'Vulgarity is not obscenity': Bombay HC clears Air India crew member who was arrested for posting and circulating obscene material on Facebook and Orkut
The Bombay High Court has discharged an Air India cabin crew member from charges under Sections 67 and 67A of the IT Act in a 2012 Facebook and Orkut posts case. The court observed that vulgarity, profanities or offensive language do not automatic...

While examining the matter, the High Court emphasised the distinction between offensive language and legally defined obscenity. It said that vulgarity or the use of profanities alone cannot attract charges relating to obscene content. The court noted that the material posted by Sharma could be considered offensive or uncivil. However, it did not meet the legal requirements necessary to establish obscenity under the relevant provisions of the IT Act.
What did the Bombay High Court say about social media posts?
The High Court referred to the Supreme Court's position that vulgar expressions and profanities do not automatically constitute obscenity. For content to qualify as obscene, it must satisfy specific legal requirements, including the potential to arouse sexual feelings or lust.Applying this principle, the High Court observed that the messages attributed to Sharma might have been inappropriate or offensive, but that alone was insufficient to establish offences under Sections 67 and 67A of the Information Technology Act. The court, therefore, granted him relief from these charges.
What was the 2012 Facebook and Orkut controversy?
The controversy originated from internal disputes within the All India Cabin Crew Association, where Sharma was actively involved as an office-bearer. The association was reportedly witnessing differences between rival factions. Against this backdrop, another office-bearer approached the police, alleging that Sharma and a co-accused had published and circulated objectionable material online.The complaint alleged that the posts targeted AICCA office-bearers and certain political figures through obscene, defamatory and derogatory remarks. Following the complaint, the BKC cyber cell registered an FIR on May 11, 2012. Sharma was subsequently arrested and spent 12 days in police custody before securing bail.
How the legal battle continued for years
The proceedings continued for several years after the FIR was registered. In July 2019, the magistrate's court rejected Sharma's request to discharge him from the charges under Sections 67 and 67A of the IT Act. He challenged that decision before the sessions court. However, his revision application was dismissed in July 2023.Sharma then approached the Bombay High Court, challenging the earlier orders and seeking discharge from the offences. The High Court examined the allegations in light of the legal distinction between vulgarity, offensive language and obscenity.
Its findings ultimately went in Sharma's favour, with the court holding that the alleged messages did not satisfy the ingredients required to establish the offences under the two IT Act provisions. The ruling highlights an important distinction in online speech cases: content being abusive, insulting or offensive does not automatically make it obscene under the law.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.