Noida woman suffers burns during laser treatment forcing her to postpone wedding; consumer commission orders clinic to refund Rs 99,000 with 6% interest, pay Rs 55,000 in compensation and costs

A Noida woman who suffered burns and blisters during a laser hair removal procedure in May 2011 has been awarded a refund of her treatment fee with 6% annual interest, along with compensation for physical injuries, pain and mental agony, and litig...

Noida woman suffers burns during laser treatment before wedding forcing her to postpone; consumer commission orders clinic to refund Rs 99,000 with 6% interest, pay Rs 55,000 in compensation and costs

A woman who suffered burn injuries and blisters during a laser hair removal procedure at a Noida clinic has been awarded Rs 1.54 lakh in refund, compensation and litigation costs by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Gautam Buddh Nagar. The Commission held Berkowits Hair and Skin Clinic and its representative, Seema Goel, liable for deficiency in service, finding that the treatment continued despite the woman's complaints of burning and was not supported by adequate medical supervision.

The complaint was filed by Komal Redu, a resident of Noida, in December 2013, alleging that she suffered injuries during a laser hair removal session on May 22, 2011, ahead of her scheduled marriage on July 9 that year. She had paid Rs 99,000 for the treatment, which was intended to remove unwanted hair from her back and legs. In its order dated November 4, 2026, the Commission directed the clinic and its representative to refund the entire treatment fee with 6% annual interest, pay Rs 50,000 as compensation for physical injury and mental agony, and provide Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs.

Noida woman approached clinic ahead of scheduled marriage

According to the complaint, Redu approached Berkowits Hair and Skin Clinic after seeing its advertisements and promotional material offering permanent hair removal and other skin-care treatments. She said the clinic represented itself as associated with Lumenis, USA, and accredited by the Gold Skin Care Centre, USA.


With her marriage scheduled for July 9, 2011, Redu sought permanent hair removal from her back and legs and informed the clinic about the upcoming wedding. She alleged that the clinic assured her the procedure was non-invasive and that the treatment would be completed within four to six months through six or seven sittings.

The clinic allegedly promised satisfactory services under the supervision of doctors and experienced laser technicians for a total payment of Rs 99,000.

Redu subsequently underwent multiple treatment sessions. According to her version, the first session took place on February 2, 2011, followed by a second session approximately a month later.
ADVERTISEMENT

Woman alleges burns and blisters after laser treatment

The complainant said she experienced severe burning sensations, pain and itching on her back and legs during the third session on May 22, 2011.

She alleged that despite informing the technician or employee about the discomfort, the procedure continued, with the staff telling her that such sensations were normal during laser treatment.

After the session, she noticed burn marks and blisters on the treated areas. When she approached the clinic the following day, its staff allegedly told her that the dermatologist would visit only on Friday.

On May 24, 2011, the clinic staff reportedly advised her to apply T. Brufen and Momat F creams. She alleged that the technician responsible for the procedure was not called to examine her.
ADVERTISEMENT

The following day, a dermatologist examined her injuries and prescribed T. Betnoso and T. Pantocid for seven days. According to the complaint, she was told that no other treatment could be prescribed.

Redu alleged that the injuries caused severe pain, sleeplessness and mental agony and affected her health and marriage preparations. She also claimed that she had to seek further medical treatment at her own expense.
ADVERTISEMENT


CMO report links burns to possible laser overexposure

The complainant further alleged that she approached the Chief Medical Officer (CMO), Noida, who examined her injuries and concluded that the burns may have resulted from overexposure to laser rays.

According to her complaint, the CMO directed an inspection team to investigate the matter and submit a report.

Redu also accused the clinic of failing to provide the promised permanent hair removal despite charging Rs 99,000. She alleged that the clinic refused to refund the money despite repeated telephone calls and emails, and that its representatives made false promises of a refund.

She further claimed that she and her parents faced misbehaviour and threats when they approached the clinic seeking repayment.

The complainant sought a refund of Rs 99,000 with 15% annual interest, Rs 1.5 lakh towards expenses allegedly incurred because of the postponement of her marriage, and Rs 4 lakh as compensation for medical expenses, physical suffering and mental agony.

Clinic denies negligence, says woman was informed about risks

Berkowits Hair and Skin Clinic and its representative, Seema Goel, denied the allegations and argued that the complaint was false, misconceived and intended to harass them and extract money.

