New motor insurance rules from December 15: Why your family may not be covered unless you opt for the right add-ons
From 15 December, car insurance comes in four parts, and only two are compulsory. What you tick on a new form decides who is protected. The change comes from a Supreme Court ruling of 4 August 2026, in National Insurance vs Thungala Dhana Laxmi. T...

The Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (Irdai) has made this “four-layer” structure mandatory for all private car and two-wheeler policies issued from 15 December 2026. The four parts are: cover for damage you cause to others (third-party), cover for claims by passengers in your vehicle, personal accident cover, and cover for damage to your own vehicle.
What’s different now
The change comes from a Supreme Court ruling of 4 August 2026, in National Insurance vs Thungala Dhana Laxmi. The case began more than three decades ago. A car owner (T. Ramu) was travelling as a passenger in his own car when an unidentified lorry rammed it and fled. He died. His car had a comprehensive policy, yet the insurer refused to compensate his family. Its argument: he had never paid an extra premium to cover his personal risk.His family went to court and won. The Telangana High Court ordered the insurer to pay, and on 4 August 2026, the Supreme Court dismissed the insurer’s appeal, relying on a 2009 Irdai circular, which said insurance companies are liable to pay compensation for any occupant in the vehicle under a comprehensive/package policy. Since the entire dispute turned on what “comprehensive” did or did not include, Irdai was tasked with drafting uniform wordings for covers other than the mandatory third-party liability cover. This will help buyers know exactly what they are paying for.
“Currently, there are two motor insurance policy forms, namely Third-Party Liability (Act Only) and Comprehensive/Package. These have now been merged into a single policy form. Customers can choose the combination of covers they need,” explains Hari Radhakrishnan, Regional Director, First Policy Insurance Brokers.
Here is how it changes things for you. Today you choose between two kinds of policies. The first is a third-party-only policy (insurers call it an “Act-only” policy, because it gives you just the minimum cover the Motor Vehicles Act requires). It pays for death, injury or damage you cause to others, and nothing for your own vehicle.
In addition, owners must also carry personal accident cover for themselves as driver, usually bought as part of the comprehensive motor policy. Then, you can also buy the own damage component, which provides coverage for the insured owner’s vehicle.
But the extent of protection available to people inside the vehicle has not always been clear to policyholders. In the National Insurance Vs Thungala Dhana Laxmi case, the owner died as a passenger in his own car, not as its driver, and the insurer argued nothing in his policy covered him. The Supreme Court order could now put an end to any such ambiguity.
Under the new system, every buyer gets one policy with four sections, worded the same way by every insurer.
Section I is third-party cover. Section II covers your legal liability towards passengers. Section III is personal accident cover, for you as owner and, if you choose, for your passengers (other occupants). Section IV covers damage to your own vehicle. Only third-party cover and the owner’s personal accident cover are compulsory; everything else is your choice.
You must fill in and sign an option form that marks each section “opt in” or “opt out”. Online buyers can confirm it with a one-time password (OTP). The policy schedule will show the premium for each section separately, so you can see what you are paying for. Insurers must also give you a customer information sheet. The owner’s accident cover now applies whether you are driving the vehicle or just travelling in it, closing the gap that tripped up the family in the Supreme Court case.
Will you pay less? Not necessarily. You will see what each part costs, but “the framework should not be viewed as a measure that will necessarily reduce overall premiums,” says Amarnath Saxena, Chief Technical Officer – Commercial, Bajaj General Insurance. Radhakrishnan adds that no new cover is being introduced, so the premium for the same set of covers should not change much. It is largely the same covers repackaged.
Section I: Third-party cover
This is the cover the law requires you to have. If your vehicle kills or injures some one, or damages their property, the insurer pays the compensation and the legal costs.The road transport ministry fixes the third-party premium in consultation with Irdai, so it will be the same everywhere. Insurers set the price of the other sections. “Except for Section I, where pricing is mandated, other sections could be priced differently by insurers,” says Segar Sampathkumar, former Insurance Ombudsman, Chennai.
