Democrats should call Trump’s bluff on immigration
Democrats are being urged to push for bipartisan immigration reform after voters expressed dissatisfaction with the Trump administration’s aggressive deportation policies. While Trump has sent mixed signals on enforcement and reform, his appointme...

This past week alone, the president has veered from offering to work with Democrats on immigration reform to defending the promotion of immigration hard-liner Stephen Miller to White House chief of staff. Trump said targeting immigrants without criminal records “hurt” Republicans, but also said he’s not making changes. “There won’t be amnesty,” he told reporters. And that’s on top of his administration bragging about hitting new records for deportations. “Thanks to President Trump’s leadership,” Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin said, “ICE has been unleashed.”
ALSO READ | More companies may face action in H-1B probe, warns US Labour Department's Anthony D’Esposito
Given all the mixed messages, it seems highly unlikely that a fix for the nation’s broken immigration system is coming if Trump gets to dictate the agenda and the timetable. To be sure, a compromise would be ideal. But if anything is to get done on immigration in the next Congress, Democrats will likely have to force the issue, pushing legislation and daring Republicans to filibuster it or Trump to veto it.
Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer has proposed just such a strategy for making health care more affordable. Trump will have two choices, as Schumer told the Washington Sun. He will either sign what will be very popular legislation — “and he’ll know it’s popular” — or obstruct it, giving Democrats a better chance of winning the presidency in 2028.
ALSO READ | IBM's H-1B move, US tech layoffs: Why is it getting harder for Indians to work and settle in America?
The same could work for legislation on immigration reform (although it doesn’t seem to be a priority for the House so far). The key for Democrats will be resisting the temptation to go too far left, as some in the party want to do, and instead stick to policies that match public opinion and stand a good chance of improving the economy.
Polls show that most Americans appreciate the economic benefits of legal immigration. They want a secure border, but don’t approve of violent enforcement tactics that have left multiple people dead. Americans also favor admitting refugees and asylum seekers fleeing war-torn countries, and providing a viable pathway to citizenship for immigrants who were brought to the US as children, or have been living in the US for years.
Depending on the day, Trump will pay lip service to agreeing to much of this. As he told 60 Minutes last Sunday, killers should be deported, but not necessarily “good people working in a landscaping company or working in a hotel” and “paying taxes.”
But Trump has said such things before, only to backtrack. He did so in 2017, when he toyed with helping DREAMers — immigrants brought to the US as children — get citizenship. What had seemed like a more solid deal fell apart in 2018 after immigration hard-liners, led by Miller, got involved. Another one fizzled in 2019.
Trump has never been a particularly reliable negotiating partner. He breaks promises and changes his mind on a whim. With Miller in Trump’s ear more often now as White House chief of staff, Democrats are right to be skeptical that will change just because Republicans received an electoral beatdown for the ages. Yet Democrats seem to be moving forward anyway, however tentatively.
This past week, a group of Latino lawmakers, many of them newly elected to Congress, gathered outside the Capitol to publicly push for immigration reform. Specifically, they called on Trump and Republicans to support the bipartisan Dignity Act and the American Dream and Promise Act, both of which would solve a mix of problems with the current immigration system.
“I have very aspirational dreams and hopes for immigration reform. But I am also a pragmatist,” Representative Veronica Escobar of Texas said. “And as we have — as we continue to have — Donald Trump in the White House, and without a supermajority in the Senate, we need Republican support. So any comprehensive immigration reform must be bipartisan.”
Senator Ruben Gallego of Arizona said congressional Democrats had a responsibility to “protect as many families as possible,” even if that means “potentially cutting a deal with Donald Trump.”
A smaller group of Latino business leaders who also spoke at the Capitol were more direct and, dare I say, more realistic. They reminded the Trump administration that its policy of mass deportations has disrupted the economy, forcing businesses to close and workers to stay home, forfeiting their paychecks. This has been as true in the Rio Grande Valley of Texas as it has been in southwestern Kansas. And it had a lot to do with Republican Latino voters abandoning Trump.
In a warning to the administration, Benny Melendez, vice chair of the South Texas Builders Association, said to nods from Latino lawmakers: “If you want to continue harassing our communities, prepare yourself not only to lose your job, but get ready, because in the 2028 elections, these same communities you are now harassing will make sure you lose the White House.”
The reality is, Trump may never compromise on legislation. That shouldn’t stop Democrats from advancing a vision of what a well-run immigration system could look like, and explaining how that could ease everything from the housing shortage that’s driving up costs to labor shortages at meatpacking plants and farms that threaten to raise grocery prices even more.
If Democrats can present a plan that’s in line with what most Americans want, there’s a good chance voters will reward them for it — and punish Republicans for standing in the way. Just because the Trump administration is in disarray over immigration doesn’t mean Democrats have to be as well.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect the views of the publication.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.