Why do MPs shout their heads off?

In the heated arena of parliamentary debates, it's not uncommon to see politicians raising their voices. This outburst isn't merely a quest for clarity; it's a calculated display aimed at command and visibility. This article posits that such theat...

Incoherent screaming in parliament has a quality of its own
One question that is never addressed by any parliamentary Question Hour is: why do parliamentarians shout their heads off, especially when one of them is speaking? The mystery is not so much why MPs shout - family traditions may, indeed, be reflected in their public lives - but why they shout incoherently with no one able to understand what they're screaming. Is the whole purpose to merely interrupt coherent speech?

India is a society where volume equals validity. Our TV studio expert panels have merely amplified this parliamentary-cum-bazaar sales pitch trait into our living rooms. Another theory has it that vocal 'MPerialism' is a primal ritual, a kind of parliamentary mating call. The louder you bellow, the more assured you're likely to feel that you've made your point. No one ever deciphers what's being shouted. Only that a whole lotta shouting's going on. It creates the illusion of passion, urgency, democracy in full-throated bloom. Polite, coherent exchange of words, after all, could seem suspicious - too contemplative, reasonable, 'baat mein kuchh kala hai'. Let the records show not what was said, but that there was screaming involved. In any case, parliament is less about persuasion than performance. And volume is the only way of showcasing how much one can truly represent one's people, who can be suitably impressed only by noise.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › Just in Jest › Why do MPs shout their heads off?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+