Retired employee gets Rs 8.09 lakh tax demand on Rs 22.47 lakh leave encashment; wins case in ITAT Jaipur

Mr. Jain, having retired from the Reserve Bank of India, was granted Rs 22.47 lakh as leave encashment. However, the Income Tax Department initially imposed a tax demand of Rs 8.09 lakh. Following his appeal, the ITAT Jaipur ruled in favor of Jain...

ET Online

Retired employee was sent Rs 8.09 lakh tax demand notice by Income Tax Dept for Rs 22.47 lakh leave encashment; he wins case in ITAT Jaipur

When Mr Jain from Jammu retired from the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), he received Rs 22.47 lakh in leave encashment and claimed full income tax exemption on the amount while in his income tax return (ITR). His ITR was processed and the tax exemption on leave encashment claim was allowed . However, the Income Tax Assessing Officer (AO) from Jaipur selected Jain’s ITR for review and restricted his tax exemption claim to Rs 3 lakh and added Rs 19.47 lakh to Jain’s salary income.

As a direct result of this action, Jain’s total income increased to Rs 69.86 lakh and a tax demand of Rs 8.09 lakh was raised. After receiving the tax notice, Jain was shocked and decided to file an appeal against this order.

On October 30, 2026, Jain won the case in ITAT Jaipur. T.R. Senthil Kumar, Judicial Member and Prakash, Accountant Member of ITAT Jaipur, heard this case. Thus Mr Jain can now get the full income tax exemption on his Rs 22.47 lakh leave encashment.


Also read: Rs 8.02 lakh leave encashment tax exemption denied: Retired employee wins case in ITAT Surat

How is leave encashment taxed for non-govt employees?

If you are receiving leave encashment money during active service then note that it is fully taxable as salary in the year of receipt. Section 10(10AA) applies only to leave encashment at retirement, so there is no tax exemption during service.

The situation changes when you get leave encashment after retirement. Under section 10(10AA)(ii), the tax exemption is the least of:

  • the amount actually received;
  • the cash equivalent of unavailed leave, at a maximum of 30 days for each year of service with that employer;
  • ten months’ average salary, based on the ten months before retirement; and
  • the notified limit, now Rs 25 lakh vide 2023 Notification
Karanjot Singh Khurana, Partner, DMD Advocates, said to ET Wealth Online: "The least of the aforesaid amounts is taxable as salary. If the assessee has received leave encashment from earlier employers, the exemption utilised against sums received from earlier employees is factored and only the balance exemption is allowed on each retirement."

Also read: Retired bank employee claims tax exemption on Rs 9.53 lakh leave encashment, faces income tax notice and wins full relief at ITAT Jaipur

Why did Mr Jain win the case?

Khurana says: Section 10(10AA)(ii) of the Income Tax Act, 1961 exempts leave encashment received on retirement by an employee other than a Central or State Government employee, subject to a limit notified by the Central Government “having regard to the limit applicable” to its own employees. As the power to notify limit of exemption is tied to the salary payable to government employees, the ceiling is a derived figure and not one chosen capriciously.

The tax exemption limit of leave encashment for the purpose of section 10(10AA)(ii) was fixed at Rs 3 lakh in 2002. The notified amount was ten months of the then highest monthly Government salary of Rs 30,000. Once the highest pay was increased to Rs 2.5 lakh from January 1, 2016 under the Seventh Pay Commission, ten months of that pay came out at Rs 25 lakh. Accordingly, the threshold was recently increased by the Central Government from Rs 3 lakh to Rs 25 lakh through a notification dated May 24, 2023 which was stated to have come into retrospective effect from April 1, 2023.
ADVERTISEMENT

Notably, in the past the notifications issued were applied retrospectively to confer benefit to employees retiring from an identified date which was closer to hike in entitlement for Government employees. However, unlike previous notifications, the increase in ceiling limit in 2023 notification was applied from a notified date (i.e. April 1, 2023) and was not relative to retirement date of the employees.

Also read: Retired employee gets income tax notice over Rs 9.29 lakh leave encashment; ITAT Jaipur cancels it and gives him full tax exemption, here's why
ADVERTISEMENT

The present case of the employee pertained to an exemption claim of leave encashment made by the Assessee for assessment year 2019-20 FY 2018-19 under Section 10(10AA)(ii). Notably, the employee had retired in FY 2018-19. The question which arose before the ITAT Jaipur was that whether the employee could claim an income tax exemption as per the threshold of Rs 25 lakh which had come into effect from April 1, 2023 i.e. whether the Notification would apply retrospectively for AY 2019-20.

ITAT Jaipur looked at the historical trend noted that every earlier revision of the threshold operated retrospectively by reference to the date of retirement. The tax tribunal therefore held that retrospective operation is the method by which the Central Government aligns the ceiling for other employees with the entitlement of the Government employees. The tax tribunal also observed that the last revision to entitlement of Government employees was made in respect of employees retiring from 01.01.2026 wherein the threshhold was fixed at Rs 25 Lakh.

However, the 2023 Notification issued for other employees has no retirement-date cut-off and is deemed in force from April 1, 2023 with an Explanatory Memorandum certifying that no one is adversely affected by its retrospective effect. Accordingly, the ITAT Jaipur held, that the Central Government has itself described it as retrospective, and seemingly the notification was intended to be applied with retrospective effect to the date when the threshold was enhanced for Government employees i.e. January 1, 2016.

Also read: Retired employee received income tax notice for Rs 9.04 lakh leave encashment; she wins case in ITAT Jaipur, know how leave encashment is taxed

Further, the ITAT Jaipur held that the Notification does not create the exemption, which Parliament has already granted, and only quantifies a ceiling on it. Building upon the same, the ITAT Jaipur stated that that the Central Government’s power to notify a limit, being inherently tied by the Act to the threshold applicable to its own employees, is derived from Government’s salary structure for its employees and not one chosen at will.

Khurana says that earlier notifications had always followed the said structure. Accordingly, the ITAT Jaipur held that the Notification shall apply retrospectively with effect from the date on which the salary of government employees was increased to Rs 2.5 lakh (i.e. January 1, 2016), and hence, employees who have retired after the said date shall be eligible to claim leave encashment exemption under Section 10(10AA)(ii) of the Act upto the increased threshold of Rs 25 lakh.

The employee retired in FY 2018-19, when Rs 25 lakh was already the limit applicable to Government employees (being after January 1, 2016), so ITAT Jaipur held that the limit applicable to the employee would be Rs 25 lakh and not Rs 3 lakh.

According to Khurana, ITAT Jaipur declined to follow the contrary view of the Chandigarh Bench of the ITAT, noting that the Jaipur Bench and several other Benches had consistently taken the same view as the one being rendered in the current judgement. It added that, even if two views were possible, the view favouring the assessee must be adopted.

Khurana says: "It is worth mentioning that while the Jaipur Bench has applied the notification retrospectively to 01.01.2016, a contrary order of Chandigarh ITAT suggests that the limit can be applied only with effect from 01st April 2023. It seems like the final word on this interpretation is yet to be spoken and the matter may reach out before higher forums."
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Tax › Retired employee gets Rs 8.09 lakh tax demand on Rs 22.47 lakh leave encashment; wins case in ITAT Jaipur
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+