Schwab compared 5 ways to invest $2,000 a year for 20 years: One investor made $186,077 by buying at market lows, while another who kept waiting for the perfect moment got just $47,357
Best time to invest in the stock market: A Charles Schwab study tracking five hypothetical investors over 20 years found that waiting for stock prices to fall could be costly. The investor who stayed in cash finished with just $47,357, while even ...

Schwab compared 5 ways to invest $2,000 a year for 20 years: One investor made $186,077 by buying at market lows, while another who kept waiting for the perfect moment got just $47,357 (Photo: iStock)
The Schwab Center for Financial Research compared five hypothetical investors, each receiving $2,000 at the beginning of every year from 2005 to 2024. They followed different investment strategies with the S&P 500 used to track stock market performance.
It found that the investor who bought at the lowest market level every year finished first. But the person who invested as soon as the money arrived was not far behind. Those who kept buying stocks, even at the wrong time, ended up with considerably more than the person who stayed out of the market.
Stock market timing study: The investor who kept waiting finished with $47,357
Larry Linger was convinced that stock prices would eventually fall, giving him a better opportunity to invest. Each year, he kept his $2,000 in cash investments, with Treasury bills used as a proxy. He never bought stocks.By the end of 20 years, Larry had accumulated $47,357.
Rosie Rotten, meanwhile, seemed to have the worst possible luck. She invested her $2,000 at the S&P 500's highest closing point every year. Yet she finished with $151,343, or $103,986 more than Larry.
That was the gap between buying stocks at the worst possible time each year and never buying them at all.
Stock market investment strategies: The five investors ended with very different amounts
Peter Perfect came out on top, but his strategy required extraordinary timing. He invested each year's $2,000 at the S&P 500's lowest closing point. His final balance reached $186,077.Ashley Action did not wait for a market dip. She invested the full $2,000 on the first trading day of each year and ended with $170,555. That was only $15,522 less than Peter.
Matthew Monthly took a slower approach, splitting his annual contribution into 12 equal investments at the beginning of each month. His dollar-cost averaging strategy produced $166,591.
Rosie finished with $151,343, while Larry brought up the rear with $47,357.
Ashley came surprisingly close to Peter without having to predict when the market would hit its lowest point. Her approach was to invest when she received the money.

S&P 500 investment returns: The pattern appeared in other 20 year periods too
Schwab didn't limit its research to 2005 to 2024. It examined 80 rolling 20-year periods dating back to 1926.In 70 of those periods, the five investors finished in exactly the same order, Peter first, Ashley second, Matthew third, Rosie fourth and Larry last.
The other 10 periods produced some changes, but investing immediately never finished last. Ashley came second four times, third five times and fourth once, during 1962–1981. Schwab said the second-, third- and fourth-place results in that period were virtually tied.
The firm also examined all possible 30-, 40- and 50-year periods beginning in 1926. The same broad pattern held: perfect timing came first, followed by investing immediately or spreading investments across the year. Buying at annual market highs came next, while keeping money out of stocks finished last.
Investing advice: Schwab's research makes the case against waiting
The market rose in 75.6% of typical 12-month periods, according to Schwab's analysis of 1,177 rolling one-year periods from January 1926 through December 2024.That helps explain why Ashley's decision to invest at the beginning of each year worked better than Matthew's monthly approach in this comparison. Ashley put the full amount into the market earlier, while Matthew spread his purchases across the year.
Schwab's advice is to decide how much stock market exposure fits an investor's goals and risk tolerance, make a plan and start investing rather than keep waiting for a market bottom.
People who are uncomfortable investing a lump sum can consider dollar-cost averaging. Regular investments may make it easier to get started and stick to a plan. However, the approach does not guarantee profits or protect against losses. When prices rise throughout the year, spreading investments over time can also mean paying more on average and missing potential gains.
Schwab described the exercise as a hypothetical illustration. It assumed dividends and interest were reinvested but did not include taxes, fees or expenses. The firm also cautioned that past performance does not guarantee future results.
In this comparison, the investor who bought at the market's annual highs still finished far ahead of the one who kept waiting. That was the cost of never getting into the market.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.