Property seller accepts Rs 6.75 lakh cash, faces 100% income tax penalty; ITAT Chennai cancels penalty after hearing his explanation

Vijayasarathy's sale of his Chennai property for Rs 32 lakh included a cash component of Rs 6.75 lakh, leading to the Income Tax Department imposing a hefty 100% penalty for the transaction. However, after appealing to the ITAT Chennai and providi...

ET Online

Property seller accepts Rs 6.75 lakh cash, Income Tax Dept imposes 100% penalty on him; ITAT Chennai gives him relief from penalty after hearing his reason


Mr Vijayasarathy from K.K.Nagar got into problems with the Income Tax Department while selling his Chennai property for Rs 32 lakh to a senior citizen property buyer. The reason for this trouble is Vijayasarathy took Rs 6.75 lakh cash from this senior citizen property buyer while the remaining amount was taken in his bank account. This whole arrangement was disclosed in the sale deed also.


When asked why he accepted the cash, Vijayasarathy said that he urgently needed to sell his residential property and had asked a broker to find a buyer. The broker found a senior citizen buyer from Vellore and invited him to Chennai to view the property.


However, the senior citizen buyer had carried Rs 6.75 lakh cash with him and when he reached Chennai and saw Vijayasarathy’s property, he liked it and on the spot made an offer to him. To secure the deal, the buyer offered Rs 6.75 lakh in cash to Vijayasarathy as an advance. He told Vijayasarathy that he did not want to carry this cash back with him to Vellore and also didn’t want to defer the deal until he could arrange to pay via banking channels.

Vijayasarathy considered his immediate need for funds and the buyer’s circumstances. He also believed that if he refused to take cash, the senior citizen buyer would have to carry the Rs 6.75 lakh cash all the way to Vellore which could be risky. So, acting in good faith, Vijayasarathy accepted the cash and recorded the whole transaction in the sale deed and also disclosed the full transaction in his income tax return (ITR) thinking that this would satisfy the requirements of the Income Tax Act.

The total selling price of Vijayasarathy’s residential property was Rs 32 lakh and since he already took Rs 6.75 lakh in cash as advance, he took the remaining amount in his bank account and also recorded the full amount in his sale deed.

However, the Income Tax Assessing Officer (AO) acting on information received from the SRO, Virugambakkam and the registered sale deed, found that Vijayasarathy had violated the provisions of Section 269SS and accordingly sent him a notice. The AO ultimately levied a penalty of Rs 6.75 lakh on Vijayasarathy for accepting cash for selling property.

On October 7, 2026 Vijayasarathy won the case in ITAT Chennai. FCA S.Vidhya had represented him before ITAT Chennai.

How did Vijayasarathy win the case in ITAT Chennai

Talking to ET Wealth Online, Chartered Accountant Suresh Surana said : ITAT Chennai ruled that Section 269SS does not apply in this case and a violation of Section 269SS does not automatically mean that Section 271D is also violated.

ITAT Chennai examined the case to check if Vijayasarathy can get Section 273B relief which protects taxpayers who can establish a reasonable cause for failure to follow Income Tax Act provisions.
ADVERTISEMENT

Surana says that ITAT Chennai found several factors in favour of Vijayasarathy and that is why he ultimately won the case. The first of these factors was the fact that Vijayasarathy never concealed the cash and instead deposited it in his bank account and even recorded the cash aspect in his registered sale deed and paid capital gains tax on it by disclosing it in his ITR.

Surana says that these honest acts of Vijayasarathy supported his story that he genuinely believed the senior citizen buyer’s reason and so he took the cash. He never intended to suppress or conceal any information.
ADVERTISEMENT

ITAT Chennai also clarified that even though genuineness of the transaction or disclosure in sale deed about cash component are not enough evidence to establish reasonable cause but these factors become relevant when considered together with Vijayasarathy’s explanation regarding the immediate need for funds, and the senior citizen buyer’s circumstances and the bona fide belief under which the cash advance was accepted.

Looking at all these circumstances cumulatively, ITAT Chennai held that Vijayasarathy had shown reasonable cause within the meaning of Section 273B.

Accordingly, The ITAT Chennai cancelled the penalty imposed on Vijayasarathy for accepting cash while selling his property.

Surana says this judgement shows that if someone who took cash from property sales can prove and give the court a genuine, bona fide and reasonable explanation for the cash and also discloses this cash aspect in ITR, sale deed and other relevant documents, then Section 273B can protect you from penalty.

ITAT Chennai also observed that a “reasonable cause” is not confined only to cases involving extreme financial emergencies and it must be assessed on the facts and circumstances of each case.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Tax › Property seller accepts Rs 6.75 lakh cash, faces 100% income tax penalty; ITAT Chennai cancels penalty after hearing his explanation
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+