Father sells 1,800 sq ft of ancestral land despite son’s objection; Supreme Court says son has no right to his exclusive share

The Supreme Court ruled that a father can sell his exclusive share of ancestral land without his son's consent. In a case involving 1,800 sq ft of land, the father's ownership prevented any claim by the son. The court emphasized that once property...

ET Online

Despite objections from son father sold his exclusive share of ancestral land and wins case in SC; Court says son has no right in his father’s exclusive land

The Hindu Succession Act, 1956, says that when a Hindu male dies intestate (without a valid Will), his property goes to his Class I legal heirs, which include his sons and/or daughters. Section 8 of Hindu Succession Act, 1956, says that this property so inherited by a son and/or daughter is generally held by him /her as individual property, and not as an ancestral or coparcenary property. This means that the children of a son or daughter (the Hindu male’s grandchildren) do not acquire a birthright in such inherited exclusive property.

That was why J.R. (the grandson) lost his case in the Supreme Court on November 6, 2026. He had challenged his father's sale of 1,811 sq ft of land. J.R. claimed that the land had been allotted to his father out of his grandfather's ancestral property through partition and therefore, he had a right to it as a coparcener.

The Supreme Court rejected this argument. It held that although J.R. might have a birthright in property that continued to be coparcenary property , the 1,811 sq ft allotted to his father had become his father's exclusive property. After the grandfather's property passed on to his the legal heirs including his father, and the father's share was separated through partition, it was no longer a joint family or coparcenary property in which J.R. could claim a birthright.


It must be noted that J.R.'s father was still alive. Therefore, J.R. could not claim a present share in his father's exclusive property just because he was the father's son. However, if the father had continued to own the property till his death, then J.R. potentially could have inherited it as a Class I heir if his father died intestate (without a Will).

But this did not happen as J.R’s father, being the owner of the 1800 sq ft land, sold it during his lifetime. That meant J.R. could not claim a share in the 1,811 sq ft land or oppose the sale.

Advocate K. Paari Vendhan, representing J.R argued that when Section 29-A was inserted in the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, by the Tamil Nadu Amendment Act, 1989, the right of daughter of a coparcener to inherit in a coparcenary property by birth was recognised, notwithstanding anything contained in Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.

Advocate K. Paari Vendhan argued that under Section 29-A, in a subsisting Mitakshara coparcenary governed by the Tamil Nadu amendment, a daughter/female member who qualifies for the provision, holds a coparcenary interest. The statutory protection preserves eligible daughters’ coparcenary rights and leaves a son’s existing right by birth intact.

However, this argument would have held true if the property was ancestral, but it was not, as it was an exclusive self property of J.R’s father.

Why did the J.R (son) lose this case?

Yogendra Aldak, Executive Partner, Lakshmikumaran & Sridharan, said to ET Wealth Online: The son lost the because the Hon’ble Supreme Court was of the opinion that the property in question had become his father’s exclusive property, and a son acquires no share by birth in property that his father owns. Importantly, a grandson is not recognised as a Class I Heir under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act.

Aldak explains using an example: Consider a situation where a grandfather has left him his orchard to his children and once the grandfather dies, the child divide the orchand among themselves and each of the children becomes sole owner of their respective share exclusively. Now if one of these children sells their exclusive portion of the orchand, his legal heirs can't claim that the orchand was ancestral property and so before selling family should have been consulted. The reason is this exclusive portion belonged to the respective child who had got it by partition.
ADVERTISEMENT

Aldak says: "The legal position is thus clear on this matter. Property inherited by a father under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 and thereafter partitioned, becomes his exclusive property, and his son acquires no right by birth in it."

Shabnam Shaikh, Partner at Khaitan & Co, said to ET Wealth Online: The hon'ble Supreme Court's judgment is based on the fact that the father inherited his share of the grandfather's property in accordance with Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act 1956 (“HSA”) as a Class I heir, prior to the partition of property. Since his father was alive at the time of his grandfather's demise, the grandson himself did not qualify as a Class I heir. The hon'ble apex court stated that property inherited by a male heir under Section 8 of the HSA does not continue to retain the character of joint Hindu family property.
ADVERTISEMENT

Shaikh says that the grandfather’s death in the above case had taken place prior to the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 2005. It may be noted that, presently, Section 6(3) of the HSA clarifies that where a Hindu dies after the commencement of the Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act 2005, their interest in the property of a joint Hindu family governed by Mitakshara law shall devolve by testamentary or intestate succession, and not by survivorship. Hence, in the absence of a will, the property shall devolve as per the scheme of the Hindu Succession Act.

Why does a son not have a right in his father's self-acquired, exclusive land during the lifetime of his father?

The father is the sole owner of any self-acquired property – and has complete rights to sell, gift, will away or otherwise deal with his own self acquired property during his lifetime. Hence, the son’s right over such property as an heir, in the absence of a will, comes alive only as a Class I heir under the HSA after the father’s lifetime.

Supreme Court discussion

J.R’s grandfather, N. Ramakrishnan, owned a big ancestral land and partitioned it among his children. Through this partition J.R’s father got 1,800 sq ft. of land. J.R wanted half of this land but his father had sold it to buyers, and so the litigation started.

The lower court held that when a son or daughter receives their father’s property through partition, they become absolute owners of their share, irrespective of whether the property was ancestral or self-acquired. They may deal with it exclusively and exclude their sons. The son of a divided son, that is the . grandson, does not acquire a birth right in this property through his father, who is excluded by virtue of Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act and cannot become a coparcener in the property in question.

T he lower court held that this 1800 sq ft land is an ancestral property belonging to N. Ramkrishnan and the divided share in this property reached the hands of his son, that is . J.R. 's father ) who became its absolute owner. J.R, as the grandson, did not acquire any interest in the property.

The Supreme Court observed that J.R’s grandfather, N. Ramakrishnan, owned the ancestral land. J.R argued that the share which his father later inherited from it was also ancestral.

The Supreme Court rejected this argument and held that succession is governed by Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Since J.R’s father was a Class I heir and J.R was not, the property remained J.R’s father’s exclusive property.

The Supreme Court also held that once property was divided among the legal heirs and J.R’s father became the exclusive owner of his allotted share, the joint coparcenary angle did not continue in that land. Therefore, J.R could not claim a share merely because he was his father’s son.

The apex court accordingly upheld the High Court’s decision and dismissed J.R’s appeal.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Legal / Will › Father sells 1,800 sq ft of ancestral land despite son’s objection; Supreme Court says son has no right to his exclusive share
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+