Scientists found a new butterfly hiding in Alaska museum collection; it may have an unusual Ice Age origin

A butterfly classified as a familiar species for decades caught the attention of a researcher examining museum collections. Its unusual appearance and DNA characteristics led scientists to describe it as a potentially distinct species in Alaska. R...

Scientists found a new butterfly hiding in Alaska museum collection; it may have an unusual Ice Age origin [AI generated image]

A butterfly can spend decades in a museum without anyone questioning its name. That is what happened to specimens from Alaska, filed away as a familiar Arctic species until one researcher noticed that they did not quite fit.

Nobody questioned the label. For decades, a small set of butterflies from Alaska sat in museum drawers under the name of a well-known Arctic species. Then one researcher looked closely, and something felt off.

His name is Andrew Warren, a lepidopterist. In 2010 he was sorting Oeneis specimens at the McGuire Center for Lepidoptera and Biodiversity, part of the Florida Museum of Natural History, when he reached a lot collected near Tok, in southeastern Alaska. The label said Chryxus Arctic, Oeneis chryxus. The insects said otherwise. They were bigger and darker than the Chryxus Arctics he knew.


Also Read: 12000 years ago, humans carved giant camels into Saudi rocks. Scientists think they marked something vital

A label that had lasted for decades

Together with colleague Jonathan P. Pelham, Warren compared the butterflies’ physical features, genital structures included. Taxonomists rely on these when two species look alike. By 2011, their first reading placed the specimens in a different group within the Oeneis genus.

The search widened in 2015. Warren and Kathryn Daly went through the Kenelm Philip collection at the University of Alaska Museum in Fairbanks and found more specimens from several spots around the Tanana River. A few more were sitting in private collections.
ADVERTISEMENT

On the wing, the differences were easy to spot. The Alaskan butterflies were larger and darker, and their undersides were dotted with pale specks that gave them a frosted look. The team set them beside two relatives, the Chryxus Arctic and the White-veined Arctic, Oeneis bore.

Then came DNA barcodes, short genetic sequences used to help identify species. The Alaskan butterflies showed a distinct pattern, and their barcodes looked a lot like those of nearby White-veined Arctics. Add the differences in appearance and anatomy, and the researchers were confident enough to describe a new species. Their paper appeared in the Journal of Research on the Lepidoptera on March 15, 2016.

The name they chose was Oeneis tanana, after the Tanana River Basin, where the butterfly lives.

Could two butterflies have produced a third?

Naming the insect was the easy part. But where did it come from? Warren and his co-authors proposed that the Tanana Arctic may be the product of hybridisation. In this picture, the Chryxus Arctic and the White-veined Arctic mated at some point in the past, and their descendants slowly grew into a population of their own.
ADVERTISEMENT

For now, that is only a proposal. The researchers said more work was needed to pin down the butterfly’s taxonomic status and to test whether hybridisation really explains it. They also acknowledged that the study could not point to a single physical feature that cleanly separates it from the Chryxus Arctic.

The DNA calls for the same caution. The barcodes supported a close link with the White-veined Arctic, yet one short piece of mitochondrial DNA cannot tell the whole evolutionary story of a species. The authors called for more genetic work, including a closer look at its full genome.
ADVERTISEMENT

The landscape may hold part of the answer

The idea sends researchers back to Beringia, the ancient region that joined parts of present-day Alaska and north-eastern Asia. Some of it stayed free of ice through the last Ice Age.

The Tanana Arctic lives in the spruce and aspen forests of the Tanana-Yukon River Basin. Most of this area was never buried under glaciers during the coldest period, roughly 28,000 to 14,000 years ago. The researchers suggested it may have acted as a refuge, a place where related butterfly populations hung on while the cold reshuffled their ranges.

In their scenario, the Tanana Arctic and the White-veined Arctic stayed in Beringia, and the Chryxus Arctic moved south towards the Rocky Mountains. If the hybrid origin is right, the butterfly could carry a trace of how species mixed, and survived, as the climate changed.

So the find reaches beyond one insect. It gives scientists a way to ask how isolated populations, shifting habitats and ancient climates shaped biodiversity in the Arctic.

Also Read: A 20,000 year old pendant still carries the DNA of the woman who may have worn it

A discovery that began with looking twice

The Tanana Arctic, also known as “Lord of the Butterflies”, was not found during a dramatic expedition.

The clue was already there, in specimens that had been collected years ago and filed away. To make sense of it, the team went through museum collections and private ones, compared the butterflies’ anatomy, and checked DNA from related species.

It’s a good example of why old collections still matter. A specimen caught decades back can suddenly mean something new. Maybe the tools got better, maybe the comparisons got wider, or maybe someone just wasn’t sure the old label was right.

For now, the butterfly goes by Oeneis tanana in the scientific literature. The authors say there’s still work to do on where it actually came from. A museum drawer isn’t only a record of what we already know. Sometimes it holds the question that makes someone look again.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Scientists found a new butterfly hiding in Alaska museum collection; it may have an unusual Ice Age origin
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+