“If you don't read about your money, your money will not take care of you”: 7 investing lessons from top fund managers
Navigating investment options like mutual funds, PMS, AIFs, and direct stocks can be daunting. Leading fund managers discuss strategies for successful investing, emphasizing the importance of personal financial goals, the role of SIPs, and the nee...

MFs, PMS, AIFs, stocks: 7 lessons for investors (AI-generated image)
Leading fund managers discussed these key questions at a panel titled e MFs, PMS, AIF, ETFs or Direct Stocks: What will work in 2026 and thereafter? at the ET Wealth Expo.
Taking part in the discussion were Vikas Khemani, Founder and CEO of Carnelian Asset Management and Advisors; Aashish P. Somaiyaa, CEO of WhiteOak Capital Asset Management; Swarup Mohanty, Vice Chairman and CEO of Mirae Asset Investment Managers (India) and Naveen Kulkarni, CIO – PMS and Listed Equity Alternates at Axis AMC. The session was moderated by Kshitij Anand, Editor, ET Markets.
Here are the key investment lessons and strategies that emerged from the discussion.
Also read: REITs in India delivered around 16% annualised returns since 2019; 5 things to check before investing
1. No single investment product can meet everyone's wealth creation needs
As India's prosperity increases, investors' financial needs and risk profiles are also changing. According to Khemani, the growing popularity of AIFs, real estate funds, REITs and private equity reflects this shift.
He pointed out that the AIF industry, relatively small a decade ago, has grown to about Rs 16-17 lakh crore in assets.
Khemani said different investment structures become relevant at different stages of an investor's wealth creation journey. While mutual funds have helped improve financial penetration over the past 10-15 years, affluent investors are increasingly looking for access to different asset classes and customised investment solutions.
However, there is no single product that can serve every investor. The choice depends on an individual's wealth, risk appetite and investment requirements.
2. Start SIPs at the beginning of the month and don't stop them during market corrections
Somaiyaa emphasised that investors should prioritise savings rather than wait until the end of the month to see how much money is left for investments.
Referring to the popular personal finance principle of income minus savings equals expenses, he explained why SIPs should ideally be scheduled at the beginning of the month.
If investors schedule their SIPs towards the end of the month, they are effectively saving whatever remains after expenses. This increases the possibility of insufficient funds and failed SIP instalments.
He also addressed concerns about continued SIP inflows despite foreign institutional investors (FIIs) withdrawing money from Indian markets.
According to Somaiyaa, criticism of domestic investors and their ability to support the Indian equity market has existed for years. He recalled how, during the 2008-09 financial crisis, India was criticised for its dependence on foreign investors and the absence of a strong domestic investor base.
He argued that SIPs are designed to work through market cycles, including downturns. Investors should not stop their SIPs simply because markets are falling.
He cited an example from September 2024 to September 2026, saying SIP returns remained positive over the two years even as the Nifty declined around 16%.
As for systematic withdrawal plans (SWPs), Somaiyaa explained that they become relevant when investors move from the accumulation phase to the distribution phase of their financial journey, such as during retirement.
He referred to the commonly discussed 3.5%-4% withdrawal rule, under which retirees withdraw a predetermined percentage of their accumulated corpus periodically. However, not every SIP investor necessarily needs an SWP.
Khemani also argued that concerns about excessive SIP investments overlook India's relatively low household exposure to equities. He said a significant proportion of SIPs are small-ticket investments, with more than 60% involving monthly contributions below Rs 3,000.
3. Decide your financial goals before choosing active or passive funds
The choice between active and passive investing should come only after investors have identified their financial goals and asset allocation.
Mohanty emphasised that personal finance is first about the individual, not merely the financial product.
He explained that two investors pursuing the same financial goal may need different investment strategies depending on their age and investment horizon. For instance, an older investor may need to invest a larger monthly amount than a younger investor to achieve the same target within the same period.
In active investing, fund managers attempt to outperform benchmark like the Nifty 50. However, this also brings the possibility of underperformance. Passive funds, on the other hand, aim to replicate an index rather than outperform it.
Mohanty said both approaches have created wealth for investors, and a combination of the two may be appropriate depending on individual requirements.
