Huang needs hearing, not morality lesson

Silicon Valley, including notable figures like Elon Musk, has signed a letter requesting Jensen Huang's reinstatement at Nvidia. However, the situation raises significant concerns regarding corporate governance and national security. Huang's repor...

ET Bureau

More than 1.65 lakh people, including Elon Musk, sign an open letter calling for Jensen Huang's reinstatement as Nvidia CEO.

Silicon Valley wants its emperor back. More than 1,65,000 people, including 'paragon of alternate virtue' Elon Musk, have signed an open letter 'demanding' Jensen Huang's reinstatement as Nvidia CEO. Their enthusiasm is understandable. The man who transformed Nvidia into the engine-room of AI isn't easily replaceable. But can corporate governance be conducted by popularity contest?

Huang's affairs raise 3 questions. One, national security - statutory barriers mean little if personal vulnerabilities provide alternative routes to sensitive information. Two, corporate discipline - a reported affair with a subordinate raises questions about conflicts of interest, unequal power and Nvidia's internal rules. Reinstatement without accountability would make a mockery of corporate culture. Three, adultery per se. This is distinct from the other two. Western Christian values have moralised sex through sin and transgression. Taoist thought, on the other hand, often approaches it through vitality, harmony and human relationships. Scholars like Robert van Gulik and California-born Taoist practitioner-author Daniel Reid have documented Chinese traditions that don't automatically equate sexual conduct with guilt. These traditions are hardly free of double standards. But their moral vocabularies differ.

Huang's obligations to his family (both his children work in Nvidia) are real. But they are not automatically matters for Nvidia's shareholders. The board must distinguish private betrayal from institutional misconduct. Neither genius nor cultural relativism excuses the latter. Huang committed his lapses in the US, under Western corporate rules and expectations, not in China, or in Teslaworld. This fact - 'Their house, their rules' - bears weight.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › ET Editorial › Huang needs hearing, not morality lesson
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+