In their written response, the opposite parties said Redu approached the clinic on January 2, 2011, and was attended to by Dr Shimpy Singh at its Noida branch. They claimed that all possible complications, including skin irritation, itching and burns, were explained to her before the procedure.

The clinic said she signed an informed-consent form and was informed that eight sessions would be required for the treatment. According to its version, the first session took place on January 2, followed by sessions on January 16, February 20, March 13, March 27, April 17, May 1 and May 22.

The respondents also gave a different account of the payment schedule, stating that Redu paid Rs 50,000 on January 2, Rs 25,000 on March 27 and Rs 24,000 on May 1.

They maintained that the laser power was tested before treatment and that the technician repeatedly checked whether she experienced a burning sensation. The clinic alleged that Redu repeatedly said she could tolerate the treatment and did not report any discomfort that required an adjustment in laser intensity.

The respondents further claimed that she developed superficial burns during the fourth session, rejected follow-up treatment offered by their doctors and demanded a full refund. They said the management offered to refund the unused sittings, even at a loss of Rs 20,000, but she insisted on a complete refund with interest.

The clinic also disputed her claim that the injuries led to the postponement of her marriage. It alleged that she had earlier attributed the postponement to her father's illness. The respondents maintained that the burns had completely healed by the second week of June 2011 without leaving scars.

They argued that the complaint was not maintainable in the absence of an independent medical expert's opinion establishing negligence and sought its dismissal with costs.

Consumer commission finds lack of adequate medical supervision

After hearing both sides and examining the documents and evidence, the Commission held that the complainant had established deficiency in service and negligence on the part of the opposite parties.

It noted that the payment of Rs 99,000 and the development of burn marks and blisters following the May 22, 2011, session were established on record. The central question was whether the procedure had been performed with due care and under proper medical supervision.

The Commission observed that the clinic's own version showed that the session on May 22 was conducted by a laser technician or employee. However, the respondents had failed to produce reliable contemporaneous evidence establishing that a qualified dermatologist was physically present and supervising the procedure throughout.

It also noted that the technician continued the treatment despite the complainant's reported burning sensation, instead of stopping the procedure and immediately referring the matter to the supervising doctor.

The Commission said the complainant's account of reporting severe burning, pain and itching during the session had not been effectively rebutted through contemporaneous treatment records, technician's notes or independent witnesses.

It rejected the clinic's argument that the complainant had repeatedly said she could tolerate the procedure, observing that even if such statements had been made, they did not absolve the clinic of its responsibility to monitor her condition and stop the treatment when she complained of pain or burning.

The Commission further observed that the clinic had represented that doctors and experienced laser technicians would supervise the treatment. Having accepted payment on that basis, it was required to ensure adequate medical supervision.

Commission rejects clinic's informed consent defence

The Commission also rejected the respondents' objection that the complainant had not produced an independent medical expert to establish negligence.

It observed that expert evidence was not mandatory in every consumer complaint and that the requirement depended on whether the medical issue could be decided from the material available.

In this case, the burns and blisters had appeared following laser exposure, while the CMO's report specifically recorded that the injuries may have been caused by overexposure to laser rays.

Referring to the Supreme Court's ruling in Jacob Mathew v. State of Punjab (2005), the Commission discussed the standard of reasonable professional competence and applied the principle of res ipsa loquitur to the circumstances of the case.

It held that the continuation of the procedure despite complaints of burning, the absence of evidence of immediate medical supervision and the delayed examination by a doctor indicated negligence.

The Commission also ruled that signing an informed-consent form did not give the clinic immunity from liability. It observed that consent to the inherent risk of burns did not amount to consent to injuries caused by inadequate monitoring, excessive laser exposure or continuation of treatment despite complaints.

Clinic ordered to refund Rs 99,000 with 6% interest

Concluding that the complainant had established deficiency in service and negligence, the Commission allowed the complaint and directed the opposite parties to jointly and severally provide the following relief:

  • Refund: Rs 99,000, representing the amount paid for laser hair removal, with simple interest at 6% per annum from the date of filing the complaint until actual payment.
  • Compensation: Rs 50,000 for physical injury, pain and mental agony.
  • Litigation costs: Rs 5,000.
The total monetary relief awarded amounts to Rs 1.54 lakh, excluding interest. The order was pronounced on November 4, 2026, by the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Gautam Buddh Nagar.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Noida woman suffers burns during laser treatment forcing her to postpone wedding; consumer commission orders clinic to refund Rs 99,000 with 6% interest, pay Rs 55,000 in compensation and costs
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+