They paid $175 for a gold necklace and got back $7.60: The undercover test that helped bring down a famous gold buyer
Cash4Gold's operations are under intense scrutiny following a probe showing that customers received a shocking 11% of the real value of their gold. Moreover, the company has initiated defamation lawsuits against ex-employees who raised alarms abou...

What did the Cash4Gold investigation uncover
Consumerist.com, led by co-executive editors Ben Popken and Meg Marco, spent months examining the company's operations. The investigation included interviews with former employees Michele Liberis and Vielka Nephew, Cash4Gold customers, the Better Business Bureau, the local fire department and the US Postal Service.The website also worked with its sister publication, Consumer Reports, to test the company's offers. The results suggested that customers could receive only a small fraction of what their jewellery was worth based on its gold content.
“The results reinforce advice we’ve offered before,” the Consumerist.com report says, “which is that consumers should not use these services because the payments they offer are too low. No matter how nice the person is who gives it to you, a bad deal is still a bad deal.” Cash4Gold, based in Fort Lauderdale, Florida, advertised that it paid "top dollar" for valuables sent in to be melted down. But the investigation questioned whether those promises matched the offers customers received.
Why did Cash4Gold take legal action against critics
The company also came under scrutiny for its response to online criticism. It added Consumerist.com and ComplaintsBoard.com to lawsuits already filed against two former employees, Liberis and Nephew.That article drew on anonymous comments Liberis had posted on ComplaintsBoard.com. She had previously worked in Cash4Gold's customer service department and described how the company handled payments to customers.
Consumerist.com said its reporting supported the decision to publish the post. It also found evidence backing parts of Liberis' account of the company's practices and working conditions.
However, the investigation did not accept every claim without qualification. Liberis had said the company was temporarily shut down because of health and code violations. Cash4Gold disputed that account. Fire department records confirmed that its premises had been closed after violations the previous year, but showed no new violations after the business moved to another address.
What happened when reporters sought the company's response
Consumers Union also tried to get Cash4Gold to address the findings. Marc Perton, the organization's executive editor for online media, said the team had investigated the company's allegations and requested further information.“We follow-up on such challenges conscientiously,” Perton said, “and so we immediately set out to learn whether the company’s allegations had merit, both through our own research and through requests to Cash4Gold for more information.”
According to Consumerist.com, the company declined to cooperate and cancelled a scheduled interview with CEO Jeff Aronson. The scrutiny did not end with the investigation. A separate class-action lawsuit was filed on October 6 in the US District Court for the Central District of California against Green Bullion Financial Services LLC, Cash4Gold's parent company. The complaint was brought on behalf of two California women who had previously used the service. Their attorneys asked the court to expand the case to include other customers who claimed they had been harmed by the company's practices.
Cash4Gold's promises of high payments had helped attract customers. But the investigation and legal complaints put the gap between those promises and the actual offers under a much brighter spotlight.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.