Old I Bonds pay just 4.08% vs new Bonds at 5.51%: Should you cash out before losing more money?
Old I bonds vs new I bonds: New Series I savings bonds offer a 5.51% annualized rate, compared with 4.08% for older bonds with a zero fixed rate after the latest inflation adjustment. But cashing out to chase higher returns could trigger a three-m...

Old I Bonds pay just 4.08% vs new Bonds at 5.51%: Should you cash out before losing more money?
The difference is largely down to the fixed interest rate. New bonds come with 1.40% fixed rate that stays unchanged for the life of the investment. And older bonds with a zero fixed rate don't get that extra return.
Investors who redeem before holding their bonds for five years lose last 3 months of interest. They may also have to pay federal income tax on interest accumulated over years.
New I Bonds Come With a 5.51% Rate
The US Treasury set the composite annual rate for I bonds issued between November 1, 2026, and April 30, 2027, at 5.51%. The previous rate was 4.26% for bonds issued between May and October 2026.The new rate consists of a 1.40% fixed component and a 4.08% annualized inflation component. The fixed portion remains unchanged throughout the bond's 30 year interest bearing life. The inflation component is reviewed every six months and can move up or down.
The 5.51% rate applies for the first six months after a bond is issued. Investors should not assume they will continue earning the same rate in subsequent periods because future returns depend partly on inflation.
Treasury uses a formula combining the fixed & inflation components to calculate the final rate.
Why Older I Bonds Pay a Lower Rate
The return on an I bond depends on the fixed rate it received when it was issued and the inflation adjustment that applies during its current 6 month period.Older bonds with zero fixed rate miss out on additional 1.40% offered to new buyers. Once latest inflation adjustment reaches those bonds, their composite annual rate becomes 4.08%.
However existing bondholders will not all see the change on November 1. Each bond follows a six month adjustment schedule based on its original issue month. So investors need to check their bond's issue date to find out when the new inflation rate will apply.
The comparison also applies only to older bonds with a zero fixed rate. Those issued with a positive fixed rate have different returns.
When It May Be Worth Switching to New I Bonds
The 1.40% fixed rate is the biggest attraction for investors considering a switch. It remains in place even when the inflation-linked portion changes. Giving new bonds a return component that older zero fixed rate bonds lack.That could appeal to people planning to leave their money invested for several years. But the higher rate alone doesn't tell investors whether cashing out is a good idea. As they also need to account for the interest they could lose and any taxes triggered by redemption.
There may be another reason to withdraw the money. SuperMoney pointed out a credit card debt carrying interest rates of around 22% as an example Using savings to reduce such debt could be more beneficial than continuing to earn roughly 4% on an older bond.
Cashing Out Before Five Years Means Losing Three Months of Interest
I bonds can't be redeemed during their first 12 months. Investors who cash them out before five year mark also forfeit final three months of interest.SuperMoney estimated that the penalty could cost around $100 when redeeming a $10000 bond earning about 4%. But the actual amount will depend on the bond's value & interest rate.
There is another restriction to remember. A newly purchased I bond also can't be redeemed during its first 12 months.
Federal Taxes Can Make Switching More Expensive
Interest earned on I bonds is generally subject to federal income tax. Investors can usually defer reporting it until they redeem bond or it reaches final maturity, although some choose to report the interest annually.The interest is exempt from state & local income taxes. Certain investors may also qualify for the federal tax exclusion when using the proceeds for eligible higher education expenses, provided they meet the IRS requirements.
SuperMoney illustrated that the tax impact with an example of a bond that grows from $5000 to $8000. The $3000 increase represents accumulated interest. At a 22% federal tax rate, the tax would be $660 if the entire amount were taxable at that rate.
The actual tax bill depends on the investor's circumstances and eligibility for any exclusions. Those who have held their bonds for several years should check the accumulated interest before redeeming.
Should You Keep Your Old I Bonds/ Cash Them Out
The new 5.51% rate gives recent I bonds an advantage over older bonds with a zero fixed rate once latest inflation adjustment applies. Still selling an older bond just to get a higher rate may not leave investors with more money.Those facing a three month interest penalty or a sizeable tax bill need to weigh those costs against the additional return. So investors who don't need their savings may find it better to keep their existing bonds rather than trigger an immediate expense.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.