Internet neutrality debate: Govt for non-discriminatory access

Amid a raging debate over equal Internet access for all, the government threw its weight behind "non-discriminatory internet access".

Internet neutrality debate: Govt for non-discriminatory access
NEW DELHI: Amid a raging debate over equal Internet access for all, the government today threw its weight behind "non-discriminatory internet access" and said an expert panel is looking into the 'net neutrality' issue.

Anti-trust watchdog CCI might also launch a probe into schemes launched by some telecom operators, including Airtel, Reliance Communications and Uninor, that claim to provide 'free' access to certain internet applications, even as the companies defended their stand saying these initiatives did not go against 'net neutrality'.

Social media platforms like Twitter continued to remain abuzz, as politicians, filmstars, start-ups and corporates joined the debate, while Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal also said there needs to be a debate on the issue.

Net neutrality implies equal treatment to all Internet traffic and any priority given to an application or company on payment basis is seen as violating the concept.

Telecom regulator TRAI, which last month floated a discussion paper on this, is also looking into the issue.

"Non discriminatory net availability is what we need to strive for," Telecom and IT Minister Ravi Shankar Prasad said, while adding that an expert committee was looking into the matter and should submit its report within a month to help the government make an informed decision.
ADVERTISEMENT

According to the Minister, Internet is one of the finest creations of the human mind and it is a property of the entire human race and not of any country or society.

"Internet to become entirely global should have a link to local and when we talk of digital inclusion it must be available to the underprivileged and on the margins," he said.

Sparking off the debate, telecom major Bharti Airtel launched its 'Airtel Zero' marketing platform -- where certain apps are available for free with charges borne by app makers.

Many free Internet advocates and start-ups feel that Airtel's platform could even "lead to monopolisation by a few and squeeze out the small companies".
ADVERTISEMENT

Airtel itself has defended its move saying the initiative would be a 'win-win' for customers and marketers alike.

Coming out in support of initiatives like that of Airtel, e-commerce major Flipkart.com's founder Sachin Bansal, tweeted, "when foreign companies do it in India - innovation. Indians do it - violation".
ADVERTISEMENT

Prasad said that way back in January he had constituted a committee headed by senior government officials of the Telecom Ministry to submit a report on the whole gamut of net neutrality objective, its benefits, advantages and limitations including the regulatory and technical issues.

"I have asked them to give me a report by the second week of May after the widest consultation possible including online to help government come to an informed decision on this issue.

"Since I am awaiting these reports, it will not be proper for me to make any comment," he said.

Reflecting the large interest generated among people by the debate, the hashtag 'savetheinternet' has been trending on micro blogging site Twitter over the last few days.
 
Over one lakh netizens have already written to telecom regulator TRAI in support of net neutrality in the country. The watchdog had sought public's views on the issue, the last date for comments is April 24 and for counter ones is May 8.

Delhi Chief Minister Arvind Kejriwal tweeted: "AAP committed to neutral internet. India MUST debate #NetNeutrality. I support #Saveinternet campaign."

After a video by comedy group AIB (explaining why net neutrality is essential for India) went viral on social networks, actors like Shah Rukh Khan and Kunal Kemmu, music composer Vishal Dadlani and Congress leader Digvijay Singh have also extended support through tweets.

The nine-minute video urged people to sign up against allowing telecom operators/internet service providers to choose the type, quantity or pricing of content for consumers.

Leading the voices of Bollywood, actor-director Farhan Akhtar has called for a campaign to 'save the Internet'.

Over the past few months, operators like Reliance Communications and Uninor have also tied up with players like Facebook, WhatsApp and Wikipedia to offer free usage to consumers, which has drawn flak from activists and consumers.
ADVERTISEMENT

Zomato CEO Deepinder Goyal had also tweeted: "Couldn't have built Zomato if we had a competitor on something like Airtel Zero."

