Landlady wanted to evict tenants to open her own ladies' tailor business but tenants resisted; she approached Delhi HC and won the case for this reason

In a case from Chandni Chowk, Mrs. Suri, a determined landlady, aimed to expel her tenants to broaden her tailoring venture. Despite resistance from the tenants, the Delhi High Court backed Suri's eviction claim. The court emphasized that tenants ...

ET Online

Tenants resisted eviction arguing landlady’s runs tailoring business from her home; Delhi HC orders tenant eviction and rules tenants cannot dictate landlady’s choice

A recent case shows how a landlady who owns four properties in Chandni Chowk had to file a legal case and take it up to the high court just to evict her tenants, so she could start a ladies tailoring business in one of the properties . The landlady, Mrs Suri, was running her ladies tailoring business from home for quite some time. As the business grew, she needed a larger space and so she requested the tenant, Mr Goel’s mother, to find another place and vacate her property.

Goel’s mother refused to vacate the property and instead told Suri to manage her ladies tailoring business from her home and leave this property for her as her livelihood was entirely dependent on this property and getting a similar property in this location was not possible at this moment.

Suri did not buy into this argument and filed a tenant eviction case (October 16, 2019) and was ultimately decided in her favour by the Delhi High Court on November 6, 2026.


Goel’s lawyer told the court that other than asserting that she needed this property for her ladies tailoring business and that she preferred a spot on the main road, Suri did not mention any other reason even though she used to carry out the same business from her residential home. On this ground, Goel claimed Suri’s need for this property was not bona fide.

Advocate O.P. Aggarwal, representing Suri, told the court that the tenant (Goel) should not dictate how or where Suri should run her tailoring business. The landlady, he argued, is the best judge of her own requirements.

Also read: Tenant refusing to vacate even after a court orders eviction? Here’s how landlords can enforce the order

Why did the landlady win the case?

Advocate Amitraj Kaushal practicing at the Supreme Court of India, said to ET Wealth Online: The landlady succeeded because she showed a genuine need for the shop to run her own tailoring business and earn her livelihood.

Kaushal says that the Delhi High Court held that a landlady is the best judge of her requirements, and a tenant cannot dictate how her own property is to be used. Also the fact that the landlady was already conducting her ladies tailoring business from her could not defeat her need for a proper commericial shop for this same business.

Delhi High Court discussion

Suri ha s categorically pleaded that she carrie s out tailoring work from her residence and require s the subject shop, situated on the main road at Nai Sarak, to carry on the said activity from a commercial location.

The Delhi High Court said that the fact that she has been able to conduct tailoring work from her residence does not establish that the residential premises are reasonably suitable for the commercial purpose now pleaded. The Delhi High Court also said that the fact that Suri’s son has a business in the same location and so her requirement is not bona fide is not true.
ADVERTISEMENT

Thus the Delhi High Court ruled that there are no grounds to interfere with Goel’s eviction order.

The Delhi High Court said that as per Section 14(1)(e) of the Delhi Rent Control Act, even if there exists another property it cannot by itself defeat a landlord's claim for tenant eviction. The reason for this is because the alternative accommodation must be available to the landlord and reasonably suitable for the requirement pleaded.
ADVERTISEMENT

In the case of M.M. Quasim v. Manohar Lal Sharma, the Hon‘ble Supreme Court held that where the tenant demonstrates the existence of vacant premises with the landlord, the Court must examine whether such premises are suitable for the purpose for which eviction is sought.

Moreover, the landlord's choice for getting a particular property evicted is not immune from scrutiny but at the same time it must be noted that a tenant cannot succeed solely by identifying another property of the landlord without establishing its availability and suitability in the context of the pleaded requirement. by the landlord.

Accordingly, the Delhi High Court dismissed the revision petition and affirmed the eviction order.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Legal / Will › Landlady wanted to evict tenants to open her own ladies' tailor business but tenants resisted; she approached Delhi HC and won the case for this reason
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+