Housing society hikes monthly maintenance by more than 3 times; Residents fight back and win relief as Maharashtra court puts increase on hold for this reason

A Maharashtra court intervened in a controversial maintenance fee hike within a housing society, halting an abrupt rise from Rs 7,867 to Rs 27,166. Homeowners Mr. Jayaswal and Mrs. Nalawade argued that the increase lacked sufficient justification ...

ET Online

Housing society increased maintenance from Rs 7,867 to Rs 27,166 for 1300 sq.ft. area flats; homeowners filed case; Maharashtra Court stops this increase

A recent judgement of the Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court shows how two home owners were made to pay nearly four times their monthly maintenance even though the society had not clearly explained how it calculated the increase.

The case concerns a housing society in Goregaon (West). Mr Jayaswal owns a flat D-101 and Mrs. Nalawade owns flat D-201. The society has four wings (A,B,C,D). It originally had 40 members, but after an approved redevelopment plan, the number of members increased to 215. There is a parking tower between C and D wings.

According to the redevelopment plan, there were only two flats in D wing measuring 1300 sq.ft each. These flats belong to Mr Jayaswal and Mrs. Nalawade. The redevelopment was completed in 2016 and on May 20, 2018, the housing society asked the flat owners to start paying society maintenance charges.


From 2018 to 2022, Jayaswal and Nalawade each paid Rs 7,867 in monthly maintenance charges. However, from 2022 onwards, the society said that the monthly maintenance amount needs to be increased to Rs Rs 27,166 and Rs 29,266 for both Mr Jayaswal and Mrs. Nalawade because it cost more to maintain the D wing.

Mr Jayaswal and Mrs. Nalawade argued that monthly maintenance should be calculated per flat and not wing wise and refused to pay the enhanced amount . They also said that since July 2022, the society removed the security service and housekeeping service of both of their flats.

On November 3, 2026, Mr Jayaswal and Mrs Nalawade won the interim case in the Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court as the court ordered the society to stop collecting the enhanced maintenance amount till the dispute was resolved.

Also read: Housing society increased maintenance fee of 6 homeowners selectively after they filed a case on Rs 3.08-crore misappropriation; Maharashtra court gives relief

Why did the residents win the case?

Vishal Gehrana, Advocate-on-Record, Supreme Court of India, and Partner Designate at Karanjawala & Company, said to ET Wealth Online: A nearly fourfold increase in monthly maintenance is bound to raise questions. If your maintenance goes up from Rs 7,867 to Rs 27,166 or Rs 29,266, you are entitled to ask how the new figure has been calculated. That was the grievance of these two members, and the Appellate Court found merit in their challenge at the interim stage.

According to Gehrana, the housing society in this case had decided to recalculate the monthly maintenance charges for wing wise but had itself not followed through with the safeguards it had itself promised to the residents. What the society had told that the maintenance calculations will be verified and members’ objections will considered before the revised charges would be implemented, but this did not happen.

Also read: Housing society demanded Rs 1.42 lakh maintenance dues with 18% interest, Maharashtra Court protects resident from being labelled defaulter; Know why
ADVERTISEMENT

Gehrana says that a general body of a housing society has considerable authority into managing the day to day affairs of the society but this authority is not unlimited. This same aspect has been ruled by Bombay High Court in the case between Venus Co-operative housing society where it was held that a majority of the members cannot use their voting power to justify an arbitrary or unreasonable demand on others.

The order is interim. The Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court has not declared wing wise maintenance unlawful or finally held that the revised charges are illegal.
ADVERTISEMENT

Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court discussion

Till July 2022, the society was charging Rs 7,867 for Mr Jayaswal and Mrs Nalawade’s D/101 and D/201 flats, respectively, which are located in D wing of the society. It is an admitted fact that after redevelopment of the society, the builder has constructed 4 wings namely A, B, C and D. It is also an admitted fact that A wing has 82 flats, B wing has 55 flats, C wing has 76 flats and D wing has only 2 flats.

The society claims that in the AGM dated September 30, 2018, it was decided by a majority vote to revise the maintenance charges and accordingly a resolution was passed vide agenda No.4 in the AGM dated March 27, 2022. The society said a resolution dated March 27, 2022 was passed by majority members which cannot be challenged by a miniscule minority i.e. by two members (Mr Jayaswal and Mrs Nalawade).

The Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court observed that the housing society had not produced on record a copy of the minutes of the AGM held on September 30, 2018 wherein the majority of the members agreed to revise the maintenance amount.

Mr Jayaswal and Mrs Nalawade argued that in this AGM no such resolution was passed. In fact, in the 2018 AGM, S.A.M. Chettiar, Pankaj Thakur, Varsha Kamble, Dinant More and Pravin Shah and the chairman Sanjay Rawool resigned and an Administrator was appointed.

When the Maharashtra State Co-Operative Appellate Court read the minutes of the 2018 AGM, the court observed that in the said AGM, the secretary of the managing committee proposed to recalculate the maintenance charges after considering actual expenses for each unit. The secretary of the managing committee of the society also decided to appoint an independent Chartered Accountant and confirm the Chartered Accountant’s calculations. The calculations were proposed to be displayed on the notice board for members and it was agreed that after hearing the members’ concerns, the rate would be finalized and revised billing done. Accordingly, it was unanimously resolved as proposed by the secretary .

The court said: “A bare perusal of the said resolution clearly reveals that AGM of the society decided to recalculate the maintenance charges after considering actual expenses for each wing and to appoint a Chartered Accountant to confirm the said calculations and then to display the same on the notice board and after considering the objections of the members received, to finalize and revise the billing.”

However, it appears that thereafter the society didn’t hold any AGM or SGM to discuss the recalculated maintenance charges, approved by the Chartered Accountant .

The court also said that it can be seen that the society never discussed the objections of the members on the recalculated maintenance charges and finalised the same unanimously.

The court also said that it is alleged by the society that according to the resolution passed in the AGM , the managing committee had a meeting on May 20, 2022 and unanimously approved the revised calculations.

However the society failed to produce any such resolution. In a co-operative society, any resolution to increase the maintenance charges has to be approved by the general body of the society.

The managing committee of the society has no power to take any policy decision without approval of the general body of the society. However, in this case, the society directly imposed the revised maintenance charges from July 1, 2022.

The court said: “Such a recourse is definitely against the object of the Co-operative Act. Apart from this fact, it appears that the society has charged wing wise maintenance. As per the Model Byelaws 2014, the society requires to charge the maintenance amount per flat or unit wise and not wing wise.”

When the court asked how D wing incurred more maintenance charges, the society said that D wing of the society had separate water connection, electricity connection, a separate lift for only two flats and these two flats were using the common compound as personal space.

The court rejected these reasons and said this was according to the redevelopment plan and it did not mean that these two flat owners in D wing were enjoying some extraordinary facilities not provided to other members of the society.

The court said that it was the decision of the society to construct 4 wings with different flats and D wing with only two flats. Since it was the decision of the society, it could not blame the disputants for using facilities of lift, water connection and electricity only for two flats. The court said the society could not be allowed to charge exorbitant maintenance charges for D wing flats.

That is how the two flat owners of the D wing won the interim case.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Legal / Will › Housing society hikes monthly maintenance by more than 3 times; Residents fight back and win relief as Maharashtra court puts increase on hold for this reason
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+