Employee works for less than 5 years yet wins Rs 1.75 lakh gratuity with 10% interest; Know how he won case in Karnataka HC

The Karnataka High Court recently ruled in favor of an employee’s entitlement to gratuity after serving four years and nine months. The court emphasized that working over 240 days in the preceding year qualifies the individual for benefits. This l...

ET Online

Employee wins Rs 1.75 lakh gratuity with 10% interest despite working for less than 5 years; Know how he won case in Karnataka HC

In a recent judgement, the Karnataka High Court has ruled an employee who resigns before completing five years of continous service can get gratuity if he can satisfy the provisions of Payment of Gratuity Act, 1972. The court ruled that if the employee has worked for at least 240 days in the last 12 calendar months leading to his resignation then it is assumed the employee has completed the full year of service for the purposes of gratuity.

This ruling came in a case filed by a former assistant engineer of Bangalore metro who was denied Rs 1.75 lakh gratuity on the ground that he had worked for 4 years 9 months 12 days and not 5 years.

On September 26, 2026, this engineer, a resident of Kengeri Satellite town, won the case in the Karnataka High Court. The court ordered the Bangalore Metro to pay him Rs 1.75 lakh gratuity with 10% interest from May 18, 2022. Advocate S.B. Mukkannappa represented him in the Karnataka High Court.


Mayank Parashar, Legal Associate at Clasis Law-India said to ET Wealth Online: "Karnataka High Court has now re-settled the principle in the context of eligibility of the continuous service requirement for gratuity and concluded that employers should consider the definition of continuous service and key conditions for gratuity together. That’s said every employee who has completed 240 days in 6 days working and 190 days in 5 days working but has not completed the entire year should be considered eligible for gratuity."

Karnataka High Court discussion

Mr H.V was appointed as an assistant engineer with the Bengaluru Metro Rail Corporation (BMRCL) on July 6, 2017. He resigned on March 19, 2022 and was relieved from service on April 18, 2022. His total service was four years, nine months and twelve days.

After his service was over, he submitted multiple representations seeking payment of gratuity, claiming a sum of Rs 1.85 lakh on the basis of his last drawn monthly salary of Rs 64,210. However, Bangalore metro refused to pay and so he filed a legal case against the corporation .

Justice D K Singh and Justice H. Shanthi Bhushan of Karnataka High Court heard this case.

The Karnataka High Court said that the question in this case is not merely whether H.V (the employee) had completed five calendar years from the date of joining the service. Instead, his eligibility for gratuity had to be determined by reading Section 4(1), together with the definition of “continuous service” under Sections 2(c) and 2A.

The Karnataka High Court said that gratuity is not a bounty or a payment made at the discretion of the employer; it is a statutory entitlement when the conditions prescribed by the Act are satisfied. Section 4(1) of the Payment of Gratuity Act says that the five year continuous service rule needs to be follow certain specified exceptions.

Thus the Karnataka High Court said that this provision cannot be read in isolation from Section 2(c), which defines what is “continuous service” with reference to Section 2A. Section 2A tells that the statutory test for determining continuous service and, in the circumstances specified under sub-section (2), deems an employee to have been in continuous service for the prescribed period where the employee has worked for not less than 240 days during the relevant period of twelve calendar months
ADVERTISEMENT

The deeming provision is not an incidental consideration; it forms part of the statutory scheme by which continuous service is assessed. Therefore, the determination can’t be made solely by calculating the calendar interval between the date of joining and the date of cessation of employment, without considering the number of days actually worked and the applicability of Section 2A of the Act.

The Karnataka High Court said that the main question in the present case was , whether H.V’s service during the fifth year satisfied the statutory requirement, and whether the benefit of the deeming provision is available to him based on the facts established before the statutory authorities.
ADVERTISEMENT

The Karnataka High Court cited the decision of the Delhi High Court in the TV Today Network case where the court considered the same statutory question with reference to Mettur Beardsell case and Sreeja B.V. case and upheld the gratuity authorities' determination in favour of an employee who had fallen short of five calendar years but had worked for more than 240 days during the fifth year.

Karnataka High Court therefore, held that the approach which treats the calendar period alone as decisive, without considering the effect of Section 2A, does not give full effect to the statutory scheme.

The Karnataka High Court said that their conclusion rested on the language of Sections 2(c), 2A and 4(1), read together, and the authorities interpreting the concept of continuous service and not merely on the beneficial object of the enactment.

The Karnataka High Court observed that H.V’s period of service was admittedly less than five calendar years, but the claim before the statutory authorities was that he had worked for more than 240 days during the fifth year. The significance of that fact had to be tested under Section 2A, read with Section 4(1), rather than rejected merely because the total calendar period fell short of five years.

Thus the high court allowed H.V’s appeal and ordered his employer to pay Rs 1.75 lakh with 10% interest from May 18, 2022.

Parashar says that this case has a very significant weightage in India’s social security jurisprudence. While the requirement of five years continuous service for full time employees and one year continuous service for fixed term employees (under the new law) is the statutory conditions for gratuity eligibility with the continuous service requirement. Although in this matter only the courts differing judicial interpretation have raised questions about its applicability of continuous service requirement.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Wealth › Legal / Will › Employee works for less than 5 years yet wins Rs 1.75 lakh gratuity with 10% interest; Know how he won case in Karnataka HC
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+