Kerala man gets RAC 44 train ticket, but Railways turns it into waiting list 1 and cancels it before journey; consumer court orders Rs 25,000 compensation

A Kerala passenger's train reservation was downgraded from RAC 44 to waiting list 1 after the Railways replaced a 3A coach with a 3E coach. His ticket was automatically cancelled before the journey, forcing him to spend Rs 2,339 on another ticket....

Kerala man gets RAC 44 train ticket, but Railways turns it into waiting list 1 and cancels it before journey; consumer court orders Rs 25,000 compensation.

A Kerala man's train ticket, which initially showed a reservation against cancellation (RAC) status of 44, was downgraded to waiting list 1 and automatically cancelled before his journey. The passenger had to spend another Rs 2,339 to book a ticket on the same train after losing the original reservation.

The Malappuram District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has held the Railway administration responsible for deficiency in service and unfair trade practice. It ordered the Railways to pay him Rs 20,000 as compensation and Rs 5,000 towards litigation costs. The commission did not hold IRCTC responsible.

Why did the RAC 44 ticket become waiting list 1?

Yadhukrishnan C, a law student at KC Law College in Mumbai, had booked a ticket through the IRCTC platform for Train No. 16345, the Netravati Express, from Lokmanya Tilak Terminus to Kayamkulam Junction.


He was travelling to Kerala because of an emergency. His ticket initially showed a booking status of waiting list 77 and a current status of RAC 44.

However, after the reservation chart was prepared, the status changed to waiting list 1. The ticket was then automatically cancelled by the Railway administration.

The original ticket cost Rs 1,819, including GST. The passenger received a refund of Rs 1,730 after the deduction of Rs 65 as clerkage charges.
ADVERTISEMENT

Yadhukrishnan said he had not cancelled the ticket himself and had received no prior information about the downgrade or cancellation. He was consequently unable to travel using the original booking.

How much did he pay for another ticket?

After the cancellation, Yadhukrishnan booked a current ticket for the same train on September 9, 2024. He paid Rs 2,339, including GST, for the new booking.

He argued that the availability of a ticket even after the reservation chart had been prepared showed that he could have travelled on the original ticket. He approached the consumer commission over the cancellation, the additional expense and the deduction from his refund.

What did the Railways say about the ticket cancellation?

The Railway administration said the train's 3A coach had been replaced with a 3E coach because of operational requirements. This led to the reallocation of confirmed passengers and changes in reservation status.
ADVERTISEMENT

It argued that RAC status was provisional and did not guarantee a confirmed berth. It also questioned the consumer commission's jurisdiction, saying the matter should be dealt with by the Railway Claims Tribunal.

IRCTC, meanwhile, said it had only provided the online booking platform. It maintained that berth allocation, preparation of reservation charts and automatic ticket cancellation were controlled by the Railways. It also said the Rs 65 clerkage charge had been deducted by the Railway administration.
ADVERTISEMENT

Why did the consumer commission hold the Railways responsible?

The commission examined the passenger's tickets, email correspondence and replies obtained under the Right to Information Act.

The RTI replies indicated that there was no specific Railway policy permitting the downgrade from RAC 44 to waiting list 1. Although the Railways admitted that the change followed the replacement of the 3A coach with a 3E coach, it failed to establish the specific circumstances that made the reallocation and subsequent cancellation necessary.

The commission also found that the passenger had not received prior information about the cancellation. It held that the unexplained downgrade, automatic cancellation and deduction of Rs 65 amounted to deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.

It cleared IRCTC because the company had no control over reservation allocation or cancellation. The commission found no evidence that IRCTC had independently imposed or retained the clerkage charge.

How much compensation must the Railways pay?

In its order, the Malappuram commission directed the Additional General Manager of Central Railway to pay Yadhukrishnan Rs 20,000 for mental agony and physical hardship, along with Rs 5,000 as litigation costs.

The order was passed by President Mohandasan K and members Preethi Sivaraman C and Mohamed Ismayil C.V. The Railways was given 45 days to comply. If it fails to pay within that period, the entire amount will carry interest at 9% per annum from the date of the order until payment.
Download
The Economic Times Business News App
for the Latest News in Business, Sensex, Stock Market Updates & More.
Download
The Economic Times News App
for Quarterly Results, Latest News in ITR, Business, Share Market, Live Sensex News & More.
READ MORE
ADVERTISEMENT

READ MORE:

LOGIN & CLAIM

50 TIMESPOINTS

More from our Partners

Loading next story
Business News › News › Trending › Kerala man gets RAC 44 train ticket, but Railways turns it into waiting list 1 and cancels it before journey; consumer court orders Rs 25,000 compensation
Text Size:AAA
Success
This article has been saved

*

+