Rs 4.10 crore cash, Rs 8.11 crore jewellery seized by I-T dept: Businessman challenges tax action and wins in ITAT Bangalore

A businessman Mr Amarlal challenged the Income Tax Department's seizure of Rs 4.1 crore in cash and Rs 8.11 crore worth of jewellery. Presenting his argument at the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, Amarlal successfully demonstrated that these assets...

ET Online

Businessman faces income tax action over ₹4.10 crore cash and ₹8.11 crore jewellery seizure; how he won in ITAT Bangalore

On July 20, 2018, the Income Tax Department searched Mr Amarlal’s home on J.C. Road and his locker. Officials seized Rs 3.9 crore cash from his locker, and Rs 20 lakh from the house .

The search also uncovered jewelry worth Rs 8.11 crore in the locker including 751.52 grams of gold and 81.470 karats of diamond. The jewelry was seized. Two watches worth Rs 16.25 lakh were also found in the locker and seized.

Based on the seizures, the Income Tax Assessing Officer from Bengaluru treated Rs 4.1 crore as unexplained cash under Section 69A and sought to tax it at a special rate. The AO asked Amarlal to explain the jewelry and diamonds. Although he provided an explanation, the AO was not convinced and deemed those as unexplained assets as well.


Amarlal also tried to tell the AO that he had filed his income tax return (ITR) declaring Rs 19.26 crore income, including Rs 18.11 crore as his business income.

Amarlal also told the AO that the cash seized by the Income Tax Department from his locker came from his previous years’ business income earned from real estate commission and money lending activities. Amarlal said the cash seized from his house belonged to various members of the family.

Also read: Income Tax Dept seized gold, diamonds and silver in a tax search operation from lady’s house and bank locker; she wins case in ITAT Mumbai

The AO did not accept these explanations.

Regarding the gold and diamond jewelry , Amarlal explained that he had already included the value of the jewelry and the watches in the business income reported for the previous year. He also submitted that the jewelry found in the locker was already reported in the wealth tax return filed by him and his family members.

As for the seized watches, Amarlal said those were gifted to him by his sister and he had also included their value in his ITR as business income.

The AO did not accept the explanations and treated the value of the jewelry and watches as unexplained investment under Section 69.
ADVERTISEMENT

Amarlal took the help of Chartered Accountant Suman Lunkar and filed an appeal in the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) Bangalore. On November 3, 2026, Amarlal won the case in ITAT Bangalore but the tribunal allowed the Income Tax Department to treat the seized cash as his business income.

Also read: ₹16 lakh jewellery, ₹3.88 lakh cash treated as unexplained income; here’s why the taxpayer wins at ITAT Hyderabad
ADVERTISEMENT

Why did Amarlal win the case in ITAT Bangalore?

Chartered Accountant Rohhit Saluja said to ET Wealth Online: ITAT, Bangalore Bench, has held that the cash and jewellery which were confiscated during search by Income Tax Department, cannot be assumed to be black money or black investment for purposes of sections 69 and 69A of Income-tax Act, 1961.

Saluja says that there were five key reasons for the ITAT's decision:

  • Several circumstances have been considered by the Tribunal. Mr Amarlal has clearly indicated the nature of the cash in question in the statement recorded under Section 132(4). The audited accounts and income tax returns reveal that the main source of income for Amarlal is business activity. In the concerned assessment year, the cash and jewellery seized have been included under Amarlal's business income.
  • Further, the previous wealth tax returns in Assessment Year 2015-16 establish that Mr Amarlal had disclosed jewellery in the past. Further, an affidavit of withdrawal was filed on 23rd July, 2018 (only three days after the search) before a Notary. However, the Assessing Officer has not provided any independent evidence to show that the assets seized are not derived from business activity.
  • Hence, it has been decided by ITAT Bangalore that the assets seized must be treated as business income. Therefore, they will be taxed at regular rates and would not attract special rates under section 115BBE. Hence, the appeal is allowed. The appeal was allowed.

How should taxpayers deal with an income-tax search and give statements to avoid future litigation?

Saluja says that this case provides an important lesson: Record of assets found during a search must align with the taxpayer’s financial position, accounting records and documentation. Oath is taken when making a declaration under section 132 (4). You should ensure that information provided in declarations is correct. Avoid making careless or inaccurate disclosures.

Saluja says: "For jewellery, keep invoices showing purchase price, inheritance information, and gifts, and previous disclosures to confirm ownership and origin. If you are in business, keep audited accounts, income tax returns and information to back up the transactions to confirm cash amounts."

If an inaccurate disclosure has been made, you should correct or withdraw it as soon as possible. Give clear reasons for withdrawal and evidence to support the correction. A withdrawal without supporting evidence may not be enough.

When asked should taxpayers accept or deny seized cash and assets? Saluja said that in general, you should not accept or decline the status of assets as unexplained. Depending on the status of the assets, as outlined below, consideration should be given to:

Although not all assets found in a search will be considered unexplained income, due to the statutory presumptions in section 292C, and weight of statements in section 132(4), it is important to have a realistic explanation for these assets supported by evidence.

ITAT Bangalore discussion

The ITAT Bangalore noted that audited financial statements showed Amarlal earned most of his income from business. The business books also included the cash and jewellery seized during the search.

Amarlal had also vouched for the seized cash and jewellery items while giving his statement and his notarised retraction affidavit. ITAT Bangalore observed that in the notarised retraction affidavit, Amarlal explained that he had been unable to provide details about the jewelry during the search. However, he and his family members had disclosed this jewelry in the returns filed under the Wealth Tax Act.

ITAT Bangalore ruled that Amarlal could prove that he has business income and the cash found and the jewelries seized were shown as business income and reported in the ITR he filed for A.Y. 2019-20. The supporting documents and evidence also supported Amarlal’s story.

ITAT Bangalore observed that the AO had no other material evidence to show that Amarlal was earning any other income which could be treated as other income liable to be taxed under Section 69 and 69A.

The copies of the wealth tax returns of the assessee as well as the family members would support the fact that the jewelry were declared in the wealth tax returns.

ITAT Bangalore also held that Amarlal’s answers given in the 132(4) statement also supported his story. Therefore, it was evident that Amarlal was earning business income and therefore, the seizures made at the time of search should be added as business income.

ITAT Bangalore accepted the plea made by Amarlal that the cash and jewelry seized during the search should be allowed to be shown as business income and taxed at normal rates and not at the special rate for unexplained income.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Tax › Rs 4.10 crore cash, Rs 8.11 crore jewellery seized by I-T dept: Businessman challenges tax action and wins in ITAT Bangalore
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+