Cummins' Sandpapergate intervention has reopened wounds he wanted to shut

Usman Khawaja's recent comments in his autobiography have reignited discussions about the Sandpapergate scandal involving Australian cricket. Pat Cummins' response to Khawaja's claims through a press conference was met with criticism from some pla...

AP
Cummins' Sandpapergate intervention has reopened wounds he wanted to shut
Sometimes, the right thing to do is to do nothing at all.

Pat Cummins’ superhero impulse of grabbing the Sandpapergate bull by its horns and muscle it into submission with a 68-minute press conference may have looked Marvel-esque in his daydream, sipping coffee in the comfort of sofa. In the real world, it triggered Newton’s Third Law of Motion: every action has an equal and opposite reaction.

In his recently released autobiography, Sabr, Usman Khawaja reawakened the ghosts of Sandpapergate. Rather than pinning the blame on any one individual, he argued that responsibility for the scandal should be shared by everyone who was part of the 2018 tour, including the coaching staff, not just three who bore the brunt of it.


"I'm not here to say he did this or that person did that, or he knew this, he knew that. It was more of a case of always, we are a team,” Khawaja told Antoinette Lattouf on the We Used To Be… podcast.

“As I said before, we win as a team, we lose as a team. We take that as a team. And I think if we genuinely do that, if there's an opportunity to do that, we can move forward once and for all.”

Some people, including Warner, backed Khawaja’s version. Others, like then Australia coach Darren Lehmann, questioned his intentions. A few, like Bancroft, chose not to revisit a painful past.
ADVERTISEMENT

But ‘Captain Australia’ Cummins was having none of it. He took it upon himself to nip what he called “complete and utter nonsense” in the bud, calling a full-fledged press conference after inviting journalists through a social media post to respond to what he described as “Uzzy’s allegations”.

Instead, he ended up antagonising those who had been reluctant to speak and remained on the fence.

For Bancroft, it proved to be the “final straw”. The man who “took the bullet for everybody” felt compelled to speak out after eight years. He said Cummins’ words during the press conference made him feel “angry, betrayed and alone”.

Bancroft then wrote a 4000-word personal account in a newspaper, directly challenging Cummins’ version of the events.
ADVERTISEMENT

Bancroft not only provided a chronology of what happened, he also named the players with whom he recalled discussing whether the ball was reverse-swinging enough.

“I walked onto the field for the final session of day two carrying sandpaper. When I collected the ball, I used it. The result wasn't immediately noticeable to me and I felt uncertain about how effective my twist and turns were on the ball,” Bancroft wrote in The West Australian newspaper.
ADVERTISEMENT

“I recall conversations with all the fast bowlers Pat Cummins, Mitchell Starc, Josh Hazlewood and Mitchell Marsh about whether it was reverse swinging enough.”

Cummins now finds himself in a position where backing down is no longer an option. He can only double down on his version of the events, which has come under renewed scrutiny.

“Pat’s position hasn’t changed in eight years. He’s been consistent and adamant from day one,” Cummins’ manager, Neil Maxwell, said in response to Bancroft’s first-person account.

His management team has now resorted to give it a sentimental twist, reminding everyone of efforts Cummins made in rebuilding the team in the aftermath of the scandal. But rebuilding a team and establishing the truth about its past are two different things. One does not absolve the other.

“Pat has rebuilt the Australian cricket team. That 24-year-old in Cape Town resolved to fix the team and spent eight years doing it,” Maxwell said.

The response is telling. This isn’t just a sign of him playing on the backfoot but also raises question over his holier-than-thou posturing.

Remember, the press conference was called at Cummins’ initiative through his personal social media account, not by Cricket Australia.

Was it arrogance or fear? Tough to tell.

But one thing is clear: in trying to extinguish the Sandpapergate fire, Cummins has only added fuel to it. It's difficult to see him coming out of this unscathed.

It would be a cruel twist if the scandal whose aftermath helped pave his way to the captaincy ended up costing him the job.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Sports › Cricket › Cummins' Sandpapergate intervention has reopened wounds he wanted to shut
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+