He cautioned investors against selecting funds solely on the basis of past returns and suggested understanding their own financial needs before deciding on the active-passive mix.
"If you don't read about your money, your money will not take care of you," was his advice to investors.
4. When should investors consider adding PMS to their portfolios?
PMS can offer investors greater customisation and the possibility of generating higher returns through concentrated investment positions. However, it also comes with a higher risk profile.
Kulkarni explained that PMS strategies are actively managed and aim to generate alpha through stock selection and concentrated bets. The ability to customise portfolios is another important advantage, particularly for investors and family offices that already have exposure to multiple equity products.
As a broad thumb rule, Kulkarni suggested that investors with around Rs 5 crore in liquid, investable assets could consider allocating approximately Rs 50 lakh, or 10%, to a PMS.
However, he stressed that the allocation should depend on the investor's risk appetite, as PMS investments can carry significantly higher risks.
PMS investments need not necessarily be deployed entirely in one go. Investors can stagger their investments over several months, with the uninvested amount parked in liquid funds. Alternatively, deployment can be left to the portfolio manager, depending on market conditions.
5. Finding the next multibagger requires more than identifying a good business
Identifying a potential multibagger is not just about finding a company with strong growth prospects. The quality of management, sector outlook, business model, corporate governance and valuations are equally important.
Khemani said his investment approach places significant emphasis on understanding the people running a business. The competence, integrity and ambition of the management team can make a substantial difference to the eventual outcome, even when two companies operate similar business models.
He also highlighted the importance of identifying sectors with favourable long-term growth drivers and understanding the nuances of individual business models rather than making broad investment decisions based on sector labels.
However, finding a good business is only the starting point. Investors also need the patience to remain invested through market corrections and periods of weak performance.
Citing Sun Pharma as an example, he recalled how the company's market capitalisation was around Rs 1,000 crore in the late 1990s and early 2000s before growing substantially over the following decades. The stock also experienced periods of significant correction during this journey.
He said investors must distinguish between temporary weakness in share prices and a genuine deterioration in the business or management quality.
Identifying sectors with favourable tailwinds is critical. A good company operating in a sector facing prolonged headwinds may not necessarily deliver strong stock returns.
It is important to understand a company's cost structure, capital management and corporate governance.
Somaiyaa said portfolio construction is as important as individual stock selection. His approach focuses on balancing portfolios across investment styles, sectors and factors while taking active stock-specific positions.
He also highlighted the importance of evaluating businesses through cash flows, governance standards and their ability to scale over the long term.
6. Don't chase past performance while selecting mutual funds
One of the biggest mistakes investors make is selecting mutual funds based predominantly on their recent returns. Somaiyaa said past performance can help investors shortlist funds, but it should not be the sole reason for investing.
Investors should examine the consistency of a fund's performance and understand what contributed to its returns.
He highlighted the importance of the information ratio, which measures a fund’s excess return relative to its benchmark, adjusted for the volatility of that excess return. It reflects how consistently the fund generates outperformance.
Information Ratio = (Portfolio return- Benchmark return) / Standard deviation of excess returns
A fund that generates high alpha in one year may not necessarily sustain that performance in subsequent years.
Investors should also examine whether the fund manager's stated investment philosophy is reflected in the actual portfolio.
Investors are dealing with uncertain market outcomes which even the best fund managers cannot control. What they can assess, however, is the quality and consistency of the investment process.
7. Don't follow the herd; invest according to your own goals
In his concluding remarks, Mohanty advised investors against following popular investment trends or making decisions based on what others are buying.
He urged investors to look beyond short-term market levels and focus on India's long-term economic growth potential.
"Investing is a journey of knowing yourself," he said, emphasising that investors should understand their own financial goals rather than copy their neighbours' investment choices.
He also encouraged investors to consider opportunities that may currently be overlooked by the market instead of blindly following past performance.
Investors should focus on their long-term investment objectives and allow professional fund managers to manage their portfolios rather than constantly monitoring short-term market movements.
Wealth creation is not about finding one perfect investment product. It is about choosing the right combination of investments, understanding the risks involved and having the discipline to stay invested through market cycles.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.