India's consumption story has a missing middle: The widening gap between growth and purchasing power
Food inflation in India has surged to 8.94% in October, exceeding the Reserve Bank of India's tolerance limit. Additionally, rural headline inflation reached 6.63%, indicating a stark contrast between urban and rural areas. Meanwhile, the gross do...

Distinction between headline and food inflation is critical. For lower-income households, food and other essentials absorb a substantial proportion of available income. Higher food expenditure leaves less money for clothing, education, healthcare, transport, household durables and other discretionary purchases. Implications extend beyond household welfare. Weaker discretionary spending affects local retailers, small businesses, consumer goods manufacturers and labour-intensive industries.
India's aggregate GST collections have been encouraging. But GST Revenue Report for April-Oct reveals an important distinction between domestic activity and imports. Gross domestic GST collections increased by 7.4%, while gross GST collections on imports increased by 29.3%. After deducting refunds, net domestic GST collections increased by ~6.04%. In comparison, net GST collections on imports increased by 34.1%. Consequently, aggregate net GST collections grew by 12.6%, considerably faster than the domestic component.

This is an indicative comparison, not a formal measure of real domestic demand. GST collections have a different tax base from the CPI basket, and are influenced by tax rates, compliance, refunds and composition of taxable transactions. Moreover, domestic GST includes business and investment-related transactions, not merely household consumption. Nevertheless, the relatively modest margin between nominal domestic GST growth and consumer inflation deserves attention. So, it would be misleading to interpret strong aggregate GST collections as conclusive evidence of equally strong mass-market consumption.
According to JLL Research's Real Estate Intelligence Service data for Jan-Sept 2026, residential sales across India's 7 major urban markets increased by ~6% to 2,14,562 units. But homes priced below ₹1 cr accounted for only 28% of total sales, compared with ~38% a year earlier. Sales in this segment declined by 23%.
Sales of homes below ₹50 lakh fell by 36%, while those priced between ₹50 lakh and ₹1 cr declined by 18%. In contrast, homes priced above ₹1 cr accounted for 72% of total sales, compared with 62% in the same period in 2025. Sales in the ₹1.5-3 cr category increased by 54%.
The auto market presents a more nuanced picture. According to Siam data, mini-car wholesale sales increased by 86.3% during April-Sept, a welcome recovery from a depressed base, supported partly by improved affordability following GST reforms. But utility vehicles accounted for nearly 68% of passenger vehicle sales during July-Sept. Their sales increased by 31.4% during April-Sept, compared with 23.1% growth in passenger cars.

There is, nevertheless, an encouraging counterpoint. MoSPI's IIP figures reported 6.7% industrial growth in September, with manufacturing expanding by 7.6%. But consumer durables production increased by 6%, while consumer non-durables grew by only 1.4%. This divergence suggests stronger production of certain higher-value consumer goods isn't necessarily accompanied by equally strong growth in everyday consumer products.
MoSPI's latest PLFS reported that overall LFPR for ages 15 and above increased to 55.5%, from 54.6% in the preceding quarter. Worker population ratio reached 52.7%, while overall unemployment rate stood at 5.1%. But urban unemployment remained higher at 6.8%, compared with 4.3% in rural areas. Unemployment among young people aged 15-29 was 15.3%. Urban female unemployment was 8.8%, against 6.1% for urban males.
Employment must be assessed not merely in terms of participation, but also through availability of productive, adequately remunerated and reasonably secure work. The issue isn't whether affluent Indians should consume more, or whether premium markets should expand. Both are legitimate features of a growing economy. The more fundamental question is whether economic progress is enabling millions of ordinary households to participate more fully in the expanding market.
Ultimately, India's consumption story should also be judged by whether an ordinary salaried family, a small farmer, a casual worker and a young first-time earner have purchasing power to buy more than they could afford yesterday. That's the essential connection between economic growth, mass consumption and genuinely broad-based manufacturing expansion.
The writer is former adviser,Asian Development Bank
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.