Pakistan minister who threatened to 'cut off hands' now shaking hands in Delhi for SCO meet; Brahma Chellaney criticises move
Brahma Chellaney has questioned the Modi government's decision to host Pakistan's Musadik Malik at an SCO forum in Delhi, pointing to the minister's threat to “cut off those hands” interfering with Pakistan's water supply. He said the move raises ...

Malik made the threat in June 2026 while criticising India's decision to place the Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance following the April 2025 Pahalgam terror attack. At a press conference alongside Pakistan's Information Minister Attaullah Tarar, he warned that Pakistan would retaliate against anyone attempting to restrict its share of river water.
In his post, Chellaney described India's decision to host Malik as a diplomatic contradiction, particularly given that New Delhi had originally invited Pakistan's National Heritage and Culture Minister Aurangzeb Khan Khichi to the November 20-22 forum at Delhi's Purana Qila. Islamabad instead nominated Malik, who has been among the most vocal Pakistani ministers criticising India's suspension of the treaty.
Also Read: Noida woman suffers burns during laser treatment forcing her to postpone wedding; consumer commission orders clinic to refund Rs 99,000 with 6% interest, pay Rs 55,000 in compensation and costs
Chellaney warns of diplomatic challenge as Pakistan picks water minister
Chellaney said the forum, initiated by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, was intended as an exercise in soft-power diplomacy, with India seeking to foreground its civilisational links and historical contributions in the SCO grouping.However, he argued that Pakistan's choice of Malik had complicated the diplomatic message New Delhi wanted to convey. He also flagged the possibility of the Pakistani minister making further inflammatory remarks while on Indian soil.
Malik's visit marks the first time a Pakistani federal minister has travelled to India since former foreign minister Bilawal Bhutto Zardari attended an SCO meeting in Goa in May 2023.
Chellaney recalled that during that visit, Bhutto Zardari used the foreign ministers' meeting and interactions with the media to accuse India of using terrorism for diplomatic purposes and criticise New Delhi on other issues. He had also made personal remarks against Modi at the United Nations months earlier.
Also Read: 300 applied, 6 interviewed: After 18 months of job hunting, applicant reveals just 12% of qualified candidates got an interview
Indus Waters Treaty dispute behind Pakistan minister's remarks
Malik made his controversial statement in June 2026, after India placed the 1960 Indus Waters Treaty in abeyance following the Pahalgam terror attack, in which 26 people were killed. New Delhi said the treaty would remain in abeyance until Pakistan credibly and irrevocably ended its support for cross-border terrorism.The SCO Civilisational Dialogue Forum is being held at Purana Qila from November 20 to 22. The inaugural three-day event will feature discussions on art, architecture, literature, languages, religious traditions and philosophical heritage, along with exhibitions and cultural performances.
Chellaney also pointed to another diplomatic decision awaiting Modi: whether to attend the SCO summit scheduled to be held in Pakistan in August 2027. The summit will coincide with the 80th anniversary of India's independence and Pakistan's creation, making the question of the Indian prime minister's participation a significant foreign policy challenge.
Disclaimer: The views and opinions expressed by Brahma Chellaney in his post on X are solely his own and are presented in this report with due attribution. They do not necessarily reflect or represent the views, positions or editorial stance of the publication. The observations and assessments are those of the speaker and should be understood in that context.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.