Is gold getting cold, as is silver?

Gold and silver have fallen sharply from their January peaks, despite continued support from central bank buying, geopolitical uncertainty and silver's supply deficit. As of November 16, gold was down nearly 25% at ₹1.37 lakh per 10 grams, while s...

Agencies
Gold Prices in India
The festive season is traditionally a good time for precious metals. But this year, gold and silver have surrendered a substantial portion of investors' gains off their record highs in January. As of Nov 16, gold price stood at ₹1.37 lakh per 10 g, down almost 25% from its peak. Silver has fared far worse, losing around two-thirds of its value to ₹1.70 lakh a kg.

The correction is particularly striking because structural arguments supporting precious metals - central banks' diversification from dollar towards gold, the latter's safe-haven appeal amid geopolitical uncertainty, and industrial supply-deficit for silver - are still intact. But these factors are being overshadowed by near-term financial market dynamics.

ALSO READ | Indians splurge ₹72,000 crore on their favourite golden obsession to satisfy festive craving


What is removing gold's gloss? Higher-than-expected inflation has revived concerns that the US Fed may have to keep interest rates elevated for longer. Markets are now pricing in 90% probability of a 25-bps rate hike in December, up from 75% a month ago.

To be sure, this is an extension of the trend observed since the beginning of this year. US 10-yr treasury yields have jumped from just around 4% to more than 5% in 2026. This has strengthened the dollar, with dollar index appreciating over 5%.

Unlike bonds, gold doesn't generate interest income. So, rising yields increase the opportunity cost of holding the metal. A stronger dollar also makes gold more expensive for buyers using other currencies like rupee. These factors gained further relevance following the sharp rally in gold leading up to 2026, and resulted in speculative deleveraging.
ADVERTISEMENT

According to World Gold Council, central bank purchases during the first 9 mths of 2026 reached 675 t, up 6% over a year ago. As many as 89% of respondents expect global central bank gold holdings to increase over the next 12 mths, while 74% expect dollar's share of global reserves to decline over the next 5 yrs.

But de-dollarisation is a gradual process, not an event that guarantees uninterrupted appreciation in gold prices. Central banks can continue accumulating gold even as speculative investors book profits. Their purchases provide structural support, but can't prevent interim corrections driven by liquidity and interest-rate expectations.

Similarly, gold's appeal as a structural store of value doesn't necessarily mean that it will rise during every bout of volatility. During periods of market stress, investors may liquidate even safe-haven assets to raise cash.

Unlike gold, silver has substantial industrial applications, making its fortunes dependent on manufacturing activity. This has historically resulted in sharp rallies and subsequent steep falls, earning the metal its 'devil's metal' nickname. A similar drawdown has been playing out in 2026, despite a sustained long-term driver - energy transition.
ADVERTISEMENT

In fact, Silver Institute expects the market to record its 6th consecutive annual supply deficit in 2026, estimated at 35 mn ounces. But a supply deficit alone does not guarantee higher prices.

Industrial demand is expected to decline 3% this year, partly because solar manufacturers are reducing silver consumption per cell and exploring substitutes. China's falling demand has also weighed on silver prices. Global silver ETF holdings had also fallen 55 mn ounces from January, reflecting the unwinding of speculative excesses this year.
ADVERTISEMENT

Despite the festive and wedding season here, elevated prices have constrained physical demand. While value of jewellery demand increased 16%, World Gold Council reported that jewellery volumes fell 20% y-o-y in the September quarter. Bar and coin demand declined 40%.

The festive calendar has also complicated comparisons, with several festivals falling in the December quarter this year, against the September quarter last year. Dhanteras demand picked up when domestic prices corrected towards 7-mth lows, suggesting that consumers remain price-sensitive rather than indifferent to gold.

Rupee's movement against dollar, along with changes in import duties, also complicates matters for domestic demand. If global gold price declines, but rupee depreciates, or if import duties are hiked as was done in May, landed price of gold for Indian consumers may not decline as much.

For investors, the question is whether they are buying precious metals for short-term momentum or for portfolio diversification. The answer could make all the difference.

The writer is founder, Credibull Capital
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › ET Commentary › Is gold getting cold, as is silver?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+