India's tax uncertainty is like Delhi's smog: Everyone contributes, nobody takes responsibility

Tax uncertainty in India is exacerbated by ambiguous laws and slow decision-making processes that impact taxpayers. Government efforts to improve clarity have included statutory reforms and higher appeal thresholds, but challenges remain. The arti...

BCCL

Caught in a web

From my balcony in Noida during the smog season, the city dissolves into grey. Nobody created that smog. Each of us contributes a little, points to someone who contributes more, and moves on. Tax uncertainty works the same way. We keep looking for the author. There isn’t one.

Blaming the government is instinctive but tells only part of the story. This gov has shown clearer intent than its predecessors: a new Act and significantly higher thresholds for its own appeals. On Tiger Global, Supreme Court ruled that the Gaar grandfathering provision, as worded, covered any tax benefit arising after April 1, 2017. Within 11 wks, the rule was amended to restore the original intent. Governments usually legislate to undo what courts have taken away. This one reversed course to give back what a court had allowed.

Following the Leader
<p><br></p><p>Following the Leader</p><p><br></p>


A second author is the drafting culture. Every February brings amendments written to settle a dispute the department has lost. Each comes with an explanatory memorandum that explains the purpose and binds nobody. Some are labelled clarificatory and reach back to years already assessed. It is the habit of a machine that writes law the way it writes orders: for the case in front of it.

The courts can only decide the cases that reach them, in the law as it stands when they do. When the law changes every year and the dispute arrives a decade later, even a careful judgment settles less than it should. And there is us, the readers. Judgments are now read within hours, almost always as scores. A judgment read as a score invites an appeal rather than a settlement, and a forum that knows every decision will be scored has little reason to be bold. Commentary that complains of uncertainty helps produce it. The rest comes from the machine, and from the tax professionals.

A World of Contradictions
<p>A World of Contradictions<br></p>

Faceless appeals were the government’s design, with disposals pressed from the top. Yet, over 5 lakh appeals have sat at the first appellate level for years. The machine absorbed the instruction and kept its own pace. Inertia carries no consequence. A decision in the taxpayer’s favour carries every consequence, because scrutiny has turned from vigilance into presumption. The safe course is not to decide. Those reflexes are the smog.
ADVERTISEMENT

Now, the profession. Every ambiguity read creatively, every structure built to sit where the words of a provision stop, and its purpose begins. Tiger Global began as a structure somebody designed, and somebody signed off. The adviser who complains of uncertainty is complaining, in part, of the weather he helped make. The cures must reach culture. Six suggestions.

Make non-decision an adverse act : An appeal left undecided beyond a fixed period should count against the officer as a reversed order does. Until silence is as risky as a decision, silence will win.

Give explanatory memorandum statutory force so an officer cannot assess contrary to it, a taxpayer cannot structure around it, and a court need not guess at it.

A disclosure bargain: Let a taxpayer flag any unsettled position in the return. In exchange, no penalty if the view fails, and an answer within a fixed period.
ADVERTISEMENT

Ways to settle before litigating: An advance ruling mechanism that actually rules, on valuation as well as law: time-bound, binding on both sides. Mediation by retired senior administrators and judges. And advance agreements, like those in transfer pricing, for other recurring questions. This needs to be done on a large scale.

Better help for those who decide: Let tribunals and courts call on independent experts in international tax and valuation, as amici, not partisans. And give the government an advisory body chosen for independence, not agreement.
ADVERTISEMENT

A hard line where the line is clear: Aggressive planning should be labelled, fraud should be prosecuted, and so should those who design it. Until the facilitator faces consequences, clients will keep finding facilitators.

The smog over the NCR will lift only when we stop pointing fingers and recognise what each of us contributes to it. Tax uncertainty will clear only when everyone involved takes responsibility: the administration must stop treating caution as a virtue when it is merely delay; commentators must read judgments as reasons, not scores; and taxpayers must resist positions the law was never meant to allow. Reasonableness begets reasonableness. Nothing else does.
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › ET Commentary › India's tax uncertainty is like Delhi's smog: Everyone contributes, nobody takes responsibility
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+