Had $100,000 in funds? Bad timing may have cost you about $27,000 over 10 years: The mistake most investors make
Poor investment timing cost US fund investors $3.8 trillion over a decade, Morningstar estimates. The average investor earned 8.7% annually, below funds’ 9.9% return. On a $100,000 investment, that difference could mean roughly $27,000 less over 1...

Morningstar tracked nearly 23,000 US open-end funds and exchange-traded funds. The 9.9% figure assumes one lump-sum purchase at the start. The 8.7% figure, which Morningstar calls the investor return, reflects what people actually did. The 1.2 percentage point difference is the “investor return gap.” It comes from the timing and size of their purchases and sales of fund shares.
The gap equals about 12% of the funds’ total return. On $100,000, the difference is easy to see. At 9.9% a year, that money grows to roughly $257,000 in 10 years. At 8.7%, it grows to roughly $230,000. The gap is about $27,000.
The industry-wide numbers are larger. On Jan. 1, 2016, the funds in the study held about $13.6 trillion. Had that money been left alone at 9.9% a year, it would have grown to nearly $35 trillion. On Dec. 31, 2025, the funds held $29.7 trillion. Morningstar says the shortfall is largely explained by about $3.8 trillion in estimated timing effects. In other words, poorly timed trades cost investors nearly $4 trillion over the decade.
Morningstar can’t say where the money moved. Jeffrey Ptak, the firm’s managing director, explained how the gap works. The greater the return gap between what an investor sells and what they buy, the more dollar-weighted returns can differ from total returns. Done well, that could help investors beat their funds. Done badly, the gap widens. One example is moving to cash just as stocks are bottoming.
Ptak found a link between how volatile investor flows are and how large the gaps are. He told Institutional Investor by email that “the less trading that allocators do, the more of their funds’ total returns they’re likely to capture.”
US stock fund investors did better
The picture was better for US stock funds and ETFs. The average dollar invested in them gained 12.8% a year. The funds’ aggregate return was 13.3%. The gap was 0.5 percentage points, well below the 1.2 points seen across all funds.US equity funds were also the largest group at the start of the study. They held $5.8 trillion in net assets on Dec. 31, 2015. Over the next 10 years, their investors compounded more than $12.0 trillion in income and gains. Ptak wrote that this was “arguably the largest haul in any decade in fund history.”
The report’s summary line says crypto investors stumbled. The material here gives no figures for that. Ptak’s reading of the stock fund result was short: investors may be getting better at sitting still.
How investors can narrow the gap
Retail investors can use dollar-cost averaging or a systematic withdrawal plan. Under dollar-cost averaging, money goes in on a fixed schedule instead of on a view about the market. Some strategies also automate routine tasks like rebalancing. Institutions can hold fewer funds, and pick diversified ones that hold hundreds of stocks.Ptak added that the findings apply more to allocators than to individuals. Institutions are less likely to use all-in-one strategies. Individuals have done better in standalone vehicles than in the building blocks institutions tend to prefer.
Institutions are moving toward ETFs, which come with low fees, strong liquidity and operational efficiency. Research from Cerulli Associates found that asset owners nearly doubled their ETF use over the past five years. Their ETF assets reached $337 billion in 2025. Nearly half of the institutions using ETFs plan to raise their allocations over the next two years.
Mack Kline, who heads endowments, foundations and healthcare at J.P. Morgan Asset Management, sees more institutions moving into ETFs. Many are choosing active funds across equity and fixed income. “There’s daily liquidity and pricing is attractive, even for non-profit institutions of significant scale that historically relied on separately managed accounts,” Kline said.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.