Rs 1,755 pressure cooker fails to cooks rice and dal even after 3-4 whistles, woman refuses Prestige's repair offer; consumer court orders company to pay her Rs 16,755 instead

A woman in Visakhapatnam approached the consumer commission after a newly purchased Prestige pressure cooker allegedly failed to cook rice and dal properly. The commission ordered a Rs 1,755 refund, Rs 12,000 compensation and Rs 3,000 costs. It al...

Woman cooks rice and dal in her new Rs 1,755 Prestige cooker, but both remain undercooked even after 4 whistles; consumer court orders company to pay Rs 16,755.

A woman in Visakhapatnam approached a consumer commission after a newly purchased Prestige pressure cooker allegedly failed to cook rice and dal properly, even after she allowed it to function for the prescribed three to four whistles. The dispute continued after the dealer collected the cooker for inspection and offered repair instead of the replacement she wanted.

The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I, Visakhapatnam, ordered the opposite parties to refund Rs 1,755, pay Rs 12,000 as compensation and Rs 3,000 towards litigation costs. It also directed the two sellers to pay Rs 21,000 to the Andhra Pradesh State Legal Services Authority (APSLSA) over allegations they made against the complainant.

Why did the woman complain about her new Prestige cooker?

According to the commission's October 30, 2026, judgment, Madhabathula Mani purchased a 4-litre Prestige Popular Jr Deep pressure pan from Khaitan's, The Home Maker's Shoppe, Visakhapatnam, on March 25, 2026.


She said she used it to cook rice on the day of purchase, following the prescribed cooking process and allowing three to four whistles. However, the rice remained partially cooked.

When she used the same cooker to prepare dal the following day, the problem persisted.

Mani contacted the dealer for assistance. She said she was asked to approach the service centre, which she found difficult because of her age and physical limitations. She also pointed out that she had purchased the appliance only two days earlier.
ADVERTISEMENT

On March 30, the dealer collected the cooker and issued a service receipt through Prestige Distributors. Mani said the dealer agreed to repair the appliance but did not initially agree to replace it with a new one. She refused the repair arrangement and left the cooker with the dealer.

She also told the commission that the salesperson had shown her a demo cooker that was already outside its sealed packaging when she made the purchase. She suspected that the same piece might have been packed and sold to her.

What did the Prestige sellers and manufacturer argue?

Khaitan's and Prestige Distributors maintained that they had promptly sent the cooker to the authorised Prestige service centre.

They said the service technician tested the appliance and sent the customer a video showing that it generated the required pressure and was functioning properly. The dealer also offered to accompany Mani to the service centre so she could check its functioning herself, they argued.
ADVERTISEMENT

The sellers said the manufacturer had offered a replacement as a goodwill gesture despite finding no defect. They alleged that Mani refused the offer and continued demanding excessive compensation.

They also accused her of threatening litigation and claiming to have connections with consumer commission personnel.
ADVERTISEMENT

TTK Prestige Ltd, the manufacturer and third opposite party, relied on the technician's video recording of the inspection. It argued that the cooker had passed operational testing and that no manufacturing defect had been found.

The company also maintained that its warranty obligations were limited to repair or replacement where an inherent manufacturing defect was established. It said Mani had not submitted an expert report or technical evidence proving such a defect.

What happened after the dealer offered new models?

Mani told the commission that the dealer contacted her on April 25 and said two or three new models had arrived, allowing her to choose one in exchange for the service slip.

She questioned why the dealer was offering a different cooker if the appliance she had purchased was functioning properly.

She further stated that on June 2, during the case proceedings, a Prestige representative named Kiran from Vijayawada called her and said the company had already instructed the dealer to replace the cooker. According to her, the replacement had still not been provided.

The commission considered these submissions alongside the invoice, warranty card, service receipt and the manufacturer's video evidence.

Why did the commission hold the opposite parties liable?

The commission noted that the warranty card recorded March 25, 2026, as the purchase date, consistent with the purchase invoice. However, it found that the warranty card did not mention the duration of the warranty provided to the customer.

It also examined the service receipt dated March 30 and observed that it did not record the technical defect or the specific problem in the cooker.

The commission considered this in the context of the opposite parties' claims that the appliance had been inspected and found to be working properly.

It drew an adverse inference from the conduct of the opposite parties and held them liable. The judgment also referred to Sections 84, 85 and 86 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, which deal with product liability involving manufacturers, service providers and product sellers.

The commission separately took exception to the sellers' allegations that Mani had connections with commission personnel. It said these allegations were unsupported by evidence and cautioned the sellers against making derogatory remarks about the functioning and image of the commission.

How much compensation did the woman receive?

In its order pronounced on October 30, 2026, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I, Visakhapatnam, partly allowed Mani's complaint.

The three-member bench was headed by President Dr Gudla Tanuja, with members Varri Krishna Murthy and Rahimunnisa Begum. The judgment was pronounced by Woman Member Rahimunnisa Begum.

The opposite parties were directed to refund Rs 1,755, pay Rs 12,000 as compensation for deficiency in service and Rs 3,000 towards litigation costs.

Separately, Khaitan's and Prestige Distributors were ordered to pay Rs 21,000 to APSLSA, Amaravathi, towards consumer literacy activities. This amount was imposed over their allegations concerning Mani's supposed connections with commission personnel.

The total amount directed under the order is Rs 37,755, including Rs 16,755 payable to the complainant and Rs 21,000 payable to the legal services authority.

The opposite parties were given one month from receiving the order to comply.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Rs 1,755 pressure cooker fails to cooks rice and dal even after 3-4 whistles, woman refuses Prestige's repair offer; consumer court orders company to pay her Rs 16,755 instead
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+