Carnelian Small Cap Fund NFO: Is Rs 5,000 crore size cap a smart move for investors or just a gimmick? Know this before investing

In the past few years, mutual funds have increasingly stopped accepting additional inflows when fund managers feel uncomfortable managing more money than they can deploy in equity markets. But newly set-up fund house Carnelian Investment Managers is probably the first mutual fund (MF) house to announce a maximum cap on a scheme during its New Fund Offer (NFO). The AMC, India’s 54th, launched its maiden liquid and equity schemes last week.

The NFO of Carnelian Small Cap Fund, open until 30 October, will cap the scheme at Rs.5,000 crore. Once the scheme crosses Rs.5,000 crore, it will stop taking lump-sum investments. However, it will continue Systematic Investment Plans (SIPs) and will also accept new SIPs.

This is possibly the first time a scheme in India’s Rs.86 trillion mutual fund industry has capped its size at the NFO stage. The closest precedent was HDFC Defence Fund in 2023, which closed its NFO three days early after collecting around Rs.1,000 crore. Unlike Carnelian, though, HDFC had not said upfront that it would stop accepting money once it hit a certain size. After the NFO closed, the fund house capped new SIPs at Rs.10,000 per Permanent Account Number (PAN) per month. Currently, HDFC Defence Fund allows SIPs up to Rs.25,000 per PAN per month.


But is the asset size limit a genuine blessing for investors, or just a gimmick? “The idea behind this scheme is to generate alpha. This is not an AUM gathering scheme,” says Rajkumar Dhiman, Chief Executive Officer, Carnelian AMC. The fund house surveyed 710 distributors across 200 cities to gauge the ideal size of a small-cap fund for generating alpha, or risk-adjusted returns above its benchmark.

ALSO READ | Mid and small-cap stocks at 20-year high premium to large caps: Why investors may need to shift fresh money to large caps

Fifty-one per cent of respondents said Rs.5,000 -Rs.10,000 crore, 31% said up to Rs.5,000 crore, and 18% said Rs 10,000-Rs 20,000 crore. Dhiman says SIPs will continue, and the fund will accept new ones even after the cap is hit. The fund house wants to encourage investors to put money in steadily, which it sees as the right way to invest for the long term.

“It’s very smart marketing,” says Shalab Gupta Bibhab, Founder & CEO - Bibhab Capital, an Agra-based mutual fund distributor, who sees merit in the cap. Bibhab explains that if a Rs.80,000 crore small-cap fund invested even 1% of its corpus in a company, that would be an investable size of Rs.800 crore.

For a small-cap company with a market capitalisation of, say, Rs.4,000 crore, that works out to a 20% stake. Sebi (Securities and Exchange Board of India; India’s capital market regulator) rules don’t allow a fund house to own more than 10% of a company, so a large fund simply can’t take meaningful bets on many smaller companies.

Not everyone is convinced. “A cap announced in the NFO stage might just create artificial scarcity. Now some investors might fear that this fund might just stop accepting fresh money, and they may just rush to invest in it, even if they’d like to wait and see it accumulate some track record,” says a senior official at a mutual fund house who did not wish to be named. Investors, distributors and advisers will watch Carnelian Small Cap Fund closely once it starts investing. With small- and mid-cap valuations elevated, experts favour large caps, which have become cheaper since September 2024.

Either way, investors must assess whether a fund can deliver alpha in an expensive market rather than rely on sheer size alone.