on an issue which had already been considered at the final orders hearing.

Importantly, the pension belonged to the husband. The judges noted that he had the same, if not a greater, responsibility to understand how his own retirement benefit should be valued. He could have contacted the pension system, reviewed its website or presented evidence at the original hearing.

The opinion made the point clear: "C.R.C.P. 16.2(e)(10) cannot rescue husband from the consequences of his own decisions to rely on wife’s attorney’s statement and not present evidence about his own pension."

His application was characterised by the court as an attempt to get a second bite at the cherry in respect of a decision which he could have appealed at an earlier stage. The court ultimately reinstated the original $2,798 monthly award. If that sum could not be placed into an order which the pension system would accept, the trial judge would have to find some other way of ensuring that the wife got her share.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › World › People › A Colorado man reopened his divorce to cut his ex-wife’s pension share from $2,798 to $401 a month. An appeals court reversed it
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+