Man books extra-legroom seats for 6 on Chandigarh-Mumbai flight, Vistara fails to provide them to 4; court orders refund with 9% interest, Rs 30,000 compensation
A passenger who paid Rs 4,620 to reserve six extra-legroom seats on a Vistara flight approached the consumer commission after four members of his group were assigned different seats. Although he and his wife received a Premium Economy upgrade, the...

Man books extra-legroom seats for 6 on Chandigarh-Mumbai flight, Vistara fails to provide them to 4; court orders refund with 9% interest, Rs 30,000 compensation (AI Image)
Khurana had booked tickets for himself, his wife and four friends on a Vistara flight scheduled for January 16, 2023. On January 12, he paid an additional Rs 4,620 to reserve six specific extra-legroom seats for the group. However, when the passengers received their boarding passes, four of them found that their assigned seats did not match the reservations.
While Khurana and his wife were upgraded to Premium Economy, the remaining four passengers were allotted different seats as the flight was fully booked. Khurana later learnt that the extra-legroom seats he had paid for had allegedly been assigned to other passengers.
Vistara acknowledged seating lapse but offered refund and Rs 500 voucher
Khurana raised the issue with Vistara, operated by Tata SIA Airlines Ltd, which acknowledged its lapse in an email dated February 9, 2023, and offered to refund the additional Rs 4,620 paid for the seats. He declined the offer. The airline subsequently offered him a Rs 500 voucher on February 20.Khurana then approached the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, alleging deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. He sought compensation for the inconvenience, mental agony and harassment caused by the airline's failure to provide the confirmed seats.
On March 2, 2026, the district commission partly allowed his complaint. It directed the airline to refund Rs 4,620 with 9% annual simple interest from the date of payment and pay Rs 9,000 as consolidated compensation for mental agony, harassment and litigation expenses.
Consumer commission says upgrade for two did not compensate four passengers
Dissatisfied with the compensation, Khurana appealed before the Chandigarh State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, seeking an enhancement.The state commission observed that upgrading Khurana and his wife to Premium Economy did not absolve the airline of its responsibility towards the four other passengers who were denied the seats they had booked and paid for.
It noted that passengers may select extra-legroom seats for reasons beyond personal preference, including their body structure, physical comfort and convenience. The group had made advance arrangements and paid additional charges to secure the facility, but four members were not provided the seats.
Vistara ordered to pay Rs 30,000 for mental agony, harassment and litigation costs
The state commission held that the Rs 9,000 awarded by the district commission was on the lower side. Referring to principles laid down by the Supreme Court and the National Consumer Commission, it observed that compensation must be fair and proportionate to the deficiency in service and the injury suffered, as there is no fixed formula for determining the amount.It retained the direction to refund Rs 4,620 with 9% annual simple interest from the date of payment. The airline has been directed to comply within 45 days of receiving the certified copy of the order. In case of non-compliance, the awarded amounts will attract 12% annual simple interest after the expiry of the 45-day period until payment.
The Economic Times Business News App for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
The Economic Times News App for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.