Living in denial: When disaster becomes the new normal

How Indians have normalised severe pollution and environmental degradation, treating public health hazards as everyday inconveniences rather than recognising them as a disaster that demands urgent action.

BCCL

If you find bursting crackers noxious, you must be smoking something funny.

'We all know what a disaster is. Especially if we read a lot of disaster stories and a lot of catastrophe fiction. But what if the sense of confusion attendant on a disaster in a population was not attendant? What if the confusion, and the not knowing, was the disaster?'

I'm yet to dive into M John Harrison's latest post-apocalyptic novel, The End of Everything, that won him the Booker Award this month. But listening to him speak in an old clip about the book at Edinburgh International Book Festival shivered me timbers. One, because of the excitement of looking forward to reading a long-admired master craftsman at the height of his powers (Harrison is 81).

Two, because I suddenly stopped in my tracks, realising that what he was describing as science fiction set in a future England is banal fact in many parts of present urban India: the real disaster being people not knowing that they are living in a disaster.


Leading up to Diwali, and almost a week after D-Day, firecrackers were going off in Delhi and Kolkata, where it continued into Chhath puja, during various times of the day and night, in varying intensity. Obviously, I'm not daft enough to make an appeal to stop this S&M fest. That would be like expecting an angry mob not to smash public property and some shopfronts.

But what I find one-Spock-eyebrow-lifting fascinating is how we are inhabiting in a smog-mix of fatalism and derring-do, where not only are we fine with the poison that goes as 'air' for us, but we are actually proud of 'sucking it up,' in all senses. In the lobster universe, that would be like a lobster turning the stove on, taking its pants off, getting into the boiling pot, and selling it - to others and itself - as extreme jacuzzi.

Ours is a fascinating culture that has turned human physical discomfort and misery - including future suffering - into celebration. UP's wisest, chief minister Adityanath, was samurai-like about this mass slow seppuku, when he said, 'So what if [pollution] has increased [because of Diwali]? It will subside as well. Why are you worried?' He then moved into delightful whataboutery of no one complaining about 'those who have polluted the entire system through their corrupt deeds,' while people 'celebrating with fireworks for one day' are picked on, like some jizya tax.
ADVERTISEMENT

Then in UP's 'sister state' of West Bengal, MLA Papiya Adhikari claimed that bursting firecrackers would 'cure several diseases.' She went on to cite traditional beliefs that smoke from crackers kills germs and viruses. Yes, keeping an onion between your armpit can also cause fever, according to old school get-out-of-duty lore.

As far as I can make out, bursting micro-cardiac-arresting and toxic fireworks, despite knowing the misery it causes, has two broad justifications:

Don't be a pretentious twat Even in rapidly viksiting Bharat, we still find fellow Indians whining about encroachments on streets, level of hygiene in our food-making, or 'Choke de India' air quality, deeply entitled and prissy. Real Indians can not only handle all this, but they thrive despite all this.

Unless we want to become lily-livered and limp-wristed appropriators of 'first world problems,' we can be honest about realising that Swachh Bharat, like pollution in general, is an emotion. And it takes a special kind of chutzpah to revel in self-harm for the sake of boom and shine.
ADVERTISEMENT

We are like this only A variation - and rationalization - of the above: we're too deep into being what we are. It is how it is. Clean city air, handsome urban views and structures, lovely clean streets, well-tended parks - essentially, public outdoors made and maintained that even the wealthy could use - is something that exists abroad. Anyway, we have too many people here for all that, bhai.

Spitting on a pristine wall is considerably harder than on a filthy one even for the most uncivic-minded. For an establishment that has unofficially made seeking and weeding out dimagi disruptors one of its missions, surely, seeking and weeding out actual polluters would be easier? But then, to fix a disaster, you'll first have to know a disaster, even if it's staring right in your face.
ADVERTISEMENT

Disclaimer: I am a smoker. But I keep my smoke to myself - which has the additional benefit of keeping sane people away.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › ET Commentary › Living in denial: When disaster becomes the new normal
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+