Irdai has also left insurers free to design and price own-damage cover as they wish, and to tweak its exclusions, as long as they do not cut back the basic cover.
Section II: Cover for passengers
If a passenger, a pillion rider or a driver you employ is killed or injured in your vehicle and sues you for compensation, this optional section covers your legal liabilities arising out of such claims.The catch is who it leaves out: you and your immediate family—parents, spouse and children. Put simply, if you injure an immediate family member while driving, this section will not cover your legal liability towards them. The exclusion covers your parents, spouse and children. Sampathkumar argues the family exclusion does not serve customers. “Legally, the brother of the insured could sue the insured for causing the death of their mother or father. The child of the insured could also sue the insured for causing the death of her mother. Such liabilities should not have been excluded,” he says.
To compensate family members for injuries or death, you need the optional personal accident cover for passengers under Section III. Unlike Section II, it does not depend on anyone suing you. It pays a fixed sum if a passenger dies or is permanently disabled in an accident involving your vehicle. “An important aspect of this change is the distinction between legal liability towards passengers and personal accident protection for occupants. The former addresses the vehicle owner’s legal liability towards covered occupants, while the latter provides personal accident protection to individuals travelling in the vehicle. This distinction will help customers better understand the nature of protection they are purchasing,” says Saxena.
A new four-layer motor insurance framework
Vehicle insurance will have four distinct components

*To comply with the Supreme Court ruling on 4 August
*The case: National Insurance Co. Ltd. vs Thungala Dhana Laxmi case.
*The apex court directed Irdai to introduce a four layer structure, standardise policy wordings for mandatory covers
Take note of the changes
*One policy form replaces the existing Act-only and comprehensive/package formats
*Choose the combination of covers you need
*Like now, road transport ministry, in consultation with Irdai, will determine mandatory TP cover premiums
*Insurers will set premiums for other covers
The gaps
*SC mandated extended third-party liability tenures
*Six years for four-wheelers; four years for two-wheelers
*Up from five years and three years
*Exclusion of immediate family from occupant liability cover needs rethink
*However, Irdai’s circular does not mention extended tenures
Section III: Personal accident cover
This has two parts: compulsory cover for you as the owner, and optional cover for passengers, pillion riders and other drivers.The owner’s cover applies only if you are both the registered owner and the policyholder, so it does not apply to vehicles owned by a company or firm. “With respect the PA cover for the owner-insured there appears to be some inconsistency in the policy wordings (which say the cover is mandatory) and the proposal form (which provides an opt-in checkbox),” points out Radhakrishnan. It pays if you die or are permanently disabled in an accident involving your vehicle, whether you are driving it, sitting in it, or getting in or out. You get the full sum insured for death or total disability, and half for losing one limb or the sight of one eye. You must hold a valid driving licence. Self-inflicted injuries are not covered, and you can claim under only one policy for one accident.
The optional cover for passengers and other drivers pays out on similar lines. The injury must come from an accident, not an illness, and should have resulted in death or disability within six months. The full sum in sured is paid for death, permanent total disability, or the loss of two limbs or eyes (or one of each). Half is paid for losing one limb or one eye.
Section IV: Own-damage cover
This component pays for damage to your own vehicle. The insurer can repair the vehicle, replace parts or pay you cash. In the case of a total loss, the compensation will be based on the vehicle’s insured declared value (IDV), minus the value of the wreck. IDV is the vehicle’s insured value, calculated after accounting for depre ciation. It is the maximum amount the insurer pays in the case of total loss. For partial damage, you get the repair bill minus depreciation on the parts. Add-ons such as zero depreciation can still be bought on top.What’s still unclear
The circular leaves some questions open. First, how long third-party cover for new vehicles must run. “The Supreme Court also ruled that new cars must have third-party cover for four years and new two-wheelers for six years. But the Irdai circular has not extended the current mandatory periods of three years for cars and five years for two-wheelers,” points out Sampathkumar.It is also not clear whether you can buy different sections from different insurers. “Since third-party cover for new vehicles runs for a longer period, and the others usually for one year, the customer should be free to choose an insurer based on price and other con siderations,” he adds.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.