BRICS should focus less on remaking the world order and more on fixing its gaps

Scepticism about BRICS has grown, especially regarding India's global ambitions, yet the organization plays a crucial role. Recent cuts in bilateral development assistance emphasize the need for reform within Multilateral Development Banks. Credit...

ET Bureau

Scepticism about BRICS has grown, especially regarding India's global ambitions, yet the organization plays a crucial role.

Finding new reasons for scepticism about BRICS has become a cottage industry. Around its New Delhi summit in September, commentators lined up to ask existential questions about the club, with some urging India to abandon it altogether. Much of the disappointment stems from BRICS' supposed failure to remake the global political order. India, in particular, is no closer to a permanent UNSC seat than it was two decades ago.

But such grand ambitions were always chimerical. India's BRICS presidency, which runs to the end of this year, won't rearrange great power relations. And it shouldn't try. The aim should be incremental progress in navigating a world that's fragmenting geopolitically, with an increasingly unreliable hegemon at centre stage.

Here, BRICS has a valuable, if unglamorous, role: giving the 'global south' a collective voice on issues that matter greatly to developing countries, but get short shrift in other international fora.


pic1
<p>Different hands, a shared task</p><p><br></p>
Development finance Here, the landscape has seldom seemed more arid. Bilateral development assistance fell by 23% between 2024 and 2025, the steepest drop on record. For the first time, all 5 largest donors cut aid flows simultaneously, the US by a staggering 57%.

MDBs are the obvious backstop. The reform agenda to make them 'bigger, better and more effective' is moving in the right direction, but too slowly. BRICS members, as both shareholders and borrowers, can push together for faster balance-sheet optimisation, wider use of hybrid capital and guarantees, and a larger voice in World Bank shareholding reviews. And for middle-income countries, which borrow from MDBs on near-commercial terms, BRICS can advocate for greater focus on transferring knowledge and crowding-in private capital.

Credit ratings Three agencies dominate the business, and their methods are opaque. Fitch rates France A+ and India five notches below that at BBB- (a single notch above junk). Yet, French government debt is about 118% of GDP against India's 83%. And a leading contender for the French presidency talks airily of cancelling the nearly one-fifth of debt that the central bank bought under quantitative easing. India, which has never defaulted on its sovereign debt, grew by over 7% in the last fiscal year.
ADVERTISEMENT

A review of the agencies' methodologies by CEA Anantha Nageswaran helps explain the puzzle. More than half of a sovereign's rating, his team estimates, rests on qualitative judgements of 'willingness to pay'. The largest single weight in Fitch's model goes to a composite of World Bank's governance indicators, which are built from surveys and expert opinion, with all the biases that those imply. Only 5 of the 18 assessments in Moody's sovereign scorecard are quantitative.

pic2
<p>Many faces, shared economic interests<br></p>
The remedy lies in greater symmetry. Just as rated sovereigns must open their books to agencies, agencies should publish their weights and privilege data over impressions. Many developing countries would earn upgrades, saving billions in funding costs (UNDP puts likely savings for Africa alone at about $74.5 bn).

BRICS can also nurture local rating agencies with potential informational advantages over global giants. If such agencies, using transparent methods and hard data, build a better track record than the Big Three, investors will follow.

Local currency markets Deepening and expanding domestic financial markets is a vital development task under any circumstances, helping borrowers to avoid currency mismatches that could plunge them into crisis. Geoeconomic fragmentation and potential weaponisation of the dollar-based system simply add urgency to the task. Progress here is real, if unspectacular. India has signed local currency settlement agreements with the UAE, Indonesia, the Maldives and Mauritius, and special rupee vostro accounts let trade settle directly in rupees.
ADVERTISEMENT

New Development Bank (NDB) is targeting 30% of its lending in member currencies. And IFC's local currency commitments have increased from $32 bn in 2024 to $48 bn today, a jump of more than a third in the past two years.

None of these worthy efforts will dethrone the dollar or get India an UNSC seat. But they are precisely the kinds of technocratic initiatives the BRICS group is well positioned to champion - partly because no other group of similar heft will, and partly because they don't divide membership into pro- and anti-Western camps.
ADVERTISEMENT

The unanimously passed New Delhi Declaration explicitly references MDB reform and local currency markets, while setting out new guidelines for credit assessments of small businesses. The point of India's BRICS presidency is not to midwife a new international order, but to make life in a fracturing world a little more manageable.

The writer is director, ICRIER
(Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.)
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › Opinion › ET Commentary › BRICS should focus less on remaking the world order and more on fixing its gaps
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+