A New York man said 9 years of pre-marriage Navy service were his alone. The top court ruled marital money made them shared, giving his ex-wife a cut
In a notable New York divorce case, the court made a significant ruling on the division of retirement benefits. A man argued that his nine years of service in the Navy should be classified as his separate property. However, the court concluded tha...

How did premarital Navy service become part of the pension?
John Szypula joined the Navy in 1987 at the age of 22. He married Meredith Szypula nine years later and left the military in 1998. Since he had not completed the 20 years of service normally required for military retirement benefits, he did not qualify for a Navy pension when he left. He later spent 14 years working in the private sector before joining the Foreign Service in 2012. As a military veteran, he had the option of adding his previous years of service to his Foreign Service Pension System (FSPS) benefits by making contributions.Between 2012 and 2018, part of his earnings went towards buying those credits. The total cost was $9,158, paid using funds earned during the marriage. The couple divorced in 2019, but they could not agree on whether the pension value linked to his nine years of premarital Navy service belonged solely to him or should be divided between them.
Why did the courts disagree over the pension?
A New York Supreme Court justice initially ruled that the pension rights linked to the Navy service were marital property. The couple had used marital money to buy back the service credits, making the resulting pension benefit subject to equitable distribution. The Appellate Division later reversed that decision. It considered the original Navy credits to be the husband's separate property because they came from his own work before the marriage. However, it agreed that the money spent during the marriage to purchase those credits could be divided. The case was sent back for the court to calculate the appropriate amount.Ms. Szypula appealed, taking the dispute to the New York Court of Appeals.
What did New York's highest court decide?
The Court of Appeals reversed the Appellate Division's ruling. Chief Judge Rowan D. Wilson explained that the original military service and the pension rights created through marital contributions had to be treated separately.When Mr. Szypula left the Navy, his nine years of service were separate property. But those years alone did not give him a pension. He still needed to make payments through a later retirement plan to turn the credits into pension rights.
Wilson wrote: “Mr. and Ms. Szypula used marital funds to convert those 11 years of Navy service, including the nine years he worked prior to marriage, into additional value to Mr. Szypula’s Foreign Service pension. The pension rights at issue in this case are therefore the product of both his pre-marriage service and the Szypulas’ contribution of marital assets,”
“The investment was an investment of marital property, and the resulting asset is marital,” Wilson wrote.
A separate-property credit may still be possible
The ruling does not prevent Mr. Szypula from seeking credit for the value of his original Navy pension credits. However, he must prove what those credits were worth when they were used to create the Foreign Service pension benefit. The Court of Appeals sent the case back to Supreme Court for further proceedings and calculation of the amount due to Ms. Szypula. It ruled that the pension rights linked to the nine years of premarital service were marital property in their entirety. The information is taken from NY Daily Record.The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.