Country's largest e-commerce company Flipkart has come under flak, specially in social media, following reports suggesting they are joining the Airtel Zero app platform and Flipkart co-founder Sachin Bansal's tweets in defence of Airtel's Zero app marketing platform.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
Buying in India vs Abroad: Where to get your latest gadget from
1/5
Text: ET Bureau

It’s a common dilemma, should you buy that latest laptop, camera, phone or projector from India or from abroad? Warranty issues aside, ET examines the price differences in four popular products to reach some obvious conclusions, – what should you buy and from where?
Text: ET Bureau

It’s a common dilemma, should you buy that latest laptop, camera, phone or projector from India or from abroad? Warranty issues aside, ET examines the price differences..
Read More
The iPhone is one of the most coveted smartphones around and prices do vary from place to place.

Apart from the shady practice of buying used iPhones that have been illegally unlocked – even the prices of officially unlocked devices can differ.

For instance, the iPhone 6 starts at Rs 56,000 in India.

The same unlocked device in the US is $649 ($40,000) and HK$5588 ($45,000) in Hong Kong.

The catch is that iPhone warranties are only valid in the country in which they are purchased.

If the phone develops any sort of issue, Apple service will not accept the product at all — even if payment for repairs is offered.

The conclusion is that you should just pay the extra and get the official unit in your own country.

In the case of iPads, Apple offers an international warranty.

As long as you buy the device from an authorised seller/reseller and official service is available in your country of residence — the warranty stays valid.

This means that even if you manage to save a few thousand Rupees on an iPad, it’s worth it!
The iPhone is one of the most coveted smartphones around and prices do vary from place to place.

Apart from the shady practice of buying used iPhones that have been illegally unlocked – even ..
Read More
Picking up one of Sony’s best compact cameras (the RX 100 Mk 3; one of the best compact cameras around, actually), the US price is roughly US$ 800 (Rs 50,000) while the India price with official 2 year warranty is Rs 52,990.

This is a direct conversion as per today’s rates and after adding currency exchange (or credit card) fees, the price is roughly equal.

You can, however, still shop for the official Sony LCD screen protector and the premium leather case.

With some of the mid-range and premium digital SLRs, the price gap starts to widen.

Take for instance Nikon’s D610 – a popular full frame (FX format, in Nikon terminology) DSLR.

With the 24-85mm VR lens bundle, the D610 retails for about US$ 2,000 (Rs 1,25,000).

In India, the price is Rs 1,42,950 with the same lens bundle.
Picking up one of Sony’s best compact cameras (the RX 100 Mk 3; one of the best compact cameras around, actually), the US price is roughly US$ 800 (Rs 50,000) while the India price with official 2 ye..
Read More
In India, most of the action in the consumer laptop segment is lower down in the price range: Rs 20,000 to Rs 50,000.

For the premium segment, prices can vary wildly.

The latest and much-talked about 2015 edition of the Dell XPS 13 (with the infinity screen, which fits a 13-inch screen into an 11-inch laptop chassis) starts at just US$799 plus tax (roughly Rs 55,000) in the US.

However, in India there is only one version of the laptop available (the top-end version), priced at Rs 1,28,990.

This instantly puts the gorgeous design out of reach of most laptop users in India.

If you're craving for this fantastic (and unique) infinity screen design, you have no option but to get it from abroad.

The warranty will probably not be valid elsewhere and if you buy from the US, you will have to carry or send the laptop to a US service location to avail warranty services if required.
In India, most of the action in the consumer laptop segment is lower down in the price range: Rs 20,000 to Rs 50,000.

For the premium segment, prices can vary wildly.

The latest and m..
Read More
To start with, you might not want to carry a projector in from another country because of two simple reasons: the size/weight of the device and because it attracts customs duties.

All other products can be carried in hand baggage and brought in duty free (regardless of value).

But there are other considerations such as availability.

In the US market, there is a much wider variety of brands and models to choose from, some of which are known for affordable, high performance products.

Case in point is the Optoma HD141X. At just US$ 600 (Rs 37,500), this projector offers phenomenal value.

It’s a compact, full HD, 3D projector with a 4,000 hour lamp life, 3,000 lumens rated brightness, built in speaker and dual HDMI inputs (with MHL for smartphones).

There’s nothing else that can even come close in terms of price to performance.
To start with, you might not want to carry a projector in from another country because of two simple reasons: the size/weight of the device and because it attracts customs duties.

All other p..
Read More
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Tech › Internet › Internet neutrality debate: Govt for non-discriminatory access
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+