GTA 6: Can gaming balance storytelling with spectacle?

The latest iteration promises a deeper understanding of what's possible within the game space. It has the potential to be a true-life simulator in every sense. But how much of it will be down to its narrative prowess, and how much because of bells...

BCCL

GTA 6 raises questions about the future of gaming, exploring whether its appeal will lie in immersive storytelling, spectacular gameplay or a balance of both.

The launch of the much-anticipated Grand Theft Auto 6 this week - 13 yrs after its earlier edition - paves the way for two potential paths in the gaming universe: one, storytelling via video games being taken seriously; two, video games being vehicles of ultra-spectacular possibilities.

The latest iteration promises a deeper understanding of what's possible within the game space. It has the potential to be a true-life simulator in every sense. But how much of it will be down to its narrative prowess, and how much because of bells and whistles is something that remains to be seen while streamers speedrun through the game.

GTA4 (2008) was a departure from GTA San Andreas (2004). The latter had a dark undertone of a storyline like the former. But in terms of mechanics, GTA San Andreas was also incredibly fun to play. GTA4 brought the kind of drudgery of life and reflected it in terms of its gameplay and mechanics, while also having a very gruesome story as well. What it did is create a sense of doom and gloom, not just in terms of writing but also in terms of play.


1
<p>​<strong>Worlds Within a Frame</strong>​<br></p>
GTA5 (2013), for many, was an apology to GTA4, in the sense that it said, 'Okay, here's a fun bank heist with everything that you can do - from playing tennis to doing yoga - with insane graphics etc etc'. What does GTA6 do with story? GTA publisher Rockstar Games has already shown what a game can do with both gameplay and story with Red Dead Redemption 2. Now, the broader question is: does GTA6 take the decision of just gameplay, or the story as well?

One of the foundational debates of video game studies of the late 90s concerned concepts of ludology - the interdisciplinary academic study of games, play, players and cultural contexts surrounding them - and narratology. This fundamentally boils down to an internal conflict: what is more important in video games? Its interactivity? Its 'play'? Or is it the storytelling that happens through the play?

2
<p>​<strong>The Art of Play and Spectacle</strong>​<br></p>
When we look at such massive open-world games, they're not merely entertainment, but also simulated proto-ethnographies of space, labour and social friction of a kind that are the culmination of an understanding of a society by a large number of people. Much like a time capsule.
ADVERTISEMENT

At the start, cinema was something lowbrow. But over the last century, we have seen a transition from something that is low, with its potential to kill off all other 'high' forms like books, to high (and mighty) art.

This is the moment of platform pragmatism, brought not just by games but also by other forms of media. We are now supposed to look not only at the bridging of high and low culture, but also at platforms and material infrastructures they are built on. That also asks us to think about the massive AI-shaped elephant in the room.

The point should not be to abandon it or glorify it but to engage critically with it - not just to think about AI through AI, or think about the environment only through AI, but to think about it in the context of what you are accessing and how you are accessing it.
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › ET Commentary › GTA 6: Can gaming balance storytelling with spectacle?
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+